Research Article
Prediction of Moderate and Heavy Rainfall in New Zealand
Using Data Assimilation and Ensemble
Yang Yang, Phillip Andrews, Trevor Carey-Smith, Michael Uddstrom, and Mike Revell
National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research (NIWA), Private Bag 14901, Wellington 6021, New Zealand
Correspondence should be addressed to Yang Yang; y.yang@niwa.co.nz
Received 7 December 2014; Accepted 5 February 2015
Academic Editor: Yuanfu Xie
Copyright © 2015 Yang Yang et al. Tis is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License,
which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Tis numerical weather prediction study investigates the efects of data assimilation and ensemble prediction on the forecast
accuracy of moderate and heavy rainfall over New Zealand. In order to ascertain the optimal implementation of state-of-the-art
3Dvar and 4Dvar data assimilation techniques, 12 diferent experiments have been conducted for the period from 13 September to
18 October 2010 using the New Zealand limited area model. Verifcation has shown that an ensemble based on these experiments
outperforms all of the individual members using a variety of metrics. In addition, the rainfall occurrence probability derived
from the ensemble is a good predictor of heavy rainfall. Mountains signifcantly afect the performance of this ensemble which
provides better forecasts of heavy rainfall over the South Island than over the North Island. Analysis suggests that underestimation
of orographic lifing due to the relatively low resolution of the model (∼12 km) is a factor leading to this variability in heavy rainfall
forecast skill. Tis study indicates that regional ensemble prediction with a suitably fne model resolution (≤5 km) would be a useful
tool for forecasting heavy rainfall over New Zealand.
1. Introduction
Te initial conditions of a numerical weather prediction
(NWP) forecast are usually generated by data assimilation, a
procedure statistically combining observations and a model
forecast and utilising their respective error information to
create an optimum estimate of the true atmospheric state
compatible with the forecast model in use. Uncertainty and
errors are unavoidable in the initial conditions of an NWP
due to meteorological equipment errors, sampling errors, and
data assimilation errors, and so forth. Ensemble forecasts
have been used for some 20 years at major meteorological
prediction centres to explore the impact of these uncertainties
in the atmospheric initial conditions (and other boundary
conditions) on NWP. Several methodologies have been used
to establish the global ensemble systems (GES) including
those based on the leading singular vectors of the operator
[1, 2], bred vectors [3, 4], the Monte Carlo method [5], and
the Monte Carlo based ensemble Kalman flter [6].
Te spatial resolution of currently operational GES is low
(e.g., ∼32 km for the current operational ECMWF ensemble
system). Many small scale processes in the atmosphere
and the underlying surface and small scale mountains that
signifcantly afect the evolution and development of severe
weather are not resolved by GES. Regional ensemble systems
(RES) were thus established. Te resolution of RES difers.
Some have very high resolutions so that supercell storms and
convections can be resolved (e.g., [7–9]). Te way to initialize
a RES also difers. Some RESs are initialized from a GES.
Some RESs randomly sample the climatological uncertainties
of the initial state [10]. Others derive random perturbations
from the background error statistics of an existing 3D/4Dvar
system (e.g., [11–13]). Some RESs use diferent model physics
and diferent global deterministic model outputs to generate
members (e.g., [14, 15]). Some use diferent regional model
outputs called multimodel ensemble [16]. For heavy rainfall
forecasts, RES has shown higher forecasting skills than GES
(e.g., [14, 17, 18]).
New Zealand lies in the midlatitude southwest Pacifc,
surrounded by ocean. Te two main islands are North Island
and South Island. North Island (Figure 1(a)) has a “spine”
of mountain ranges extending from the middle, with gentle
rolling farmland on both sides. Te South Island is dominated
by mountain ranges running its entire length. Te main
Hindawi Publishing Corporation
Advances in Meteorology
Volume 2015, Article ID 460243, 14 pages
http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2015/460243