Influence of edge barriers on vortex dynamics in thin weak-pinning superconducting strips
B. L. T. Plourde* and D. J. Van Harlingen
Department of Physics, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 1110 West Green Street, Urbana, Illinois 61801
D. Yu. Vodolazov
Department of Physics, Nizhny Novgorod University, Gagarin Avenue 23, 603600, Nizhny Novgorod, Russia
R. Besseling, M. B. S. Hesselberth, and P. H. Kes
Kamerlingh Onnes Laboratorium, Leiden University, P. O. Box 9504, 2300 RA Leiden, The Netherlands
Received 17 November 2000; published 5 June 2001
We introduce a type of vortex entry edge barrier which controls the critical current in a perpendicular
magnetic field in thin-film weak-pinning superconducting strips. Measurements of the critical current in thin-
film amorphous-MoGe strips show a linear decrease with increasing magnetic field strength at low magnetic
fields, and a crossover at a well-defined threshold field to an inverse power-law decay that is independent of the
strip width. This behavior has not been observed previously due to bulk pinning, which only becomes domi-
nant in our MoGe samples at high magnetic fields. To describe our results, we present calculations of the
current distribution in thin superconducting strips with a finite penetration depth and negligible bulk pinning,
and show that the measured critical currents in our MoGe samples correspond to a current density at the strip
edge which approaches the Ginzburg-Landau depairing limit. Shape variations and defects along the strip
edges influence the vortex entry conditions, leading to deviations from the ideal behavior, including offsets in
the critical current maximum with respect to zero field.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevB.64.014503 PACS numbers: 74.60.Jg, 74.76.-w
Sample edges play an important role in the dynamics of
vortices in superconductors. In addition to intervortex forces
and bulk pinning at defect sites, which limit vortex flow in
uniform superconductors, interactions with the edges of a
superconductor can significantly affect vortex transport in
finite size superconducting structures and thin-film devices.
The vortex screening current distribution is distorted near a
surface so that the boundary condition of no normal current
flow at the surface is satisfied. This distortion creates a sur-
face barrier, first considered by Bean and Livingston,
1
and
delays the entry of vortices until a magnetic field strength
which can be much greater than the lower critical field H
c 1
when vortex nucleation in the bulk first becomes energeti-
cally favorable. Another type of vortex entry barrier can oc-
cur in superconductors with a large demagnetizing factor,
such as thin platelet crystals in a perpendicular magnetic
field. The associated strong curvature of the field lines at the
sample edges results in a broad distribution of the screening
currents across the entire top and bottom surfaces of the
sample. If the sample is thicker than the penetration depth,
then the curved field lines can cause the entry of tilted vortex
segments at the sample corners. As the segments penetrate
further into the superconductor, the length of the segment
increases initially, leading to an energetic barrier against vor-
tex entry. These so-called geometrical barriers have been
studied extensively, particularly in wide, thick samples of the
type-II superconductors.
2–4
In this paper, we consider a different regime for which the
sample thickness is much less than the penetration depth so
that the vortices behave essentially as 2D objects. In this
thin-film limit, the vortices cannot cut across the sample cor-
ners, but the large demagnetizing factor again leads to a
broad current distribution across the strip width, while the
vortices still interact with the sample edge via a Bean-
Livingston surface barrier mechanism. This hybrid effect,
which we call an edge barrier, is particularly important for
understanding vortex phenomena in microfabricated thin-
film devices, including flux-flow noise processes in super-
conducting quantum interference device,
5
vortex transport in
weak-pinning channels,
6–8
and the realization of asymmetric
vortex ratchet devices.
9
To investigate the effect of the edge
barrier on the dynamics of vortices, we have measured the
magnetic field dependence of the critical current of patterned
thin-film amorphous MoGe strips. The weak bulk pinning of
this material ensures that the critical current is dominated by
the vortex interactions with the strip edge over a wide range
of magnetic field. We observe several distinct regimes of
magnetic field dependence which we identify with different
vortex distributions within the strip. In order to fit our data
quantitatively, we have calculated the current distribution
and vortex entry conditions for thin-film strips in which the
thin-film transverse penetration depth is comparable to the
strip width, the regime appropriate for our samples and most
relevant for typical thin-film superconductor devices.
Using standard photolithographic processing and Ar ion
milling, we fabricated strips ranging in width from 10 to
40 m from 200 nm thick films of amorphous MoGe. Films
were sputter deposited onto silicon substrates and had the
following properties: superconducting transition temperature
T
c
=6.5 K, normal state resistivity
n
=180 cm, and
critical field slope dB
c 2
/ dT |
T
c
=2.8 T/K. The superconduct-
ing transition-metal glasses have been studied extensively
because of their weak vortex pinning,
10
typically exhibiting
bulk critical current densities less than 10
4
A/cm
2
at low
magnetic fields, several orders of magnitude lower than most
superconducting materials. Because of the short electronic
PHYSICAL REVIEW B, VOLUME 64, 014503
0163-1829/2001/641/0145036/$20.00 ©2001 The American Physical Society 64 014503-1