A Feedback-Based Approach for Mainstream Traffic Flow Control
of Multiple Bottlenecks on Motorways
Georgia-Roumpini Iordanidou, Ioannis Papamichail, Claudio Roncoli, Markos Papageorgiou
Dynamic Systems and Simulation Laboratory, Technical University of Crete, 73100 Chania, Greece
(Tel: +30-28210-37422; e-mail: <giordanidou, ipapa, croncoli, markos> @ dssl.tuc.gr)
Abstract: Mainstream traffic flow control (MTFC) enabled via variable speed limits (VSLs) has been
investigated in previous studies, utilizing various control strategies. In this paper a new feedback control
strategy is proposed for MTFC enabled via VSLs, considering multiple bottleneck locations. Results are
evaluated using a validated macroscopic model. The feedback concept is robust and can be immediately
implemented in the field as it considers practical and safety constraints.
Keywords: Feedback control, Mainstream traffic flow control, Multiple bottlenecks, Variable speed
limits.
1. INTRODUCTION
Congestion on motorways is a major community problem
which leads to a sensible reduction of the motorway
infrastructure capacity (Papageorgiou and Kotsialos, 2002).
This reduction occurs during the peak periods, causing
degradation in terms of travel times, traffic safety, fuel
consumption, and environmental pollution. With the purpose
of alleviating traffic congestion, various control strategies
have been suggested. However, some of them face
limitations; e.g., ramp metering suffers from the limited
number of vehicles that can be stored while route guidance is
most valuable under non-recurrent traffic congestion.
Mainstream traffic flow control (MTFC) regulates the flow
upstream of a bottleneck location in order to maximize
throughput at the specific location. This control action has
been proposed by Carlson et al. (2010a, b) and was shown to
lead to a remarkable improvement of the traffic flow
efficiency indicators. In early research, Gazis and Foote
(1969) had proposed a traffic-responsive control system for a
tunnel flow control. Real-time traffic measurements from the
bottleneck location were used by the system to make
decisions on the tunnel’s flow control. Crowley and
Greenberg (1965) and Foote and Crowley (1967) suggested
the first simple feedback control strategy, while Foote (1968)
and Gazis and Foote (1969) proposed a more sophisticated
heuristic feedback algorithm. Another MTFC-like system is
the traffic-light based entrance control system of the San
Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge, which was introduced by
McCalden (1984) and has been in operation for more than 35
years. The algorithm used (Chen et al., 1990) appears to have
important similarities with the algorithm proposed by
Spiliopoulou et al. (2010). Finally, some fix-time mainline
strategies have been investigated by Jacobson and Landsman
(1994), and Haboian (1995) using traffic lights as a new
traffic management tool for motorways.
So far, the use of traffic lights is generally not acceptable on
motorways. As a result, researchers have considered MTFC
enabled by use of Variable Speed Limits (VSLs) with various
control strategies and traffic application settings. In the work
by Carlson et al. (2010b), it has been shown that ramp-
metering and MTFC can have a similar impact on bottleneck
locations, while an optimal control problem has been
proposed by Carlson et al. (2010a) showing the benefits of
MTFC, applied to a large-scale motorway. It is obvious from
these papers that MTFC applied upstream of an active
bottleneck location is able to avoid the capacity drop.
Nevertheless, the optimal control approach used may be
cumbersome for use in real field implementation. Zhang et al.
(2006) proposed an ALINEA-like feedback controller for
MTFC, based on VSLs, and performed tests via microscopic
simulation. The obtained improvements were marginal
probably because of the absence of an acceleration area, as
proposed by Carlson et al. (2010a, b).
This paper proposes an extension of the feedback controller
presented by Carlson et al. (2011) for the case of multiple
bottlenecks. The issue of multiple bottlenecks was addressed
by Wang et al. (2010) for the case of ramp metering control;
hence this paper combines the concepts developed by Carlson
et al. (2011) and Wang et al. (2010) to derive a feedback law
for VSL-based MTFC addressing multiple downstream
bottlenecks. The new feedback control strategy is simple and
robust and can be directly applied in the field. Many practical
aspects of VSL operations are also considered in the
simulation-based tests using a validated second-order
macroscopic traffic flow model.
In Section 2, the MTFC concept is reviewed and the
implementation aspects are presented. In Section 3, the
MTFC strategy for multiple bottlenecks is described, taking
into account practical application aspects. The efficiency of
the proposed control strategy is evaluated in Section 4, while
the conclusion of this paper and some ideas for further
research on the subject are presented in Section 5.
Preprints of the 19th World Congress
The International Federation of Automatic Control
Cape Town, South Africa. August 24-29, 2014
Copyright © 2014 IFAC 11344