1532 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INSTRUMENTATION AND MEASUREMENT, VOL. 56, NO. 5, OCTOBER 2007
Design and Implementation of a New
Nonradioactive-Based Machine for Detecting
Oil–Water Interfaces in Oil Tanks
Ahmed M. Al-Naamany, Mahmoud Meribout, Member, IEEE, and Khamis Al Busaidi
Abstract—In the oil industry, many applications require the
measurement of more than one liquid level interface, often in
challenging environments. In this paper, a new ultrasonic-based
technique has been developed to determine oil, emulsion, and
water levels in oil tanks. It consists of a compact and program-
mable ultrasound-based multilayer level measurement device for
which a feed-forward neural network is implemented. The ad-
vantages of this method over current methods include contactless
distance measurement, higher accuracy, lower cost, simpler setup,
and not using ionizing radiation. The other advantage of this
technique over light-based methods is its insensitivity to a dusty
and smoky environment and independence of the object material
and surface. Preliminary experiments have been conducted on the
device. In this paper, the design and operating parameters of the
device are discussed, and evidence of satisfactory performance is
given.
Index Terms—Emulsion level detection, hardware design,
multilayer level measurement (MLLM), neural network, oil tank,
ultrasonic device.
I. I NTRODUCTION
O
IL PRODUCING institutions in many parts of the world
are still faced with the problem of producing water and
gas, together with oil from oil fields. Separating these three
components from each other requires settling them in large
tanks for a short period of time generating oil at the top,
oil/water mixture in the middle, and water at the bottom. Water
will then be pumped out from the tank. However, in order
not to pump out oil with water, the level of the mixed liquid
(water–oil) needs to be monitored continuously, particularly
during the pumping process. In [1], an extensive literature
review on currently available level measurement methods have
been investigated. The authors claimed that most of the devices
have been designed to detect only the top level of the liquid
in the tank. These measurement sensors include RF capaci-
tance, conductance, nuclear, radar, differential pressure, optical
switches, and ultrasonic. A microwave-based sensor is among
the few devices that have been recently designed for the ex-
traction of the levels of the emulsion layers in the tank [2]–[4].
Manuscript received April 30, 2006; revised January 15, 2007. This work
was supported by the Petroleum Development Oman Corporation.
A. M. Al-Naamany and M. Meribout are with the Electrical and Computer
Engineering Department, College of Engineering, SQU University, Muscat 123,
Oman (e-mail: meribout@squ.edu.com).
K. Al Busaidi is with the Petroleum Development Oman Corporation,
Muscat 123, Oman.
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available online
at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org.
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TIM.2007.895665
However, the system is expensive. Additionally, the high en-
ergy of the microwaves makes the technique inappropriate for
combustible liquids.
In this paper, a new ultrasonic-based hardware device for
multilayer level measurement (MLLM) is presented. This so-
lution makes use of the fact that the ultrasonic properties of
an emulsion or suspension vary significantly with a varying
disperse phase volume fraction. The actual results are very
encouraging and demonstrate that the device can easily mea-
sure, with very good accuracy, the emulsion in a single vessel.
Furthermore, since its electronics is placed outside the tank, the
device can work in hazardous, clean, or sterile environments
and cope with surface foam or bottom sludge. Hence, the
approach can be extended to allow the measurement of other
fluid types as well. The system was designed in such way that it
can work autonomously during long periods in remote areas
where environmental conditions (i.e., temperature) may vary
within wide ranges.
II. MULTILEVEL DETECTION SENSOR
HARDWARE ARCHITECTURE
A. Concept
The basic idea of our device is that the amount of ultrasound
waves received and its speed depends upon the density of
the liquid: Since the acoustic impedance of the water and
oil (1.55 and 1.072 MRayls for water and Kerosene, where
1 MRayls =(kg/(sxm
2
) × 10
6
[5]) are not similar, different
responses for both liquids can be expected. Hence, by measur-
ing the signal response at different vertical positions in the tank,
the two levels of the interface (i.e., lower and higher levels) can
be measured. Fig. 1 shows the layout of the tank, which has
a capacity of 0.25 m
3
. An ultrasonic emitter and receiver are
mounted inside two vertical stands, respectively. A thin layer of
silicon is inserted between the active surface of both sensors and
the interior wall of the vertical stands in order for ultrasound
waves not to be back-scattered. Both sensors move up and down
at the same horizontal level providing acoustic characterization.
One advantage of this design is that the results are independent
from the geometrical and chemical properties of the walls of
the tank. Fig. 2 is a photograph of the tank. Fig. 3 shows
the overview hardware architecture of the MLLM device. It is
composed of an ultrasonic emitter-receiver pair placed inside
the two vertical stands and transmitting at a programmable
frequency.
0018-9456/$25.00 © 2007 IEEE