Universal Journal of Management 5(6): 278-290, 2017 http://www.hrpub.org
DOI: 10.13189/ujm.2017.050603
Achieving a Sustained Competitive Advantage in the
South African Telecommunications Sector
Mfanasibili Ngwenya
Graduate School of Technology Management, Faculty of Engineering,
the Built Environment and Information Technology, University of Pretoria, South Africa
Copyright©2017 by authors, all rights reserved. Authors agree that this article remains permanently open access under the
terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0 International License
Abstract The sustainability of South African
telecommunications companies is under threat. Such threats
are as a result new regulations that allowed influx of new
entrant in the form of ISPs (Internet Service Providers) and
the emergent of over-the-top (OTT) applications in recent
years. This research seeks to understand the factors that
influence a sustained competitive advantage despite all the
challenges in the telecommunications industry in South
Africa. The research explained the relationship that exist
between service quality and sustained competitive advantage
as well as the relationship that exist between intellectual
capital and sustained competitive advantage. The study
looked at the influence from both an internal perspective and
external perspective. The internal perspective analysed the
three constructs that make up intellectual capital namely;
human capital, structural capital and relational capital. The
external perspective used the SERVQUAL model to analyse
how customers perceive services they expect to get from the
telco providers and how they perceive the services after an
encounter with the telco provider. The SERVQUAL model
looks at five constructs of service quality namely; tangibility,
reliability, responsiveness, assurance and empathy. The
results of the study show that in the telco industry, relational
capital is the most important dimension of intellectual capital
followed by human capital, with structural capital coming up
last. On the service quality variable, the research shows that
customers see assurance as the most important dimension of
service quality. With this in mind, the telco companies need
to focus on their relational capital and human capital which
includes customers and suppliers. They also need to focus on
the assurance and responsiveness part of service quality.
These variables will then influence future behaviour of
customers (external view) as well allow employees to forge
relationships that are long lasting and develop skills
continuously (internal view). These dimensions are critical
for the telco providers to achieve a sustained competitive
advantage.
Keywords Service Quality, SERVQUAL, Competitive
Advantage, Intellectual Capital, Relational Capital,
Structural Capital, Human Capital, Tangibility, Assurance,
Responsiveness, Reliability, Empathy
1. Introduction
The sustainability of most companies remains under threat
unless conscious steps are taken by management to remain
relevant. This is especially true in the telecommunications
industry where information moves at the speed of light from
one part of the world to any destination, and technological
changes happen at the blink of an eye. The over-the-top
(OTT) applications have increased tremendously in recent
years with the introduction of smart phones and tablets. An
OTT application is any application or service that provides a
product over the Internet and bypasses traditional ways.
Services that come over-the-top are most typically related to
media and communication and are more often than not lower
in cost than the traditional methods of delivery. The South
African telecommunications sector is not immune to these
challenges. Other challenges are caused by changes in
regulations, entry of new players, and more disruptive
innovations. This kind of competition comes with disruptive
innovations in a sense that such innovations threaten
traditional revenue streams of telco companies.
This research attempts to answer the effect of intellectual
capital and service quality to sustained competitive
advantage despite the challenges mentioned above. The
dimensions that make up intellectual capital are examined
and the most influential dimension is determined. On the
other hand, the five dimensions that contribute to service
quality (SQ) are discussed and the most significant
applicable in the telecommunications industry in South
Africa from a customer perspective is tested. The study
assumes that a combination of superior intellectual capital
(IC) of a company and great service should lead to
sustainable competitive advantage. However, the study also
takes cognizance that each of the constructs that contribute to