|
Eur J Health Econom 4 · 2003 304
Countries all over the world are facing
important issues of health care organiza-
tion, cost, financing, and quality, one be-
ing the appropriate level of per capita fi-
nancing for defined populations. While
age and gender are important predictors
of future health care needs, these predic-
tions can be improved by considering the
previous health problems of the popula-
tion so that the various insurance plans
do not have incentives for selective enroll-
ment of healthy individuals and avoiding
those with health problems [1]. For in-
stance,in the United States the Center for
Medicare and Medicaid Services is using
principal inpatient (PIP) diagnostic cost
groups (PIP-DCGs) [2], a measure that is
defined by clinical conditions in the pre-
vious year, to account for patient risk in
the Medicare health maintenance organi-
zation population.
While the health districts in Italy are
geographically based and not subject to
selective enrollment, it is nevertheless im-
portant that the criteria for financing the
health districts adequately account for
population differences so that care pro-
grams may be equitably planned and im-
plemented to meet specific population
needs. The Italian National Health Service
guarantees universal access to health care
to 57 million Italians. Each of the 20 Ital-
ian regions has the responsibility for pro-
viding care to residents of the region.
Funding flows from the central govern-
ment to the regions with an increasing
emphasis on regional taxation. The re-
gions in turn have delegated major re-
Original Papers
Elaine J.Yuen
1
· Daniel Z. Louis
1
· Paolo Di Loreto
2
· Joseph S. Gonnella
1
1
Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, Pa., USA ·
2
Regione Umbria, Italy
Modeling risk-adjusted
capitation rates
for Umbria, Italy
sponsibility to geographically defined Lo-
cal Health Units. As a part of the decen-
tralization of responsibility for providing
health care, the Local Health Units have
been further divided into geographically
defined health districts, typically with a
population of 50,000–100,000. A major
challenge with the creation of health dis-
tricts to assure that appropriate financing
is provided to meet the needs of the pop-
ulation [3]. Currently the allocation of re-
sources from the regions to the Local
Health Units is based on a formula which
takes into account age, gender, and mor-
tality data.
Methods and materials
Study objective
The purpose of this project with the re-
gion of Umbria was to study the effect of
refining per capita financing by risk ad-
justment in an Italian population.Adjust-
ment on the basis of age and gender as
well as severity of illness was studied. Dis-
ease Staging risk adjustment measures
were used. We had two major study ob-
jectives: (a) to collect and compile data
from an entire population in the region
of Umbria and (b) to estimate and test risk
adjustment factors using models based
upon Disease Staging in this population.
Data sources
Data consisted of 2 years of hospital data
(1997–1998), 2 years of outpatient phar-
maceutical data (1997–1998), and 1 year of
demographic data (1998) from the region
of Umbria. Hospital data were from the
Italian hospital discharge abstract (Sche-
da di Dimissione Ospedaliera, SDO) and
included inpatient admissions as well as
day hospital episodes. Pharmacy data were
from the paid pharmacy claims and cap-
tured information at the individual’s pre-
scription level.As data were provided by
the regional health services agency in Um-
bria which was responsible for payment of
health services for the entire Umbrian
population, we obtained information data
on Umbrian residents who sought care in
other regions as well as Umbria residents
hospitalized in Umbria.
Data on hospital SDO files included di-
agnosis-related groups (DRGs) and DRG-
based tariffs, ICD-9 CM codes (which had
been converted in Italy from the Interna-
tional Classification of Diseases, 9th edn.),
and demographic information. Hospital
payments included both facility and phy-
sician reimbursements. The pharmacy
files included individual prescriptions,
drug codes, tariffs, and copayments. For
both hospital and pharmacy records the
costs were estimated by tariffs, the amount
reimbursed by the region for health care
services, as there is no cost accounting
system in place in Italy at the present time.
Tariffs were reported in Italian lira in the
data, but for purposes of reporting these
have been converted to euros.
Demographic data were from region-
al files kept for all Umbrian residents and
included unique identifiers such as health
Eur J Health Econom 2003 · 4:304–312
DOI 10.1007/s10198-003-0193-2
Online publiziert: 15. August 2003
© Springer-Verlag 2003