Volume 5 , Number 1, February.2011
ISSN 1995-6665
JJMIE
Pages 9 - 16
Jordan Journal of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering
Jig Design, Assembly Line Design and Work Station Design and
their Effect to Productivity
Adi Saptari, Wong Soon Lai, Mohd. Rizal Salleh
Faculty of Manufacturing Engineering
Universiti Teknikal Malaysia Melaka, Hang Tuah Jaya, Ayer Keroh, 76100 Melaka, Malaysia
___________________________________________________________________________
Abstract
This report discussed the effect of workstation design, assembly design, jig design and working posture on the assembly
of plugs. Two different designs of jig (vertical and rectangular) and two sets of assembly line design (one and two operators)
and two set of workstations design (sitting and standing) were studied to observe their effects to productivity. Design of
Experiments 2
3
with two levels of each factor is used to conduct an experiment for obtaining the most productive jig and
assembly line design. Two groups of workers were employed to assemble the plug in 8 different ways. Number of
replication is 32 for each setting and total of electric plugs produced by each group is 256 units. The results shows that jig
design have the most significant effect to the assembly time. Furthermore, the other factors: assembly design and
workstation design are also show significant factors to assembly time. However, interaction combinations of two or three
factors were not significant to assembly time. The most productive assembly line design which achieved the lowest assembly
time is the combination of one operator, with rectangular jig and work station design sitting. Meanwhile the working posture
of workstation design that provides the lowest RULA score was sitting position, it provided score 2 which is safe.
© 2011 Jordan Journal of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering. All rights reserved
Keywords: Jig design, design of assembly, workstation design, productivity, working posture.
___________________________________________________________________________
1. Introduction
An assembly line is designed by determining the
sequences of operations to manufacture of components
as well as the final product. Each movement of material
is made as simple and short as possible, with no cross
flow or backtracking. All operations performed along the
line are balanced. Design of assembly line plays the
important role in manufacturing which will directly
influence its productivity.
Previous researchers [13], [19-20] explained assembly
line is a widely used in production systems. The main
objective of assembly lines designers is to increase the
efficiency of the line by maximizing the ratio between
throughput and costs. Chow [5] stated that “A simple
process design criterion is to balance the assembly line
so that each operation takes approximately the same
amount of time. A balanced line often means better
resource utilization and consequently lower production
cost.”
Jig is a special tool used for locating and firmly holding
work piece in the proper position during the
manufacturing or assembly operation. It also guides the
tool or work piece during the operation. Jig is designed
to increase the productivity of operation assisting worker
to do job easier, faster and more comfortable.
Meanwhile, applying principles of ergonomics in the job
environments such as improving working posture and
workstation design as part of ergonomics efforts on
enhance productivity and safe working condition have
been extensively discussed by many authors [7] [8] [2]
[22]. The studies discussed ergonomics intervention may
improve productivity, quality, operators’ working
condition, occupational health and safety (OHS), and
even cost effectiveness. The areas of working
environment studied include workplace layouts, working
tables and chairs of appropriate height, fixing hand-tools,
better lighting and job rotation and also working postures.
This research studied several parameters afore mentioned:
i.e. design of workstation, design of assembly process,
design of jig, their effects to productivity in the assembly
line of plugs. Other variables such as equipment and skill
of worker which may contribute to productivity are
assumed kept constant. The hypothesis to be tested that
either one or more of the parameters or combinations of
parameters contribute to better production performance
in this case assembly time or cycle time.
Two designs of jig were introduced, one has rectangular
shape and the other has line or vertical shape or vertical
orientation. Two design of assembly were tested one
with single operator and the other with two operators.
Design of workstation was created by applying common
industrial practices in assembly line i.e. standing or
sitting position. For working poster assessment, RULA
(Rapid Upper Limb Assessment) analysis was conducted
to examine different workstation designs effect to safe
working postures.
2. Methods
2.1 Product Design
For the purpose of this experiment an electric product
was chosen as a case. This product was selected since it