Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Modelling and Simulation in Engineering
Volume 2013, Article ID 421350, 14 pages
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2013/421350
Research Article
Control Theory Concepts Applied to Retail Supply Chain:
A System Dynamics Modeling Environment Study
Balaji Janamanchi
1
and James R. Burns
2
1
Division of International Business and Technology Studies, Texas A&M International University, 5201 University Blvd,
Laredo, TX 78041-1900, USA
2
Rawls College of Business Administration, Texas Tech University, ISQS Area, P.O. Box 42101, Lubbock, TX 79409-2101, USA
Correspondence should be addressed to Balaji Janamanchi; bjanamanchi@tamiu.edu
Received 21 May 2013; Accepted 5 September 2013
Academic Editor: Jing-song Hong
Copyright © 2013 B. Janamanchi and J. R. Burns. Tis is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons
Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is
properly cited.
Control theory concepts have been long used to successfully manage and optimize complex systems. Using system dynamics (SD)
modeling methodology, which is continuous deterministic simulation modeling methodology, we apply control theory concepts to
develop a suitable performance functional (or objective function) that optimizes the performance of a retail supply chain. Te focus
is to develop insights for inventory management to prevent stock-outs and unflled orders and to fll customer orders at the lowest
possible cost to supply chain partners under diferent scenarios, in a two-player supplier-retailer supply chain. Moderate levels
of inventory, defning appropriate performance functional, appear to be crucial in choosing the right policies for managing retail
supply chain systems. Te study also demonstrated how multiple objectives can be combined in a single performance functional (or
objective function) by carefully assigning suitable weights to the components of objectives based on their priority and the existence
of possible trade of opportunities.
1. Introduction
Tere is no denying that supply chains are complex business
systems and the more we know about them the better we can
manage them. In this paper we focus on retailer supply chains,
rather than manufacturer supply chains. Additionally, we
demonstrate the use of control theory concepts to optimize
the performance of the retail supply chain for predefned
performance functional. One signifcant diference between
manufacturers and retailers is that retailers do not have
a manufacturing delay. However, both manufacturer and
retailer have one week lead time delay. When the retailer
transmits an order, one week is required to fll and ship the
order; likewise when a manufacturer transmits a shop order
to produce a product, one week is required to manufacture
the product. Once the product is shipped, it is in-house
at a retailer’s facility and is available for sale. Structurally,
this is signifcant. Te structural model used for retailers
does not include the manufacturing delay found in man-
ufacturing models, typically known as cycle time. Further,
the goals and objectives of retailers are diferent from those
of manufacturers. Manufacturing supply chains are focused
on minimizing a bullwhip efect, while retailers are more
interested in minimizing unflled order costs and inventory-
carrying costs. Tis is the fabric, the substance, this paper will
address—the supply-chain needs of retailers accomplished
via a control theory optimization process.
Tis study is part of a series of studies aimed at gaining a
deeper and better understanding of supply chain dynamics
using system dynamics modeling methodology developed
and enhanced over the past ffy years [1, 2]. In prior studies
efects of reduction in information delays and fow delays, as
well as forecasting/smoothing, upon manufacturing supply
chains have been explored [3, 4]. Te focus of our current
study is to develop useful insights for inventory management
to prevent stock-outs and unflled orders under diferent
scenarios, exclusively for retailers in a two-player supplier-
retailer supply chain. Afer all, the success of the supply
chain lies in meeting customer orders in a timely manner at