Copyright © 2014 IJAIR, All right reserved
931
International Journal of Agriculture Innovations and Research
Volume 3, Issue 3, ISSN (Online) 2319-1473
Field Evaluation of a Newly Introduced Thiamethoxam
Insecticide and Neem Seed Water Extract Against the
Predator Hippodamia Variegata in Sudan
Ensaf S.I. Mohamed
Shambat Research Station,
Agricultural Research Corporation,
Wad-Medani, Sudan
Hayder Abdelgader
Crop Protection Research Center,
Agricultural Research Corporation,
Wad-Medani, Sudan
Abdalla Abdelrahim Satti
National Centre for Research,
Khartoum, Sudan
email: satisattisat@yahoo.com
Abstract — Naturally occurring biological control agents
play an important role in suppressing many important
agricultural insect pests under normal conditions.
Regrettably, many synthetic pesticides are reported to
impose negative impacts on beneficial insects. Therefore,
considerable efforts are devoted in recent years to choose
selective insecticides for combating noxious pests.
Accordingly, field experiments were conducted on potato
crop during two consecutive winter (December-March)
seasons at Shambat Research Station, Khartoum North,
Sudan, to study the side effects of a newly introduced
insecticide Actara (thiamethoxam) 25 WG, applied at
different rates, and neem seed kernel water extract
(NSKWE) at two rates, on larvae of the coccinellid predator,
Hippodamia variegata. The results indicated that Actara was
toxic (IOBC class 4) to the larvae of H. variegata under the
two experiments, while NSKWE was found to be safe to the
predator. Such neem extract at its two rates (2.5% and
5%w/v) showed significantly the highest numbers of the
predator in the two experiments. It is concluded that the
tested neem treatments can be used safely against potato
pests without adverse effect on the predatory larvae of H.
variegata, but Actara should be avoided when natural
enemies are active.
Key Words — Predatory larvae, Hippodamia, neem,
Actara, Side effect, toxicity, selective insecticide.
I. INTRODUCTION
Natural enemies (predators, parasites and
entomopathogens) of insects play an important role in
regulating agricultural pests under normal conditions.
Therefore, exploitation of these enemies in biological
control through various ways (importation, augmentation
or conservation) comprises an important component of
many integrated pest management programmes at the
global level. Nevertheless, the extensive usage of several
broad spectrum synthetic insecticides in field and
vegetable crops is found to affect the natural enemies
negatively [1]-[2]-[3]. The beneficial arthropods
(predators and parasitoids) can be exposed to insecticides
either directly through sprays or indirectly when get in
contact with residues on plant surfaces, or by ingesting
insecticide contaminated preys on host. To avoid such
problems, harmful synthetic insecticides should be applied
selectively (i.e., in terms of place, time and application
technique), or otherwise selective chemicals with high or
moderate safety to natural enemies may be selected and
used.
Thiamethoxam is a second–generation neonicotinoid
compound with systemic and contact activity on economic
important sucking pests (e.g., aphids and whitefly) of
vegetables and other crops [4]. In Sudan, thiamethoxam
(viz., Actara 25 WG) was recently recommended for the
control of whitefly Bemisia tabaci on tomato and Aphis
gossypii on potato [5]. On the other hand, biologically
active substances from neem tree, Azadirchtca indica (A.
Juss), have been evaluated against agricultural pests and
their natural enemies in different parts of the world [6]-
[7]-[8]-[9]. Likewise, neem seed water extract was
recommended for the control of various pests on different
vegetable crops in Sudan [10]-[11]-[12]-[13]. No adverse
effects on populations of insect predators were recorded
from the application of such neem extract on vegetables
[11]-[12]-[14]. However, the important predatory groups
recorded on vegetables in Khartoum and other parts of the
country included: Coccinellids (e.g., Hippodamia
variegata, Scymnus spp., Cheilomenes propinqua vicina
and Coccinella undecimpunctata), chrysopids (e.g.,
Chrysoperla carnea), syrphids (e.g., Xanthogramma
aegyptium) and different spiders [9]-[15]-[16]-[17]-[18]-
[19]. Among the coccinellids recorded, H. variegata is the
most abundant and most widespread in different parts of
the country [12]-[16]-[19]-[20]. This rich fauna need to be
thoroughly investigated and conserved to enhance their
biological role in pest control.
Objective: The side effects of Actara 25 WG
(thiamethoxam) insecticide and neem seed kernel water
extract, used for controlling potato insect pests, were
evaluated in this study against the larvae of the coccinellid
lady bird beetle, Hippodamia variegata, on the same crop
(potato).
II. MATERIALS AND METHODS
Two consecutive field experiments were conducted on
potato crop at Shambat, Khartoum North, Sudan, during
winter seasons of 2002/03 and 2003/04. It was aimed to
evaluate the side effects of Actara (thiamethoxam) 25 WG
insecticide at 18.8, 25.0, 31.3 and 37.5g a.i./feddan
(=42ha) and neem seed kernel water extract (NSKWE) at
2.5%w/v (25g neem kernel powder/L. water) and 5%
(50g/L.) on larval population of the coccinellid predator,
Hippodamia variegata. Moreover, Actara at 25g a.i/fed.
mixed with NSKWE 25g /L. of water were tested in the
second season.