Numerical Simulation of Steel Quenching
B. Smoljan
(Submitted 22 May 2001)
The algorithm and computer program are completed to simulate the quenching of complex cylinders,
cones, spheres, etc. Numerical simulation of steel quenching is a complex problem, dealing with estimation
of microstructure and hardness distribution, and also dealing with evaluation of residual stresses and
distortions after quenching. The nonlinear finite volume method has been used in numerical simulation. By
the established computer program, mechanical properties and residual stresses and strains distributions in
the quenched specimen can be given at every moment of quenching.
Keywords hardenability, hardness, modeling, quenching, simu-
lation, steel properties
1. Introduction
Steel quenching can be defined as “cooling of steel work-
pieces at a rate faster than still air.”
[1]
Although very simple on
first sight, quenching is physically one of the most complex
processes in engineering and very difficult to understand.
Quenching used to be called the black hole of heat treatment
processes.
[2]
Computer simulation of quenching includes several differ-
ent analyses: (1) heat transfer analysis for computation of cool-
ing curves, (2) material properties analysis for computation of
microstructure composition and mechanical properties, (3)
thermoplastic analysis for computation of stresses and strains,
and (4) fracture mechanics analysis for computation of damage
tolerance.
[1]
Generally, in simulation of steel quenching, two essential
problems have to be solved. The first problem is to develop a
mathematical model of cooling and prediction of the mechani-
cal properties, stresses and strains. The second problem is to
establish the proper method for real heat data evaluation.
Simulation of any one process can be made successfully
only if all mechanisms of the process are well known and if the
appropriate mathematical methods are used. For steel quench-
ing, it means that the essential characteristics of the phase
transformation and mechanisms of stress and strain generation
during the quenching should be known. In steel quenching
stress-strain analysis, both strains due to thermal strain and
strains due to phase changes have to be taken into account.
[1]
Physical and mechanical materials properties, as functions of
structure and temperature, should be known in each moment
during the quenching. From these reasons it is understandable
that computer simulation of steel quenching is of interest to
engineers from a wide range of disciplines, i.e., material sci-
ence, thermodynamics, mechanics, manufacturing, mathemat-
ics, chemistry, etc.
Detailed theoretical and quantitative analysis of the process
that can be applied to a wide range of different types of quench-
ing remains unavailable. Although many attempts have been
made to develop theoretical models to describe steel quench-
ing, all the earlier work relied on simplifications that rendered
the analysis unrealistic. In particular, successful description of
steel quenching is not possible without a good theoretical ex-
planation of all physical processes involved in the mathemati-
cal model. Second, the real complexities of plasticity have to be
introduced into the model, but it is known that the theory of
plasticity is not sufficiently developed. Moreover, change of
physical and mechanical properties by temperature change
have to be involved in the mathematical model.
In the past three decades the Finite Element Method (FEM)
has enjoyed an undivided popularity as the method for solid
body stress analysis. On the other hand, the Finite Volume
Method (FVM) has been established as a very efficient way of
solving heat transfer problems. Recently, FVM was used as a
simple and effective tool for the solution of a large range of
problems in the thermoplastic analysis.
[3]
2. Temperature Field Change
Temperature field change in an isotropic rigid body with
heat conductivity , density , and specific heat capacity c, can
be described by Fourier’s law of heat conduction:
cT
t
= divgradT (Eq 1)
The heat sources that can exist during steel quenching are
neglected in Eq 1. Axially symmetrical bodies, such as com-
plex cylinders, cones, and spheres, can be described as 2-D
problems in cylindrical coordinates r, z, and 1.
To solve Eq 1, the finite volume scheme is used. The time
domain is divided into a number of discrete time steps, t,
whereas the space domain is divided into a number of rectan-
gular cells. Each cell is bounded by four faces with areas S
i(j,j+n)
and S
(i,i+n)j,
(i 1,2 . . . i
max
;j 1,2 . . . j
max
;n ±1), and it
contains one computational nodal point at its center (Fig. 1).
Linear distribution of the temperature T between neighboring
points is assumed. The discretization equation system was es-
tablished by integrating the differential Eq 1 over each control
volume, taking into account initial and boundary conditions.
B. Smoljan, University of Rijeka Faculty of Engineering, Rijeka,
Vukovarska 58, HR5100 Rijeka, Croatia. Contact e-mail: bozo.
smoljan@ri.hinet.hr.
JMEPEG (2002) 11:75-79 ©ASM International
Journal of Materials Engineering and Performance Volume 11(1) February 2002—75