World J Urol (1993) 11:178- 182
Free paper
1
World Journal of ~'
Urology
© Springer-Verlag 1993
Clinical experience with multiagent intravesical therapy
in interstitial cystitis patients unresponsive to single-agent therapy
G.M. Ghoniem, D. McBride, O.P. Sood, and V. Lewis
Department of Urology, Tulane University School of Medicine, 1430 Tulane Avenue, New Orleans, LA 70112, USA
Summary. A total of 25 patients with the diagnosis of in-
terstitial cystitis (IC) were involved in this study. All pa-
tients had been previously diagnosed with interstitial
cystitis and had received treatment with single intravesical
agents. Patients were divided into two groups according
to their bladder capacity. The bladder capacity was
>350 ml in group I patients and <350 ml in group II
patients. For our study, dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO),
methylprednisolone, and heparin sulfate were given every
week for a total of 6 weeks. When symptoms recurred,
supportive oral pharmacotherapy consisting of an-
ticholinergics and/or tricyclic antidepressants was given.
Under anesthesia, patients in group I showed a 99% in-
crease in their bladder capacity; whereas those in group
II showed an increase of only 19%. Cystoscopically,
Hunner's ulcers were present in 60°7o of the group II pa-
tients but were seen in only 5% of the group I patients.
Histopathological examination showed that the inflam-
matory changes were more frequent and severe in group
II than in group I. Mast-cell hyperplasia was present in
100% of the patients in group II, versus only 61% of
those in group I. A total of 23 patients (92%) achieved
an initial remission averaging 8.1 months. In all, 9 pa-
tients (35°7o) had 1 or more relapses, and all achieved a
subsequent remission averaging 8 months. By this com-
bined multiagent approach, the majority of patients with
IC obtained relief from their incapacitating symptoms
and were socially rehabilitated.
Few diseases prove as difficult to diagnose and as difficult
to treat as interstitial cystitis (IC). Afflicted patients suf-
fer from incapacitating urgency, frequency, nocturia, and
pain. Quality-of-life scores measured in these patients
Correspondence to GM. Ghoniem, M.D., EA.C.S.
have been lower than those recorded for patients with
chronic renal disease [1]. Patients are understandably
frustrated when told they have a disease of unknown eti-
ology, a disease with no cure. Since the exact etiology and
a specific cure are as yet unknown, we developed a proto-
col that uses intravesical multiagent therapy supplement-
ed by oral medications as needed. An essential part of the
program is a group of supportive compassionate person-
nel, incuding physicians and nurses who can translate
their own confidence into optimism and hope for these
desperate patients.
The problems of IC in women are estimated to occur
in between 18 and 36 per 100,000. The female-to-male ra-
tio is 10 to 1 and the average age at diagnosis is between
40 and 50 years [2]. Very few blacks have been diagnosed
with IC. The average interval from the onset of symptoms
to diagnosis has been 24-51 months; this interval has re-
cently been reduced due to more awareness of physicians
and patients with the disease. Although the majority of
patients are middle-aged and white women, both children
and the elderly may be afflicted. Several etiological theo-
ries have been proposed. Among those that have been ex-
plored are infections [3, 4], exposure to toxic substances
in the urine [5], autoimmune disease [6-11], hypersensi-
tivity reaction to local stimulants [12, 13], neurogenic or
vascular inflammation [14-18], and psychosomatic ori-
gin [19, 20]. Despite much research, the etiology remains
elusive. Considerable attention has focused on the possi-
bility that the protective glycosaminoglycan (GAG) lining
the transitional epithelium leaks, allowing toxic substanc-
es to penetrate the deeper layers and induce an inflamma-
tory response [21- 23]. Nonetheless, the reported success
of heparin-like agents seems logically based on their abil-
ity to simulate this GAG-defense layer [24, 25]. Addition-
ally, the success of the time-tested dimethylsulfoxide
(DMSO) in the treatment of IC probably lies in its anti-
inflammatory properties.
Our goal in this study was to evaluate multiagent in-
travesical therapy to induce remission of the disease in
patients who did not respond to previous single-agent
therapy.