Production of Hydrogen from Glucose as a Biomass Simulant: Integrated
Biological and Thermochemical Approach
Sadashiv M. Swami,
†
Vaibhav Chaudhari,
†
Dong-Shik Kim,
†
Sang Jun Sim,
‡
and
Martin A. Abraham*
,†
Department of Chemical and EnVironmental Engineering, UniVersity of Toledo, Toledo, Ohio 43606, and
Department of Chemical Engineering, Sungkyunkwan UniVersity, Suwon, 440-746, Korea
Hydrogen production from biomass was investigated using an integrated biological and thermochemical process.
Glucose was used as a biomass surrogate and was first converted to ethanol in a fermentation process. The
fermentation experiments were carried out using Saccharomyces cereVisiae. The fermentation broth was then
used in aqueous phase reforming (APR) over a platinum-based catalyst. An economic analysis of the proposed
process demonstrates the economic viability of producing hydrogen from biomass using fermentation combined
with APR. The average production yield of hydrogen was ∼25%. The hydrogen obtained from APR of the
fermentation broth was compared against the yield from a feed containing 5% ethanol in water. While the
catalyst was stable for an extended time on stream during APR of ethanol, very rapid deactivation was observed
during APR of fermentation broth. Different catalyst characterization techniques, including XRD, BET surface
area, and ICP-AES, were employed to investigate the causes of catalyst deactivation. Although the analysis
suggested similar catalyst changes in both cases, and the exact deactivation mechanism could not be concluded,
these techniques helped to eliminate some mechanisms while suggesting other possible deactivation routes.
Nanofiltration of the fermentation broth was shown to remove the impurities leading to deactivation.
Introduction
Hydrogen is receiving increased attention as a future energy
alternative owing to the recent global efforts to reduce the
dependence on fossil fuels and the desire to reduce carbon-
based emissions. Hydrogen offers great potential as a clean
renewable energy carrier. It has the highest gravimetric energy
density of any known fuel, and it can be used in a fuel cell
with a high energy conversion efficiency compared to other
electrochemical and combustion processes. As fuel cells are
becoming more efficient and approaching commercialization,
hydrogen will become an important component of the alternative
energy profile.
Despite its tremendous potential, hydrogen energy has many
technical challenges. One of them is the production of sufficient
quantities of hydrogen.
1
There are many ways to produce
hydrogen including steam reforming or thermal cracking of
natural gas, coal gasification, electrolysis, and biological
production. Currently, nearly 90% of hydrogen is produced by
the steam reforming of natural gas and light oil fractions.
2
These
methods consume fossil fuel, and thus fail to address either the
long-term reliance on fossil resources or the carbon emissions
issues associated with their consumption.
Direct biological hydrogen production can be classified into
biophotolysis using algae and cyanobacteria, photodecomposi-
tion by photosynthetic bacteria, fermentation, and hybrid systems
using photosynthetic decomposition combined with fermenta-
tion.
3-5
The major problems in the biological hydrogen produc-
tion are slow reaction rates and the problems associated with
scale-up of bioreactors.
6
Also, even if most nonphotosynthetic
anaerobic bacteria use glucose to produce hydrogen,
7
usually
the resulting components after hydrolysis of biomass wastes
consist of various sugars including arabinose and xylose as well
as glucose, which are not well utilized by anaerobic bacteria.
Because hydrogen is not produced through biological pro-
cesses in sufficient yield to operate commercial size fuel cells,
biohydrogen technologies still need further progress.
8
Thus,
combinations of other well-established techniques have been
tested to overcome their limitations. Direct conversion of
biomass to hydrogen has been extensively studied in the past
few years. The most common techniques for biomass conversion
are gasification and pyrolysis.
9
However, the major disadvantage
of these processes is the decomposition of the biomass feed
stock, leading to char and tar formation.
10,11
Overcoming this
difficulty, aqueous phase reforming (APR) has been demon-
strated as an alternative technique for hydrogen production from
sugars.
12
In order to reduce the char formation and enhance the
biomass conversion, it has been suggested that the biomass
feedstock be converted to organic chemicals before reforming.
In previous work, researchers first reduced glucose to sucrose
through hydrogenation, before APR.
13
As an alternative, we have
proposed an integrated fermentation and reforming process. APR
has been chosen over conventional steam or autothermal
reforming so that unconverted biomass from a fermentation
process can still be utilized in a reforming process without
decomposition. Biomass feedstock will be first converted to
ethanol and organic acids in a fermentation process followed
by aqueous phase reforming of these converted products to
hydrogen.
The integrated biological and reforming process concept is
depicted in Figure 1, in which conventional conversion processes
based on fermentation and catalytic reforming are combined to
convert waste biomass into hydrogen. Biomass wastes from food
or agricultural processing can be converted, nearly eliminating
the cost of raw materials (or even possibly generating revenue
by reducing waste disposal related costs) and improving the
overall economics of the process. In order to be a practical
option for industrial and agricultural interests, an economically
* To whom correspondence should be addressed. Tel.: (419) 530-
8092. E-mail: martin.abraham@utoledo.edu.
†
University of Toledo.
‡
Sungkyunkwan University.
3645 Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 2008, 47, 3645-3651
10.1021/ie070895p CCC: $40.75 © 2008 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 12/14/2007