Geoinformation Science Journal, Vol. 9, No. 2, 2009, pp: 36-44
36
ACCURACY ASSESSMENTS OF POINT CLOUD 3D
REGISTRATION METHOD FOR HIGH ACCURACY
CRANIOFACIAL MAPPING
Zulkepli Majid, Halim Setan and Albert K. Chong
Photogrammetry and Laser Scanning Research Group
Faculty of Geoinformation Sciences & Engineering
Universiti Teknologi Malaysia
zulkeplimajid@utm.my
ABSTRACT
Three dimensional (3D) laser scanning technology has found to be an excellent method for
modeling and measuring 3D objects. The 3D point clouds of an object can be acquired within
less than one second and stored digitally for pre-processing task. Complex mapping of 3D
object such as human faces required at least two scanning images to cover the complete facial
area (from right ear to left ear, and from hair line to bottom part of the chin) with optimum 3D
modeling accuracy. For complete 3D model generation, the scanning images are needed to be
registered and merged together. Existing registration method used corresponding features
between the two scanned images as registration primitive and finally 3D transformation
algorithm was applied to register the images. This paper describes the use of photogrammetric
targets, as registration primitive to register two scanning images of human face. The so called
“paper targets” were setup on the special design photogrammetric control frame where the
human face was placed at the middle of the frame during scanning process. The
photogrammetric control frame was calibrated using close-range convergent photogrammetry
with coded targets and high precision scale bars to determine the precise 3D coordinate of such
targets. The targets were also included in the scanning images and represented as point clouds.
Via laser scanning images, the centroid of the targets was precisely measured and the 3D
transformation algorithm was successfully applied to transform the scanning point clouds from
laser scanning coordinate system to photogrammetric coordinate system. The output of the
registered point clouds was displayed and processed in reverse engineering RapidForm 2004
software. The accuracy of the method was evaluated using shell-shell deviation analysis
method where the average deviation of the two scanning images was calculated. The results
show that the accuracy of the 3D registration accuracy using photogrammetric targets was
measured to be 0.129mm to 0.285mm. The reliability of the 3D registration accuracy using
photogrammetric targets method was also evaluated and the standard deviation of the method
is 0.10mm to 0.50mm.
Keywords: 3D registration, laser scanning, photogrammetric targets, point clouds, craniofacial
mapping
1.0 INTRODUCTION
Close-range photogrammetry can be defined as the art, science and technology of obtaining
reliable information from photographic images taken at less than 300 m object distance (Majid et
ISSN 1511-9491© 2009 FKSG