International Research Journal of Engineering and Technology (IRJET) e-ISSN: 2395-0056
p-ISSN: 2395-0072 Volume: 08 Issue: 04 | Apr 2021 www.irjet.net
© 2020, IRJET | Impact Factor value: 7.529 | ISO 9001:2008 Certified Journal | Page 549
Progressive Collapse Analysis of R.C.C. Framed Structure using Etab’s
Anjali G. Dhole
1
, Prof. D.H. Tupe
2
, Dr. G.R. Gandhe
3
1
PG Student Department of Civil Engineering, DIEMS Aurangabad, Maharashtra, India
2
Assistant Professor, Department of Civil Engineering, DIEMS Aurangabad, Maharashtra, India
3
Head of Department of PG in Civil Engineering, DIEMS Aurangabad, Maharashtra, India
---------------------------------------------------------------------***---------------------------------------------------------------------
Abstract - A structure experiences progressive collapse when
a primary structural member (generally column) fails due to
manmade or natural causes. The failure of a member in the
primary load resisting system leads to redistribution of forces to
the adjoining members and if redistributed load exceeds
member capacity it fails. This process continues in the structure
and eventually the building collapses. This phenomenon is
referred as progressive collapse of the structure. In the present
study progressive collapse potential of 15-storey symmetrical
concrete framed building is evaluated. Linear static and
dynamic analysis is performed by following the General Service
Administration (GSA-2003) guidelines for evaluating
progressive collapse potential. Modeling, analysis and design
of the buildings are performed using ETABS 2019 for three
different threat-independent column removal conditions by
following the alternate load path method. It is observed that
demand capacity ratio (DCR) in beams and columns are
exceeding the allowable limit for all the cases. This indicates the
building considered for study is having high potential of
progressive collapse. To reduce the potential of progressive
collapse various approaches for mitigation of the progressive
collapse are implemented in this research. Different approaches
like providing bracing at floor level, moderate increase in the
size of beam at all the storey levels. Comparison between the
approaches is presented in this study by analyzing progressive
collapse of G+15 RCC Framed structure.
Key Words: Progressive Collapse, ETABs, IS Code, DCR,
PMM Ratio, story displacement, story drift.
INTRODUCTION
The progressive collapse of building structures is a
complicated mechanical behavior of entire structural systems
under large deformation. However, limited researches have
been conducted to investigate this issue at the last century due
to the lack of the experimental technique and numerical
simulation for entire structural systems under large
deformation. In recent years, with the development of the
experimental technique and numerical simulation, the
progressive collapse of building structures is studied in depth
and the exciting progresses have been reported. A progressive
collapse of a building is initiated by an unexpected event that
causes local damage and subsequently propagates throughout
the structural system, leading to a final damage state in large-
scale or entire collapse of the building. A progressive collapse
can be triggered by accident actions, including fire hazard, gas
explosion, terrorist attack, vehicle collision, design and
construction errors, and environmental corrosion. With the
development of industrialization, the buildings with multi-
function and high complication become more common of which
the safety and stability are far more concerned. However, the
current ultimate limit state design based on the structural
reliability theory is commonly used for regular structures to
ensure their safety. On the other hand, during the long-term use,
the structure may suffer unexpected accidental actions, causing
local damage or failure. Hence if the remaining structural system
cannot absorb or contain the internal force variation caused by
the initial failure, it will lead to a further damage even the
collapse of whole structure, causing huge loss of life and
property.
Stages in Structural Design
Every structure follows a specific path from its initiation to
ultimate design as follows:
1) Structural planning of the building.
2) Calculation of applied loads.
3) Structural analysis of the building
4) Design of the building as per analysis.
5) Drawing and detailing of the structural members.
6) Preparation of tables and graphs.
7) It is the responsibility of the structural engineer to
construct the building structurally good, considering all
the loads acting on the building. There are so many
methods of conducting these design we use E-tab
software.
Introduction to E-tab
ETABS-Extended 3D analysis of Building Systems”, is a
product of Computers and Structures Inc. It is an engineering
software that is used in construction. It has highly efficient
structure analysis and design programs developed for catering
to multi-story building systems. It is loaded with an integrated
system consisting of modeling tools and templates, code-
based load prescriptions, analysis methods, and solution
techniques. It can handle the largest and most complex
building models and associated configurations. ETABS
software is embedded with CAD-like drawing tools with an
object-based interface and grid representation. Integration,
productivity and technical innovation.
ETABS software has the following implications in the
construction, designing, and modeling industry: