Teacher Trainees’ Interpretations of Chemical Stability and Chemical
Reactivity
Ruby Hanson
University of Education, Winneba, Ghana
Abstract
This paper reveals teacher trainees’ over-
reliance on the octet model. It assesses the nature and
possible origins of these conceptions. One hundred
and thirty-eight teacher trainees in a teaching
university, who were purposely selected, participated
in this case study. Instruments used in gathering data
were worksheets and focus group interviews. Data
obtained were analysed quantitatively and
qualitatively. Records of the interviews were
transcribed after thematic descriptions. Findings
showed that majority of the trainees relied heavily on
the full shell concept model, which they imbibed from
teachers, and so confused the chemical reactivity
framework with that of chemical stability. This led
them to pay attention to irrelevant features to the
negligence of other authentic reasons in their
assigned task. The octet model also led the trainees to
reduce the relevant number of propositions that they
could have considered as possibilities in
differentiating between models. These findings will
add to existing knowledge among the science learning
community as they are relevant to educators
interested in conceptual development and students’
learning progressions. Remediation was
recommended to enable the trainees to form proper
mental models of the concept of chemical stability and
its application through innovative constructivist
teaching strategies.
1. Introduction
Chemistry, as a discipline, is found in almost all
other science-related programmes and vocations such
as nursing, medicine, pharmacy, agronomy, chemical
engineering, research and many more. Yet, students
shy away from the study of chemistry because of a
few basic, but abstract rule-governed principles [1]
that must necessarily be well understood for further
higher learning. Research shows that students struggle
to comprehend how chemical reactions occur, even in
laboratory practice settings where they are exposed to
tangible substances [2, 3, 4, 5]. Helping students to
relate among the macroscopic, and tangible properties
of matter, as well as their chemical compositions, and
structures at the sub-microscopic levels in a practical
manner, is a vital goal in the teaching of chemistry.
Students often experience learning challenges when
they have to deal with visualisations of these sub-
microscopic structural models such that they develop
alternative conceptions about them, and particulate
matter in general. They prefer to live in a world where
they can see and feel. Thus, when they have to deal
with chemical reactivity, where reacting species
cannot really be ‘seen’ in their microscopic forms,
they think of the phenomenon as a situation where
species merely undergo changes in their systems to
attain ‘stability’ [6].
Students’ perception of ‘stability’ is one about
matter that is at ‘rest’ and ‘chemically inactive’
because it has attained a full ‘outer shell’, ‘orbital’ or
‘configuration’. In other words, a system which is
deemed to be ‘stable’ would not be prone to ‘attach’
itself or be ‘involved’ in further chemical reaction.
Students perceive the stability of compounds as the
need of atoms to fill their ‘electron shells’; that is, the
full electron shell configuration or octet model [1].
This suggests that teachers must provide opportunities
through practice, for learners to acquire scientific
knowledge alongside their own activities through
purposeful interactive discussions. They must create
situations that can enable learners to apply other
acquired knowledge to reinforce new knowledge.
This would enable them to hold discussions and
reflect on their discursive discourses in a minimal
corrective and crosscutting environment [7].
Students in the high school exhibit in their answers
to questions on chemical stability that chemical
species with octet or full outer shell presentations are
more stable than those with other configurations.
Species with octet presentations actually tend to
dominate in discussions that concern molecules, ionic
lattices, and metallic lattices [6]. Students therefore
extend this idea to believe that species with structures
such as Mg
6-
and Na
7-
all carry the octet and so are
stable, without due consideration to feasibility on the
basis of thermodynamic requirements. It must be
noted that the octet framework has pedagogic values
as it could be used to explain how some common
alternative conceptions are epistemologically related.
Chemical stability is a concept that describes the
tendency of a chemical system to ‘resist’ change due
to its thermodynamic stability. In terms of energy
factors, what this implies is that a system will
preferably be in its lowest energy state with its
International Journal for Cross-Disciplinary Subjects in Education (IJCDSE), Volume 9, Issue 4, December 2018
Copyright © 2018, Infonomics Society 3906