Humanities & Social Sciences Reviews
eISSN: 2395-6518, Vol 7, No 1, 2019, pp 347-353
https://doi.org/10.18510/hssr.2019.7140
347 |www.hssr.in © Mohad et al.
MUSLIM-CHRISTIAN RELATIONS IN MALAYSIA: ISSUES AND
SOLUTIONS
Abd Hakim Mohad, Ros Aiza Mohd Mokhtar, Mashitah Sulaiman, Latifah Abdul Latiff
Universiti Sains Islam, Malaysia
abdhakim@usim.edu.my, rosaiza@usim.edu.my, masyitah@usim.edu.my, latifah@usim.edu.my
Article History: Received on 10
th
December 2018, Revised on 20
th
April, Published on 02
nd
August 2019
Abstract
Purpose: The issue of Muslim-Christian relations in Malaysia is often in the limelight of the mass media, domestic and
foreign. Within recent years, there have been incidents directly related to this topic of discussion. This paper discusses
these the issues and challenges faced by the Muslim and Christian communities in Malaysia.
Methodology: This is a qualitative study, and the data were collected from library sources such as books, journals,
newspapers, periodicals, websites, and detailed interviews with members of the Muslim and Christian faiths. The data was
then analysed through a documentary analysis technique.
Main Findings: This study found that Muslim-Christian relations often go through ebbs and flows. Generally, incidents
involving religious sensitivities are fanned further by the mass media and interested politicians, although these issues are
not as serious as reported. These situations then create an uneasy tension between the two communities, thus negatively
affecting foster unity in diversity within the plural societies in Malaysia. What should be encouraged as an alternative is
dialogue between adherents of different religions for them to know one another, and to promote religious harmony.
Implications: In the New Malaysia era, room of dialogue seems to flourish with the inclusive approach of the Pakatan
Harapan (PH) government. This is a positive development, which hopefully would be a catalyst to building a Malaysia
society united in diversity.
Keywords: Tolerance, Religion, Islam, Christian, Malaysia.
INTRODUCTION
Muslim-Christian relations has been around for 1,400 years (Troll, 2008). Throughout this period, there have been
numerous events that marked the high and low points of this relationship. Within the Malaysian context, both Islam and
Christianity have their respective rights guaranteed under Article 3(1) of the Constitution, which states that “Islam is the
religion of the Federation; but other religions may be practised in peace and harmony in any part of the Federation. ”
(Yaacob, 2012).
As is generally known, Malaysia is one of the countries whereby its citizens consist of peoples of various religions,
cultures, and ethnicities. However, a number of issues have affected Muslim-Christian relations in this country. Among
them are the issue of banning the use of the word “Allah” in the Herald-The Catholic Weekly (Herald) by the Court of
Appeal. This issue has attracted both local and international attention, as it has the potential to shape Muslim-Christian
relations in the future. There are also other issues related to relations between the two faiths, like the confiscation of
Malay-language Bibles by the Selangor Islamic Religious Council (MAIS) on 2 January 2014, as well as the protest by a
group of Muslims against the erecting of a cross in a church there. These issues are very important in shaping Muslim-
Christian relations in Malaysia. These issues have been brought to court for adjudication in order to find a solution.
LITERATURE REVIEW
There have not been a lot of studies on Muslim-Christian relationship, specifically in the Malaysian context. By and large,
published writings focus more on the general themes of the plural society in Malaysia, without reference to the relationship
between the Muslim and Christian communities. The narrative of Muslim-Christian relationship in Malaysia ranges in the
majority-minority or superior-inferior interaction. The majority-minority interaction occurs as the majority of Malaysians
are Muslims (61.3%); Christians are the minority (9.2%) (2010 Population and Housing Census of Malaysia). The
superior-inferior interaction relationship is due to Islam being elevated as the religion of the federation, and Christianity is
not (Yaacob, 2012).
It should be emphasised here that religious issues in Malaysia is very sensitive. An issue considered unexceptional in other
countries might be viewed highly seriously in Malaysia. Throughout Muslim-Christian relations in Malaysia, many issues
have been interpreted as causing strains between the two communities. The largest and most polemical issue happened in
2009, when the High Court of Malaya allowed the Christian periodical the Herald Tribune to use the term “Allah” in their
publications. On the government side, the Home Ministry had restricted the periodical for using the term “Allah,” which
was seen as touching on Muslim sensitivities in this country. Imagine the strained relations and crisis between adherents of
the two faiths. It was quote worrying (Rawa. 2013).