#
Compact long-term recorder for the
transabdominal foetal and maternal
elect rocard iog ram
J. F. Pieri I J.A. Crowe I B.R. Hayes-Gill I C.J. Spencer 2 K. Bhogal 2
D. K. James 2
1School of Electrical & Electronic Engineering, University of Nottingham, Nottingham, UK
2School of Human Development, University of Nottingham, Queens Medical Centre,
Nottingham, UK
Abstract--Foetal heart rate (FHR) monitoring is a proven means of assessing foetal
health during the antenatal period. Currently, the only widely available instrumenta-
tion for producing these data is based on Doppler ultrasound, a technology that is
unsuitable for long-term use. For nearly a century, it has been known that the foetal
electrocardiogram (FECG) can be detected using electrodes placed on the maternal
abdomen. Although these signals suggest an alternative means of FHR derivation,
their use has been limited owing to problems of poor signal-to-noise ratio. However,
the eminent suitability of the transabdominal FECG for long-term FHR monitoring
has suggested that perseverance with the technique would be worthwhile. The paper
describes the design, construction and use of a compact, long-term recorder of three
channels of 24 h antenatal transabdominal data. Preliminary use of the recorder in
around 400 short recording sessions demonstrates that FHR records of equivalent
quality to those from Doppler ultrasound-based instruments can be extracted from
such data. The success of FHR derivation is, on average, around 65% of the
recording period from around 20 weeks gestation (although this figure is reduced
from around 28-32 weeks, and the success rates exhibit a wide range when
individual subjects are considered). These results demonstrate that the technique
offers, not only a means of acquiring long-term FHR data that are problematic to
obtain by other means, but also a more patient-friendly alternative to the Doppler
ultrasound technique.
Keywords--Foetal monitoring, Antenatal, Foetal electrocardiogram, Foetal heart rate,
Maternal heart rate, Electrophysiological recorder
Med. Biol. Eng. Comput., 2001, 39, 118-125
J
1 Introduction
DURINGPREGNANCY, the inaccessibility of the foetus means that
the only physiological parameter that can be monitored non-
invasively on a routine basis is heart rate. Fortunately, the
analysis of these data provides clinically valuable information,
and so the technique is widely used for both routine monitoring
and more regular assessment of foetuses considered at risk.
Currently, virtually all foetal heart rate (FHR) data are obtained
using the Doppler ultrasound technique. However, despite its
domination, it has a number of disadvantages.
Being an active technique, the question of the safety of
insonating the foetus is a recurring issue, with the bulky
transducer (containing the ultrasound generation and detection
elements) also having relatively large power requirements, in
addition, it must be held in position by an elasticated belt that is
found uncomfortable by the mothers being monitored and it
must be continually repositioned to ensure that the foetal heart
Correspondence should be addressed to Dr J. Crowe;
e-marl: john. crowe@nottingham.ac.uk
First received 19 April 2000 and in final form 1 November 2000
MBEC online number: 20013538
© IFMBE:2001
118
falls within the ultrasound beam's path. Also, only averaged
heart rate, rather than RR interval data, is provided
(MORGENSTERN, 1996), and it is well known that, under
certain conditions, erroneous heart rate patterns are obtained
(DAWES et al., 1990). In summary, although widely and
successfully used for routine bedside antenatal monitoring, the
current Doppler ultrasound-based monitors nevertheless leave
room for improvement in this role, and the technique is wholly
unsuitable for long-term ambulatory use.
Alternative means of antenatal FHR monitoring include foetal
magnetocardiography, phonocardiography and electrocardio-
graphy. The foetal magnetocardiogram (PETERS et al., 1998),
detectable using SQUiD-based magnetometers, enables the
acquisition of beat-to-beat FHR data and foetal magnetocardio-
gram (FMCG) waveforms from the 13th week of pregnancy,
both of which are of value in assessing foetuses with known
cardiac abnormalities. However, its requirements of costly,
sensitive and bulky instrumentation, which must be operated
in a low-noise environment by skilled personnel, render it
inconvenient for routine bedside use and obviously not suitable
for ambulatory use.
Derivation of FHR from the foetal phonocardiogram has been
demonstrated, but, although low-cost and simple to use, it
suffers from the breakthrough of non-foetal heart sounds into
Medical & Biological Engineering & Computing 2001, Vol. 39