[Thalassemia Reports 2013; 3(s1):e42] [page 103]
Bone marrow transplantation for thalassemia: a global perspective
Mohamed Hamed Hussein,
1
Mohamed El Missiry,
1
Sadaf Khalid,
1
Naila Yaqub,
2
Sarah Khan Gilani,
2
Itrat Fatima,
2
Tatheer Zara,
2
Priya Marwah,
3
Rajpreet Soni,
3
Frederic Bernard,
1
Annunziata Manna,
1
Cornelio Uderzo,
1
Lawrence Faulkner
1
1
Cure2Children Foundation, Florence-Italy;
2
Children’s Hospital Pakistan Institute of Medical
Sciences, Islamabad-Pakistan;
3
South East Asia Institute for Thalassemia, Jaipur, India
Abstract
Even though severe thalassemia is a preventable disease, over
100,000 new cases are born yearly, particularly in the Middle East and
South-East Asia. Most of these children may not reach adulthood
because long-term appropriate supportive care is either inaccessible or
unaffordable. Bone marrow transplantation (BMT) remains the only
available definitive cure and success rates can be very high in appropri-
ately selected patients, i.e. low-risk younger children with a matched
family donor. In these circumstances BMT may be justified medically,
ethically as well as financially, in fact, the cost of low-risk BMT is equiv-
alent to that of a few years of non-curative supportive. This manuscript
will briefly review the current status of bone marrow transplantation for
thalassemia major with particular emphasis on a global prospective and
present the experience of the Cure2Children Foundation supporting
sustainable and scalable start up BMT programs in low-resource set-
tings. The initial twelve consecutive patients managed in two start up
BMT units in Pakistan (Children’s Hospital of the Pakistan Institute of
Medical Sciences, Islamabad) and India (South East Asia Institute for
Thalassemia, Jaipur) were included in this analysis. These initial six
patients per each institution where purposely chosen as the focus of this
report because they represent the steepest phase of the learning curve.
The median age at transplant was 3.9 years, range 0.9 to 6.0, liver was
no greater than 2 cm from costal margin, and all received matched relat-
ed BMT. A structured on-site focused training program as well as ongo-
ing intensive on-line cooperation was provided by the Cure2Children
team of professionals. At a median follow-up of 7.5 months (range 3.5 to
33.5 months) both thalassemia-free and overall survival are 92%, one
patient died of encephalitis-meningitis of unknown cause. No rejections
where observed. Neutrophil recovery occurred at a median of 15.5 days
(range 13-25) and platelet recovery at 18 days (range 12-27). Toxicities
included, fever and neutropenia (10 patients), CMV reactivation (9
patients), acute GVHD grade 3 or less (4 patients), hypertension (4
patients), mild mucositis (3 patients), bacterial sepsis (1 patient).
Median number of transfusions was 2 for red cells (range 0 to 7) and 5
for platelet transfusions (range 1 to 18). Median post-BMT hospital stay
was 49 days (range 33 to 109). No patients developed significant chron-
ic GVHD, one had a suspicion of malaria 8 months post-BMT and one of
tuberculosis 11 months post-BMT, both where treated empirically and
are doing well. The mean cost of a BMT and follow-up was around
10.164€ (8.952€ in Pakistan and 11.377€ in India), range 5.618€ to
14.604€ .. In low resource settings matched-related low-risk BMT for tha-
lassemia can be performed with outcomes comparable to richer coun-
tries and with a fraction of the costs even from the very beginning of
newly developed BMT units and by relatively untrained personnel pro-
vided a structured and intensive cooperation program with BMT experts
is provided. This observation may have important implications to
increase access to cure thalassemia major worldwide and for the start-
up of new BMT services in low- to middle income countries.
Introduction
Severe thalassemia accounts for a substantial proportion of child-
hood mortality, morbidity, health care expenses and donated blood con-
sumption in the Middle East and South-East Asia, were carrier rate
ranges of 5 to 30%.(1) In spite of significant progress in supportive
care which, in the best circumstances, may extend life expectancy well
into adulthood,(2) most patients in low- to middle-income areas,
where thalassemia is most prevalent, do not survive beyond 20 years of
age and the risk of blood-borne infections, primarily hepatitis C,
remains significant.(3) Even the definition of thalassemia major in
low-resource settings is not very clear cut, in fact, the standard criteri-
on of ≥8 red cell transfusions/year may not apply to a setting where
pre-transfusion hemoglobin are often as low as 3-4 g/dL and where tha-
lassemia intermedia phenotypes frequently occur; in these circum-
stance the term severe thalassemia, meaning inability to keep a spon-
taneous hemoglobin greater than 7 g/dL, i.e. the threshold below which
most centers would recommend a regular transfusion regimen2, might
better apply.
Bone marrow transplantation (BMT) has been shown to cure tha-
lassemia over 30 years ago(4) and remains the only definitive cure
with thalassemia-free survival rates consistently reported over 80% in
selected young low-risk patients with a histocompatible family
donor.(5) BMT has also been shown to improve quality of life.(6,7) In
areas where thalassemia is endemic, there is a severe shortage of cen-
ters for the cure of this diseases;(8,9) this is not only due to lack of
financial resources, in fact BMT is less expensive compared to long-
Correspondence: Lawrence B. Faulkner
©Copyright M.H. Hussein et al., 2013
Licensee PAGEPress, Italy
Thalassemia Reports 2013; 3(s1):e42
doi:10.4081/thal.2013.s1.e42
This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution Noncommercial License (by-nc 3.0) which permits any noncom-
mercial use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the orig-
inal author(s) and source are credited.
Parts of this work were presented at the
“3
rd
Pan-European Conference on Haemoglobinopathies and Rare Anaemias”,
Limassol (Cyprus), 24-26 October 2012.
Thalassemia Reports 2013; volume 3(s1):e42
Non-commercial use only