Biochemica/SystemaEcs and Ecology, Vol. 14, No. 6, pp. 597-602, 1986. 0305-1978/86 $3.00+0.00
Printed in GreatBritain. © 1986Pergamon JournalsLtd.
Patterns in the Phytochemistry of Three Prairie Plants
RICHARD L. LINDROTH*~, GEORGE O. BA3-ZLI* and DAVID S. SEIGLERt
*Ecology Program and Department of Ecology, Ethology and Evolution, Universi~ of Illinois, Urbana, IL 61801, U.S.A.;
1"Department of Plant Biology, Universiw of Illinois, Urbana, IL 61801, U.S.A.
Key Word Index--Andropogon gerardii; Pensternon digitalis; Lespedeza cuneata; Microtus pennsylvanicus; protein; phenolics;
alkaloids; boschniakine; seasonal patterns.
Abstract--From 1980 to 1983 we monitored seasonal variation in leaf qualib/of three species of prairie plants; characteristics
selected are known to influence feeding by herbivores. Leaf water and protein content generally declined with age in each
species. Total and protein-binding phenolics declined with age in Andropogon gerardil; peaked in summer in Lespedeza cuneata,
changed little or increased with age in Penstemon digitalis and were negatively correlated with protein content in Lespedeza and
Penstemon. The alkaloid (boschniakine) content of Penstemon leaves showed consistent seasonal declines and was positively
correlated with leaf protein but negatively correlated with leaf phenolics. Patterns in the phytochemistry of Penstemon fit the
predictions of the plant apparency model, but those of Andropogon and Lespedeza do not. Seasonal patterns in the phyto-
chemistry of these plants are most likely the product of still largely unknown physiological constraints on primary and secondary
metabolism and the risks and costs of herbivory through time.
Introduction
The chemical defence system of a plant is
influenced by the plant's requirement for effec-
tive defence (including, for example, the risk and
cost of herbivory) and its physiological pro-
cesses and constraints (e.g. resource availability
and competitive interaction between primary
and secondary metabolic pathways). These
factors and subsequent allocation of plant
photosynthates to various contingencies change
over time [1, 2]. Thus herbivores, particularly
generalists, are confronted with a constantly
changing mosaic of food items of different
quality. Such seasonal changes in forage quality
in turn affect consumption patterns [3-6] and
population densities [7-9] of herbivores.
Developmental changes in the levels of
nutrients and allelochemicals have been
reported from many plants, particularly ferns
[10, 11] and woody angiosperms [2, 5, 12-16];
much less is known about seasonal variation in
the phytochemistry of herbaceous angiosperms.
Here we document the annual and seasonal
changes in several leaf quality characteristics of
three tallgrass prairie plants, big bluestem
~:Present address: Department of Entomology, 237 Russell
Laboratories, 1630 Linden Drive, Madison, Wl 53706, U.S.A.
(Received for publication 10 June 1986)
(Andropogon gerardil), bush-clover (Lespedeza
cuneata) and foxglove penstemon (Penstemon
digitalis), and relate our findings to current
theories of plant defensive chemistry.
Andropogon is a perennial grass, Lespedeza is
a perennial leguminous forb and Penstemon is a
biennial forb. In east-central Illinois these plants
commence growth in late April to early May,
senesce by mid- to late-September and are the
major foodplants of the meadow vole (Microtus
pennsylvanicus) during the growing season [17].
A preliminary screening procedure showed that
all of the plants contain phenolic compounds
(Lespedeza contains condensed tannins) and
Penstemon produces alkaloids [18]. The data
presented here were collected as part of a study
investigating the effects of grazing by voles on
the levels of secondary compounds in their food
plants. We found no such influence of meadow
voles on their food [18, 19].
Results
Levels of water and protein in Andropogon
showed consistent seasonal patterns from year
to year, decreasing rapidly from spring to
summer (9 and 8% drop on average, for water
and protein, respectively) and slightly, if at all,
from summer to autumn (Fig. 1). Levels of total
and protein-complexing phenolics also tended
597