SHORT COMMUNICATION
DOI: 10.1002/ejoc.201101374
Cyclotrimerization of Corannulyne: Steric Hindrance Tunes the Inversion
Barriers of Corannulene Bowls
Michael Yanney,
[a]
Frank R. Fronczek,
[b]
WilliamP. Henry,
[a]
Debbie J. Beard,
[a]
and
Andrzej Sygula*
[a]
Keywords: Arynes / Cyclotrimerization / Bowl-to-bowl inversion / Corannulenes
Palladium-catalyzed cyclotrimerization of corannulyne gen-
erated from 2-trimethylsilylcorannulenyl triflate produced a
C
60
H
24
hydrocarbon that prefers a highly nonplanar “twist”
conformation of C
1
symmetry, as demonstrated by X-ray crys-
tal structure determination and HDFT calculations. Its three
corannulene subunits, identical in the idealized D
3h
sym-
metry, exhibit dramatically different inversion barriers (from
Introduction
Palladium-catalyzed cyclotrimerization of acetylenes
provides a synthetically useful route to substituted ben-
zenes.
[1]
1,2-Didehydrobenzenes (benzynes) have also been
successfully cyclotrimerized to afford triphenylenes.
[2]
Re-
cent reports of the preparation of sterically hindered poly-
cyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) such as hexabenzotri-
phenylene (1) by using o-TMS triflates as benzyne precur-
sors
[3]
prompted us to attempt the synthesis of hydrocarbon
C
60
H
24
(2) by cyclotrimerization of 1,2-didehydrocor-
annulene (corannulyne) 3. The resulting cyclotrimer exhib-
its an interesting conformational behavior that is driven by
dramatically different bowl-to-bowl inversion barriers of
formally identical corannulene subunits. In addition, this
synthetic approach opens the possibility for generation of
discotic bowl-shaped molecular networks of nanometric
size.
[a] Department of Chemistry, Mississippi State University,
310 President’s Circle, Mississippi State, MS 37962, USA
Fax: +1-662-325-1618
E-mail: asygula@chemistry.msstate.edu
[b] Department of Chemistry, Louisiana State University,
Baton Rouge, LA 70803, USA
Supporting information for this article is available on the
WWW under http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ejoc.201101374.
© 2011 Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH & Co. KGaA, Weinheim Eur. J. Org. Chem. 2011, 6636–6639 6636
8.4 to 17.3 kcal mol
–1
), tuned by the steric congestion inside
the highly dissymmetric structure. Bowl-to-bowl inversion of
the corannulene unit with the lowest activation barrier re-
sults in pseudorotation of the molecule and gives rise to a
1
H
NMR spectrum exhibiting only 12 distinct proton signals. The
line-shape analysis of selected NMR signals gave an estima-
tion of the barrier at 8.5–8.6 kcal mol
–1
.
Results and Discussion
Our synthesis was achieved with 40 % yield (Scheme 1)
by using 2-trimethylsilylcorannulenyl triflate (4), previously
introduced by us as an efficient precursor for aryne 3.
[4]
The
identity of 2 was first confirmed by MALDI/TOF spec-
trometry, which showed the expected pattern for the molec-
ular radical ion of C
60
H
24
.
[5]
Room-temperature
1
H and
13
C
NMR spectra of 2 exhibit very broad bands presumably
due to slow (on the NMR time scale) conformational in-
terconversions that did not allow immediate confirmation
of the product’s structure.
[5]
The final confirmation of the
structure of 2 came from X-ray crystallography (Figure 1),
which showed two symmetry independent molecules of the
highly nonplanar conformer with both DCM and toluene
solvate molecules present in the unit cell.
[6]
Scheme 1. Cyclotrimerization of corannulyne.
Cyclotrimer 2 belongs to the class of overcrowded PAHs
with “ideal” D
3h
symmetry that are forced to adopt confor-
mations of lower symmetry due to steric congestion. The
distortion gives rise to either propeller-type conformations
(up–down, up–down, up–down) or twist structures (up–down,
up–up, down–down; Figure 2).
[8]
Conformational analysis of 2 is complicated by the bowl-
shape of the corannulene subunits. This feature multiplies
the number of possible conformations in comparison to the
simpler analogues possessing planar rim attachments. How-