RESEARCH ARTICLE
Teaching financial education in schools and students'
financial literacy: A cross-country analysis with PISA data
Manuel Salas-Velasco | Dolores Moreno-Herrero | José Sánchez-Campillo
Department of Applied Economics,
University of Granada Business School,
Granada, Spain
Correspondence
Manuel Salas-Velasco, Department of
Applied Economics, University of
Granada Business School, Campus
Cartuja 18071, Granada, Spain. –
Email: msalas@ugr.es
Abstract
In the last decade, developed and emerging economies have become increas-
ingly aware of the importance of ensuring that their citizens are financially lit-
erate. Eighteen countries and economies, including 13 OECD countries,
participated for the first time in 2012 on the financial literacy assessment of
15-year-old students. Financial literacy scores varied according to the partici-
pating countries, and they were determined by factors related to the teaching-
learning process, especially those related to the delivery of financial education
in schools. This paper assesses the effectiveness of the provision of financial
education in the school curriculum across all the countries that participated in
PISA 2012 data from 2015 did not allow such analysis. We measured the —
direct effect of different ways of financial education delivery on students' finan-
cial literacy scores, after controlling for math and reading perf ormance, and
individual characteristics of students and their schools. The majority of the
countries have introduced financial education topics in the curriculum some-
how. But only in the Flemish Community of Belgium, the United States, and
Latvia and to a lesser extent in Australia, Estonia, France, Israel, Poland, —
Spain, the Czech Republic, the Russian Federation, and the Slovak Republic—
the way how financial education (FE) is delivered is positively correlated with
students' financial literacy scores: FE taught as part of business or economics
courses in Belgium, FE taught as part of a cross-curricular subject in the U.S.,
and FE taught as part of mathematics in Latvia. Our main findings pose funda-
mental challenges for educational policy regarding school-based FE. The first
is to decide at what age (grade) interventions should be introduced into the
education system so that students are not only financially literat e but also
financially competent. The second is to devise instructional approaches that
more effectively lead young people to put pertinent financial knowledge into
practice and to do so correctly when they make financial decisions.
KEYWORDS
financial education, financial literacy, multi-level analysis, PISA 2012
Received: 24 June 2018 Revised: 7 November 2019 Accepted: 18 June 2020
DOI: 10.1002/ijfe.200 5
Int J Fin Econ. 2021;26:4077 4103. wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/ijfe © 2020 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd. – 4077
Printed by [Universidad De Granada - 150.214.205.175 - /doi/epdf/10.1002/ijfe.2005] at [23/07/2021].