Reductive electrolysis of [60]fullerene mono-methanoadducts in THF leads to
the formation of bis-adducts in high yields
Marcel W. J. Beulen,
a
Jos´ e A. Rivera,
b
M.
´
Angeles Herranz,
c ´
Angel Mart´ ın-Domenech
c
Nazario Mart´ ın*
c
and
Luis Echegoyen*
a
a
Department of Chemistry and Center for Supramolecular Science, University of Miami, Coral Gables, Florida
33124, USA. E-mail: echegoyen@miami.edu
b
Department of Chemistry, Pontifical Catholic University of Puerto Rico, Ponce, Puerto Rico 00731, USA
c
Departamento de Qu´ ımica Org´ anica, Facultad de Ciencias Qu´ ımicas, Universidad Complutense, E-28040-Madrid,
Spain
Received (in Columbia, MO, USA) 30th October 2000, Accepted 19th January 2001
First published as an Advance Article on the web 9th February 2001
A new reaction, electrolytically induced adduct transfer
between [60]fullerene mono-adducts, leads to bis-adducts
with a unique regioisomer distribution.
Cyclopropanation of fullerenes by the addition of malonate
derivatives (the Bingel reaction) has been widely used for the
preparation of fullerene adducts.
1
The groups of Diederich and
Echegoyen reported the reverse of this reaction, the retro-Bingel
reaction, an electrolytic reduction reaction performed in
dichloromethane, which efficiently removes di[alkoxycarbo-
nyl]methano (Bingel) adducts to yield the parent fullerene (see
Scheme 1).
2
The ‘Bingel–retro-Bingel’ strategy as a protection–
deprotection scheme has already found several uses in fullerene
chemistry, such as the isolation of enantiomerically pure C
76
2a
and of a new C
2v
-C
78
bis-adduct,
2b
and in the separation of
constitutional isomers of C
84
.
2c
The groups of Diederich and
Echegoyen also described a chemical retro-Bingel reaction
(using Mg/Hg, THF, heat) which also efficiently removes the
Bingel addends.
3
Very recently we reported that the range of fullerene adducts
that can be removed via electrolytic reduction is not limited to
di[alkoxycarbonyl]methano adducts (see fullerene 3), but
includes those present in structures 1 and 2 (Scheme 1).
Controlled potential electrolysis (CPE) in dichloromethane
after the first (2) and third (1) electrochemical reduction wave
induces the efficient removal of the adducts, to form the parent
C
60
.
4
While electrolytic reduction can lead to the efficient removal
of the adducts mentioned, it has been shown that methano-
adduct formation can also result from the reaction between
electrolytically prepared fullerene anions and dihalo-com-
pounds, even with dichloromethane.
5
Dichloromethane reacts
efficiently with the [60]fullerene trianion to form methano-
fullerenes of the type C
60
> (CH
2
)
n
,
5b
and forms similar adducts
with C
84
[C
84
> (CH
2
)
n
] during the reductive retro-Bingel
reaction of di[alkoxycarbonyl]methano-adducts of C
84
.
2c
In
order to avoid these reactions and to further explore the
potential and mechanism of the electrolytic methods of
fullerene adduct removal, we decided to investigate the
electrolysis of compounds 1–3 in THF. In the process we found
an electrochemically induced intermolecular reaction that leads
to the formation of multiple fullerene adducts.
6
The cyclic voltammograms of the methanofullerenes 1 and 2
in THF are shown in Fig. 1.
7
These compounds exhibit
irreversible electrochemistry in THF, similar to that observed in
dichloromethane. Compound 1 exhibits, in addition to several
reversible electrochemical processes, an irreversible reduction
process between the first and third reduction potentials whilst 2
undergoes an initial two-electron reduction, followed by a one-
electron reduction. The irreversible behavior presumably results
from the cleavage of one of the cyclopropane bonds connecting
the addend to C
60
after reduction.
8
Compounds 1 and 2 were subjected to CPE in 0.1 M
NBu
4
PF
6
–THF and the products were separated and analyzed.
CPE of 1 was performed at ca. 100–150 mV more cathodic than
the third, reversible, reduction wave (Fig. 1, arrow a); 2.7
electrons per molecule were discharged and clear changes in the
CV and OSWV were observed, indicating that a chemical
reaction had taken place. Subsequent re-oxidation at 0 V and
purification of the product mixture by column chromatography
(eluent: toluene) yielded fullerene products in ca. 91% yield.
Analysis of this mixture by HPLC, UV–VIS spectroscopy, and
MALDI-TOF spectrometry clearly showed the formation of C
60
as the main product (41%). Thus reductive electrochemistry
removes the addend in THF (as also observed in CH
2
Cl
2
),
leading to the formation of C
60
. A second fraction (39%)
containing the starting material 1 was also recovered. Inter-
estingly and unexpectedly, a third fraction (11%) with a higher
polarity was also isolated. Analysis showed this fraction to be
composed of the bis-adducts: fullerenes with two spiro-
anthraquinone groups attached (MALDI-TOF: m/z 1104).
CPE of 2 in THF was performed after the first two-electron
reduction wave (Fig. 1, arrow b), and 1.8 electrons per molecule
were discharged. Re-oxidation and purification yielded 81% of
fullerene products, consisting of 40% C
60
, 27% recovered 2,
and 14% of bis-adducts. Adduct removal is also the main
Scheme 1 Protective group system for fullerenes: synthesis of methano-
fullerenes 1–3 and subsequent adduct removal by reductive electro-
chemistry. Fig. 1 Cyclic voltammograms of 1 and 2 in THF.
This journal is © The Royal Society of Chemistry 2001
DOI: 10.1039/b008769f Chem. Commun., 2001, 407–408 407