Journal of the Neurological Sciences, 104 (1991) 197-202
© 1991 Elsevier Science Publishers B.V. 0022-510X/91/$03.50 197
JNS 03575
Regional differences in the orbicularis oculi muscle: conservation between
species
Linda Kirschen McLoon and Jonathan D. Wirtschafter
Department of Ophthalmology, Universityof Minnesota, Minneapolis, Minnesota (U.S.A.)
(Received 28 January, 1991)
(Revised, received 15 March, 1991)
(Accepted 19 March, 1991)
Key words: Facial muscles; Mimic muscles; Fiber typing; Enzyme histochemistry
Summary
The orbicularis oculi muscle is a complex facial muscle involved in eyelid closure. The central parts ofpretarsal and preseptal regions
of the palpebral part of the orbicularis oculi muscle in rabbit and cynomolgus monkey lower eyelids were examined histologically and
were analyzed for muscle fiber number, muscle fiber cross-sectional area and fiber type composition. Distinct regional differences were
seen in the muscle fiber composition in these two regions of the muscle. The pretarsal portion of the muscle, that closest to the eyelid
margin, was quite homogeneous and almost completely composed of type 2 fibers. These fibers were the smallest in cross-sectional area.
Type 2 fibers also predominated in the preseptal portion of the muscle, but this region contained between 10 and 20% type 1 fibers.
There appeared to be a gradient in muscle fiber size, whereby the fiber size increased as a function of the distance from the eyelid margin.
The same pattern of regional differences were found in both rabbit and monkey orbicularis oculi. Thus, there is a clear conservation
of these regional differences in these two species. While the developmental significance is unknown, the identification of this pattern
may facilitate the evaluation of chemomyectomy agents for treatment of eyelid spasms in humans and allow a more accurate analysis
of biopsy material from this muscle.
Introduction
The determination of pathological changes in injured
and regenerated muscle is important to our understanding
of the effects of various diseases or surgical and drug treat-
ments on normal muscle fiber structure and function. Histo-
logical studies of muscles are often directed at the assess-
ment of fiber size and composition in the affected muscle
after a specific drug treatment or disease state. One problem
with many of these studies is that the histological analysis
is based on biopsy material that is randomly removed from
the affected muscles even though it is now recognized that
muscles are not homogeneous entities. The extraocular
muscles, as an extreme case, show marked differences in
muscle fiber types in various regions of the muscles
(Spencer and Porter 1988). The masseter muscle shows
regional and compartmental specialization in terms of fiber
Correspondence to: Linda Kirschen McLoon, Ph.D., Department of
Ophthalmology, University of Minnesota, Box 493, Mayo Memorial
Building, Minneapolis, MN 55455, U.S.A.
Tel.: (612) 624-0409; Fax: (612) 626-3119.
type content (Bredman et al., 1990). Even the diaphragm
has different fiber type and size composition on the thoracic
and abdominal surfaces (Kilarski and Sjostrom 1990).
Precise knowledge of the fiber sizes and fiber type com-
position of individual muscle groups would not only aid in
our understanding of pathological processes, it would also
help in designing treatment protocols where surgical or
chemical manipulations of a specific muscle are required.
For example, botulinum toxin is injected into the orbicularis
oculi muscle to alleviate muscle spasms in patients with
blepharospasm and hemifacial spasm and is becoming the
current preferred non-surgical treatment (Scott et al. 1985).
Knowledge of regional differences in the orbicularis oculi
muscle may alter the location of botulinum injections in
these patients. Interpretation of supposed histopathologic
changes in the botulinum treated muscles may also be
obscured by lack of knowledge as to the basic anatomy of
this muscle.
The anatomy of the facial muscles is unique, due to the
fact that these muscles have a complex spatial arrangement
and insert directly into the skin. The orbicularis oculi
muscle is described as being composed of palpebral and