International Journal of Engineering Works
ISSN-p: 2521-2419
ISSN-e: 2409-2770
Vol. 7, Issue 01, PP. 62-67, January 2020
https://www.ijew.io/
https://doi.org/10.34259/ijew.20.7016267
© Authors retian all copyrights 2020 IJEW. This is an open access article distributed under the CC-BY License, which permits
unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Comparative Analysis of Different Storage Technologies for Energy
Critical Application
Alamgir Ahmad Khattak
1
, Muhammad Safdar
2
, Asad Nawaz Khan
3
, Adil Nawaz Khan
4
1,2,3
Department of Electrical Energy Systems Engineering, US Pakistan Centre for Advanced Studies in Energy,
University of Engineering and technology Peshawar, Pakistan
4
CECOS University of IT and Emerging Sciences Peshawar, Pakistan
khattak.seecs@gmail.com
1
, salarsafdar@gmail.com
2
, p096409@nu.edu.pk
3
, isfmardan@gmail.com
4
Received: 17 January, Revised: 21 January, Accepted: 27 January
Abstract— The scope of this research work is the analysis and
study of the rechargeable batteries. During this research, battery
testbeds are developed for all under study battery technologies. A
few hundreds of charging, discharging experimentation has been
performed under a variety of charging profiles and discharging
load patterns. These observations have been critically analyzed to
capture the behavior of the batteries comprehensively. These
behavioral profiles of these batteries have been utilized for
developing an accurate battery model. The proposed model is a
hybrid model composed of Diffusion model and combined
electric circuit-based model, which accounts for nonlinearities of
rate capacity effect, recovery effect, capacity fading, storage
runtime and open circuit voltage, current-, temperature-,
dependency to transient response. This proposed model would be
a great help for energy aware circuit designing, because it’s an
equivalent circuit model that could be co-simulated in circuit
simulation environment, like Matlab Simulink. A quantitative
figure of merit for the selection of battery system for a specific
microgrid application has been devised on the bases of important
battery parameters.
Keywords— Battery storage system, Micro-grid, Battery Model,
Three stage battery charger, and constant current electronic load.
I. INTRODUCTION
The Conventional electrical power grid is undergoing a
disruptive change as the development of smart grid is motivated
by the energy crisis of the time throughout the globe [1]. The
limited amount of fossil fuels availability and more precisely the
fear of climate change caused by the greenhouse emissions are
the agents of this development [2, 3]. It is prioritized that more
Renewable Energy Sources (RES’s) must be incorporated into
system. Micro-grid is a critical infra-structure to integrate
Distributed Energy Sources (DES’s) for the deployment of smart
gird [4, 5]. This development is around the corner and increasing
of amount of research has been undergone in the last decade.
The smart grid is an electric grid integrated with Information
and Communication Technologies (ICT) to embody a high-
fidelity power-flow control having the ability heal if self, self-
healing ability, ensuring a reliable and secure provision of energy
[5]. Smart Grid refers to the set of technologies and infrastructure
which would put intelligence in the present dump grid to
transform it into a digital system which talks, listens, understand
and adapt accordingly. Smart grids is demand responsive
electricity system that balance out energy consumption and
supply, and has the capability to integrate new Renewable Energy
Sources (RES), while enabling the integration of energy storage
systems and the use of electric vehicles (EV).
A Micro-grid is the local version electric grid implement in a
small region and enables the integration of distributed energy
resources (DER) having connected with local flexible loads. The
micro-grids could be operated both in grid tied and in isolated
islanded mode to ensure a required level of high reliability and
resilience against disturbances in grid [4]. The micro-grid is a
miniature of a smart gird operating into a small premise and
having integrated RES’s. ESS is an integral part of micro-grid
infrastructure which enables it to improve the systems resiliency,
stability and reliability. The objectives of the development of a
Micro-grid are to provide clean electric energy with increased
reliability and sustainability with economic considerations.
Energy storage is an integral part of the Micro-grid which enables
it to integrate intermittent RES’s and to operate in stand-alone
mode without compromising on the reliability. Though, the core
functionality of a Micro-grid is considered to be the backup for
power systems, however, it provides on-site real time control of
both supply and demand and manage the available storage
capacity and also enables the interaction with the grid to improve
resiliency.
Micro-girds are evolving as a vital feature of future power
systems that has been developed by different smart-grid
initiatives, that can provide substantial environmental benefits by
integrating and utilizing energy efficient Distributed Generation
(DG) [6, 7]. Micro-grids are considered to provide a promising
solution by improving the power system resiliency by integrating
local sustainable resources and compensating the intermittent
nature of these sources with incorporation of Electrical Energy
Storage (EES) with in the systems [4, 8]. Solar PV systems, Wind
Power Plants, Micro Hydro Power Plants and Fuel cell are the
commonly exploited renewable energy resources and micro-grid
incorporates one of them as their main source of energy supply.
PV plants and Wind power depends on weather and they also