[CANCER RESEARCH 55, 4438-4445, October 1, 1995]
Overexpression of bcl-2 Protects Prostate Cancer Cells from Apoptosis in Vitro and
Confers Resistance to Androgen Depletion in Vivo1
Anthony J. Raffo, Harris Perlman, Min-Wei Chen, Mark L. Day, Jack S. Streitman, and Ralph Buttyan2
Department of Urology, College of Physicians and Surgeons of Columbia University, Neu- York, Neu- York 10032 ¡A.J. R.. H. P.. M-W. C., J. S. S., R. B.¡,and Michigan
Prostate Institute, University of Michigan. Ann Arbor. Michigan 48109 ¡M.L D.¡
ABSTRACT
Normal (nonneoplastic) human prostatic secretory epithelial cells do
not express the hcl-2 protein. However, a recent immunohistochemical
.survey of neoplastic human prostate tissues showed that a fraction of
primary untreated prostate adenocarcinoma cells expressed this apopto-
sis-suppressing oncoprotein at significant levels (Colombe! el al.. Am. J.
Pillimi., 143: 390-400, 1993). Additionally, a number of hormone-refrac
tory prostatic adenocarcinomas obtained from hormonally-treated pa
tients (subsequent to surgical or drug castration therapy) were examined
and were found to be uniform in their elevated expression of bcl-2
oncoprotein. The results of this preliminary survey imply that bcl-2
expression distinguishes a subgroup of primary human prostate cancers
and that the expression of this protein might be a factor enabling prostate
cancer cells to survive in an androgen-deprived environment. The current
study was undertaken to determine the degree to which overexpression of
bcl-2 can protect human prostate cancer cells from apoptotic stimuli in
vitro and in vivo. Human prostate cancer cells (LNCaP) were transfected
with a neomycin-selectable eucaryotic expression vector containing cDNA
encoding human bcl-2. Transfected clonal variants that express bcl-2
protein (LNCaP/bcl-2) were unaltered with regard to their basal growth
rate in 10% serum-containing medium, or with regard to their expression
of the differentiated human prostate cell gene products prostate-specific
antigen or androgen receptor protein. The bcl-2-transfected clones were
altered, however, with regard to their growth rate in charcoal-stripped
serum lacking dihydrotestosterone. Additionally, in contrast to the paren
tal or control-transfected cell lines, LNCaP/bcl-2 cells were highly resist
ant to a variety of apoptotic stimuli in vitro including serum starvation and
10 MMphorbol ester (phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate) supplementation of
the medium. Lastly, the overexpression of bcl-2 by these prostate cancer
cells altered their tumorigenic potential in a nude mouse assay, s.c.
injections of Id1'LNCaP/bcl-2 cells into male nude mice resulted in earlier
and larger tumor formation compared to an equivalent injection of pa
rental or control-transfected LNCaP cells. When these variant cell lines
were injected into castrated male nude mice, only the LNCaP/bcl-2-
transformed cells gave rise to tumors. Moreover, LNCaP/bcl-2 tumors
grown in intact male nude mice were refractory to the growth-inhibiting
effects of castration demonstrated by parental LNCaP cells. Data obtained
in this study demonstrate that the bcl-2 oncoprotein can protect prostate
cancer cells from apoptotic stimuli hi vitro and suggest that such protec
tion correlates with the ability to form hormone-refractory prostate tu
mors in vivo.
INTRODUCTION
Therapy for the advanced form of prostate cancer generally in
volves either surgical gonadectomy to remove the major source of
androgens or drug treatments that suppress androgen production and
action. These treatments are at least palliatively effective because they
Received 4/4/95; accepted 8/2/95.
The costs of publication of this article were defrayed in part by the payment of page
charges. This article must therefore be hereby marked advertisement in accordance with
18 U.S.C. Section 1734 solely to indicate this fact.
1 This work was supported by United States Public Health Service Grants N1H-
CA58089 and NIH-CA47848, as well as grants from the CaPCure Foundation and
the Koch Foundation. M-W. C. is a research fellow of the American Foundation for
Urological Disease.
• To whom requests for reprints should be addressed, at Department of Urology,
Columbia University, College of Physicians and Surgeons, 630 West loKth Street, New
York, NY 10032.
can initiate apoptosis of prostate cancer cells. Unfortunately, some
fraction of the prostate cancer cells inevitably survives these therapies
and continues to grow. It is clear that these cells have a means of
avoiding or inhibiting the cellular mechanism that activates the cell
death pathway so intrinsic to normal prostate epithelial cells after
androgen withdrawal. Therefore, our ability to comprehend the mech
anism of this apoptotic inhibition and overcome it has significant
ramifications for the development of new and more effective therapies
to successfully treat this malignancy.
On the basis of the rapidly increasing knowledge of the genetic
components involved in the apoptotic pathway, we recently screened
a large number of human prostatic tissues to characterize whether any
of these tissues expressed the bcl-2 oncoprotein, a potent and broad-
spectrum suppressor of apoptosis (1, 2). The results of this immuno
histochemical survey showed that no normal cells of the adult human
prostatic secretory epithelium expressed this protein. In contrast, a
subset of primary prostatic adenocarcinomas obtained from untreated
prostate cancer patients positively immunostained for bcl-2, as did all
of the hormone-refractory prostatic adenocarcinomas obtained from
hormone-treated patients (3). This intriguing pattern establishes the
potential involvement of bcl-2 in the developmental pathway of
prostate cancer leading to hormone resistance. The results that we
obtained by experimental manipulation of bcl-2 expression in prostate
cancer cells, presented here, further support this hypothesis.
When exogenously expressed in cultured cells and in transgenic
mouse systems, bcl-2 has been shown to protect against apoptotic
stimuli as diverse as chemotherapeutic agents and growth factor
deprivation (1, 2, 4—6).This protection extends to certain forms of
hormone-activated apoptosis, most prominently, glucocorticoid-in-
duced apoptosis of thymocytes (7). To date, the question of whether
bcl-2 expression can protect endocrine-dependent cells from hormone
withdrawal has not yet been established. To test this for prostate cells,
we genetically manipulated a commonly used prostate cancer cell line,
LNCaP, so that these cells would overexpress the human bcl-2 pro
tein. This cell line is a popular model for the study of prostate cancer
(8, 9) because it retains some of the most prominent differentiated
features of the human prostate cell, including the production of the
prostate secretory protein, PSA1 (10), the prostate-specific membrane
antigen (11), and the AR (12). Moreover, LNCaP cells have proven to
be growth responsive to androgenic steroids in vitro (13). Addition
ally, these cells show an androgen-dependent phenotype in vivo with
regard to their ability to form tumors in male but not castrated male
nude mice (8, 9).
In this series of experiments, we examined whether exogenously
expressed bcl-2 protein can alter the expression of the differentiated
prostate gene products or the basal growth rate of LNCaP cells.
Furthermore, we tested whether enhanced bcl-2 expression could alter
the LNCaP cell growth response to DHT or the apoptotic response of
these cells to serum withdrawal or phorbol ester supplementation in
vitro. Finally, the results of a study of LNCaP tumor formation in
intact and castrated male nude mice strongly support the hypothesis
1 The abbreviations used are: PSA, prostate-specific antigen; FBS, fetal bovine serum;
TPA, phorbol 12-myristate 13-acetate; AR. androgen receptor; DHT. dihyrotestosterone.
4438
Research.
on September 10, 2021. © 1995 American Association for Cancer cancerres.aacrjournals.org Downloaded from