Analytical Estimation of Packet Delays in
Relay-based IMT-advanced Networks
Daniel C. Schultz, Ralf Pabst, Bernhard Walke
RWTH Aachen University, Faculty 6, Chair of Communication Networks (ComNets), Aachen, Germany
e-mail: {dcs|pab|walke}@comnets.rwth-aachen.de
Abstract— The paper shows that relays as inherent technology
of IMT-Advanced system can provide low delays as required for
future multi-media services. The results shown prove that the
proposed relaying scheme is able to keep relay requirements on
the air interface and to support delay sensitive high interactive
services. The analytical results are validated by system level
simulations, which show that the relay might become even
more important for real scenarios in order to connect the User
Terminal (UT) on the uplink.
I. I NTRODUCTION
Fourth-Generation (4G) radio system such as investigated
in the EU funded IST WINNER project aim at the provision
of ubiquitous broadband access for nomadic users.
It is well known that the range of a 4G broadband radio
interface will be limited by the high attenuation at the envis-
aged carrier frequencies around 2.4 GHz and beyond 3.4 GHz
as identified by the World Radiocommunication Conference
(WRC) 2007. Further the rather limited amount of spec-
trum identified for broadband radio communication will force
mobile network operator to deploy an increased number of
site with limited transmission power owing to in order to
achieve the necessary capacities per area element especially
in densely populated urban areas. Fixed layer-2 Relay Node
(RN) appear to be the most promising technology to overcome
the unfavorable radio propagation conditions and bring the
capacity available at the Base Station (BS) into the area cost
efficiently [1][2].
Relays will be cost efficient due to their deployment flex-
ibility and the missing fixed, either by cable, fibre wire or
microwave, backbone connection. Thus they provide the opti-
mal means for initial network roll out of broadband wireless
systems.
On the other hand RNs need extra radio resource to connect
to the backbone network. That these resources are justified in
terms of capacity has been proven in several papers [3]. Next
to the achievable throughput, delay is an important Quality of
Service (QoS) measure for future broadband internet services.
To achieve a good insight in the delay characteristics the
Complementary Distribution Function (CDF) of delay in a
relay based OFDMA system will be determined.
The basis for the analytical delay calculation will be the
WWI New Radio (WINNER) Medium Access Control (MAC)
super frame as briefly introduced in the following section. In
Section III for the delay calculation in MAC frame based
Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiple Access (OFDMA)
systems will be derived and calculated analytically. In Sec-
tion IV the calculated results are validated by means of system
level simulations.
II. WINNER MAC SUPER- FRAME STRUCTURE
In the EU funded WINNER project an OFDMA based MAC
frame has been developed (for further details see [4] and [5]).
The WINNER MAC frame concepts has large similarities with
the currently developed 3rd Generation Partnership Program
(3GPP) Long Term Evolution (LTE) OFDMA protocol as well
as with the approach followed be mobile WiMax.
Figure 1 for the Time Division Duplex (TDD) mode the
super frame consists of a set of eight sub-frames. Each sub-
frame is further divided into an Downlink (DL) and an Uplink
(UL) slot. In the configuration assumed for this paper each
slot consists of 15 OFDM symbols and is 0.3372 ms plus
8.4 μs duplex guard time long. resulting in a MAC frame
duration of 0,6912 ms. The frames in the Frequency Division
Duplex (FDD) mode are of similar length, but subdivided in
the frequency domain for UL and DL operation.
III. DELAY CHARACTERISTICS OF THE TDD MAC
SUPER- FRAME
To achieve a good insight in the delay characteristics the
CDF of delay will be determined. To better classify the results
for the multi-hop scenario the results for the 1-hop scenario
will be presented firstly as reference.
A. One hop Delay TDD
Figure 2 shows an extract of the investigated MAC Super
Frame (SF), which is composed of a number of MAC Frames
each again subdivided into DL and UL phase.
For the investigation of delay characteristics the traffic flows
are not fully loaded in order to avoid an impact of scheduling
strategies and buffer waiting times.
The calculation is based on a given constant packet arrival
rate with equidistant packet interarrival times t
DL−Rate
and
t
UL−Rate
for the DL and UL direction respectively.
The total delay t
DL−Delay
(i) of packet i on the DL is
calculated as follows:
t
DL−Delay
(i)= t
DL−W ait
(i)+ t
DL−trans
(i)+
+p
ret−SH
∗ t
ret−SH
(1)
with the waiting time
t
DL−W ait
(i)=(n − i) ∗ t
DL−Rate
(2)
978-1-4244-1645-5/08/$25.00 ©2008 IEEE 2411