Touyz and Nassani. Int J Oral Dent Health 2018, 4:061
Volume 4 | Issue 2
DOI: 10.23937/2469-5734/1510061
Citaton: Touyz LZG, Nassani LM (2018) Acidity and Dental Erosion from Apple- and Grape-Juice (An in
vitro and in vivo Report). Int J Oral Dent Health 4:061. doi.org/10.23937/2469-5734/1510061
Accepted: September 15, 2018: Published: September 17, 2018
Copyright: © 2018 Touyz LZG, et al. This is an open-access artcle distributed under the terms of the
Creatve Commons Atributon License, which permits unrestricted use, distributon, and reproducton
in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
• Page 1 of 7 • Touyz and Nassani. Int J Oral Dent Health 2018, 4:061
Open Access
ISSN: 2469-5734
International Journal of
Oral and Dental Health
Acidity and Dental Erosion from Apple- and Grape-Juice (An in
vitro and in vivo Report)
Louis ZG Touyz
*
and Leonardo M Nassani
McGill University, Canada
Introducton
Acidic drinks and food are consumed worldwide
for a long tme and presumed to be innocuous to good
health and teeth [1]. Acidic drinks and food do afect
teeth, and chronic repeated regular consumpton ex-
posure will contribute to the causes of dental ravages
(in the form of dental abrasion, atriton, erosion and
caries) [2]. Acids are sourced in the drinks, but also af-
ter drinking them, more acid is produced from oral bac-
terial plaques catabolizing mono- and disaccharides as
fermentable sugars in the drinks [3]. Intra-orally, whole
stmulated human saliva slowly neutralizes and/or buf-
fers ingested acid beverages [3,4]. Afer swallowing a
bolus of acid beverage, the intra-oral acidity (pH = 7.00)
drops to pH = 4 or lower, within 3 to 5 minutes [4]. Oral
bioflm with acidogenic bacterial acton on fermentable
carbohydrates (monosaccharides like glucose and fruc-
tose; Disaccharides like maltose and sucrose) also lower
the pH to below pH = 4. Intra-oral pH takes about 25 to
30 minutes to eliminate the acid environment, as fur-
ther stmulated-saliva neutralizes any residual acid [4].
The acknowledged critcal pH to dissolve hydroxyapatte
is pH = 5.5 [5]. The major Ca-crystal in teeth is hydroxy-
apatte, which is structurally composed of calcium-de-
fcient carbonated hydroxyapatte. Consequently, the
dental hydroxyapatte crystals are more vulnerable to
decalcifcaton in acid media [5]. Frequent regular ex-
posure to acidity from drinks modifes intra-oral pH to
below the critcal pH (pH = 5.5). At pH 5.5 chemical dis-
soluton of calcium from dental hydroxyapatte occurs.
Keeping the pH low at pH, < pH = 5.5, promotes mor-
dant development of ravages initated and developing
from decalcifcaton. Not only is the acidity and buf-
ReseaRch aRTicLe
Abstract
Introduction: Dental erosion from acid drinks is known; in
vitro with in vivo evidence that apple and grape juices cause
erosion is rare.
Aim: i) To test acidity (pH and buffering capacity) in vitro; ii)
And assess if these juices leach calcium from teeth in vivo.
Methodology: First: Six commercially available potable ap-
ple and grape juices were measured (six times each drink)
for pH and buffering using 0.5 Molar NaOH with a Mettler
DL 25 Automatic Titrator. The apple and grape juices were
measured separately, using a 50 mL bolus for measures,
6 times for each. Second: Two volunteer cohorts; (One ful-
ly dentate WITH TEETH (mean age 20, M:F 6:6, n = 12)
the second edentulous WITHOUT TEETH (mean age 61,
M:F 6:6, n = 12), were used to swish with 50 mL aliquots
of Apple and/or Grape juices for 30 seconds. Each sample
was analyzed six times with Inductively Coupled Plasma
with Optical Emission Spectroscopy (ICP-OES) for Calci-
um, and Phosphorous. Juices from source were analyzed
for Calcium, and Phosphorous, and post-swish expectorate
samples were analyzed for Calcium and Phosphorous. Data
were analyzed ‘blind’ by technicians unaware of the source
of procured samples.
Results: Analysis reveals apple and grape juices have pH
below 5.5. Statistics consistently show signifcant (p < 0.01
Student-t paired data) increases in Calcium and Phospho-
rous leeched from dentate (WITH TEETH) subjects after
swishing with apple and grape juices tested. Results pro-
vide strong evidence that rinsing with Apple or Grape juices
will erode teeth. Grape is more erosive than apple juice.
Conclusion: Apple and grape juices have acidity below critical
pH 5.5; Both have strong buffering capacities and will decalcify
teeth by erosion, when exposed to these drinks in diets.
Keywords
Acid, Apple juice, Buffering, Calcium, Dental-erosion, Drinks,
Critical pH, Grape juice, Hydroxyapatite, Phosphorous, Tooth
destruction
*Corresponding author: Louis ZG Touyz, Professor, McGill University, Canada
Check for
updates