A novel approach for assessing the interaction of
masonry walls under vertical loads
Márcio R.S. Corrêa and Adrian W. Page
Abstract: This paper investigates the behaviour of masonry load-bearing walls subjected to differential vertical load. A
new approach for evaluating the interaction of intersecting walls is used, focusing on the mechanism of load transfer
and the resulting shear stresses. The study is carried out using finite element modelling. Previous full-scale tests are
used to verify the features of the numerical model. Once confirmed, the model is then used to study the phenomenon,
varying parameters such as the number of floors and the dimensions of the walls. It is shown that the distance down
the wall at which homogenization of the applied loads occurs can be predicted by application of the Saint Venant’s
Principle. The distribution of shear stresses along the interface can be simulated by a simple parabolic distribution. A
simple design procedure is proposed, allowing more realistic, cost-effective designs of load-bearing masonry structures.
Key words: masonry, walls, vertical loads, finite elements, interaction of walls.
Résumé : Cet article étudie le comportement des murs porteurs en maçonnerie soumis à une charge verticale différen-
tielle. Une nouvelle approche pour évaluer l’interaction des murs d’intersection est utilisée, ciblant le mécanisme de
transfert de charge et les contraintes de cisaillement qui en résultent. L’étude est effectuée par modélisation par
éléments finis. Des essais antérieurs à pleine échelle sont utilisés pour vérifier les caractéristiques du modèle
numérique. Une fois confirmé, le modèle est ensuite utilisé pour étudier le phénomène, en variant des paramètres tels
que le nombre d’étages et les dimensions des murs. Il est démontré que la distance le long du mur à laquelle survient
l’homogénéisation des charges appliquées peut être prédite en appliquant le principe de Saint Venant. La distribution
des contraintes de cisaillement le long de l’interface peut être simulée par une simple distribution parabolique. Une
procédure de conception simple est proposée, permettant des conceptions plus réalistes et rentables des structures
portantes en maçonnerie.
Mots clés : maçonnerie, murs, charges verticales, éléments finis, interaction des murs.
[Traduit par la Rédaction] Corrêa and Page 614
Introduction
Two intersecting load-bearing walls will interact provided
there is some form of structural connection crossing the
plane of the interface (steel bars, connectors, or bonded
units), resulting in an interface that has sufficient strength to
transmit the transferred forces. This interaction will result
from loading conditions such as out-of-plane bending or
differential compressive loading on different parts of the
wall system. Compared to walls subjected to horizontal
loads, the differential vertical loading phenomenon has not
been widely studied.
It is common for load-bearing walls at the same floor
level to be subjected to different levels of vertical load due
to their different tributary areas, with internal walls usually
supporting higher loads than external walls. The ratio of
internal wall load to external wall load can be up to two in
residential buildings. Normally the most heavily loaded wall
governs the masonry strength, since the same masonry units
will normally be used for all walls. In the case of block
work it is also possible to use grout to vary the masonry
strength, although this can create site control difficulties. If
two intersecting walls are subjected to different levels of
vertical load, they will shorten differentially, with resulting
interaction at the interface. If the interface has sufficient
shear strength, the more heavily loaded wall will transfer
load to the other, leading to progressive vertical stress
homogenization across the complete wall system. This
sharing of the load uses the walls more efficiently, thus
enabling a more cost-effective design, particularly for tall
load-bearing walls. This homogenization of the load is not
as important in low-rise structures where load levels are low,
but even in this case it is useful to gain a more complete
understanding of the mechanism of this interaction.
Stockbridge (1967) carried out one of the first research
projects on this subject at the University of Edinburgh. The
author monitored wall strains on a five-storey full-scale
building and found evidence of the homogenization of
Can. J. Civ. Eng. 31: 601–614 (2005) doi: 10.1139/L05-010 © 2005 NRC Canada
601
Received 6 September 2004. Revision accepted 17 January
2005. Published on the NRC Research Press Web site at
http://cjce.nrc.ca on 5 July 2005.
M.R.S. Corrêa. University of São Paulo, Av. Trabalhador
Saocarlense 400, Sao Carlos, SP, Brazil.
A.W. Page.
1
Faculty of Engineering and Built Environment,
University of Newcastle, University Drive, Callaghan, NSW
2308, Australia.
Written discussion of this article is welcomed and will be
received by the Editor until 31 December 2005.
1
Corresponding author (Adrian.Page@newcastle.edu.au).