Australian Health Review April 2007 Vol 31 Suppl 1 S13
System Observations
Aust Health Rev ISSN: 0156-5788 1 April
2007 31 Suppl 1 S13-S15
©Aust Health Rev 2007 www.aushealthre-
view.com.au
System Observations
Abstract
In advocating for significant reform of the health
care system, the Australian Health Care Reform
Alliance (AHCRA) supports a process of citizen
engagement that will allow the wider community to
have a say in the future direction of their health
care system. Models that have engaged commu-
nity opinions have been successful overseas, and
Aust Health Rev 2007: 31 Suppl 1: S13–S15
this article calls for similar processes in Australia.
COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT TECHNIQUES have
been carried out in Australia on a small scale.
Government commitment is required to establish a
rigorous and systematic national consultation
process. This is especially important when crucial
decisions about the future of our health care
system need to be made. We believe this is the first
step in the journey to health reform.
The need for reform
There is a chronic shortage of doctors, nurses and
other health professionals, especially in rural and
remote areas. Australia has the resources to train
more health professionals, yet we are increasingly
relying more on overseas-trained doctors and
nurses. Twenty five per cent of all doctors working
in Australia are trained overseas and, increasingly,
nurses from overseas are relied on to address
Australia’s skills shortages.
1,2
There is sound evi-
dence that we have the resources to train more
health professionals. According to the 2005 United
Nations Human Development Report, Australia is
ranked third of 177 countries in economic per-
formance.
3
The Australian health system has insufficient
focus on prevention and primary care, but, most
critically, we have an increasingly fragmented sys-
tem with inefficient allocation of government
resources due to the state–federal funding struc-
ture. The reform which the Australian Health Care
Reform Alliance (AHCRA) advocates involves
adopting a new approach which considers these
failings and engages stakeholders which have pre-
viously not been consulted. It involves undertak-
ing a holistic approach instead of small sectoral
changes. The nature of the reform needs to con-
sider the views of consumers and the community
to ensure reform meets communities’ needs.
Why consult the community?
AHCRA considers that reform of the health care
system needs to consider the views of those who
use health services and whose taxes are used to
support the system. The community contributes to
the government’s purse and should have a say as to
how that money is spent.
As articulated by the Health Canada Policy
Toolkit, citizen engagement is described as the
“public’s involvement in determining how a society
steers itself, makes decisions on major public
Tony McBride, CEO; and member of AHCRA Executive
Viola Korczak, Health Policy Officer, CHOICE; and
member of AHCRA Executive
Health Issues Centre, Melbourne, VIC.
Correspondence: Ms Viola Korczak, Health Issues Centre,
Level 5, Health Sciences 2, Latrobe University, Victoria,
Melbourne, VIC 3086. vkorczak@choice.com.au
Community consultation and engagement in
health care reform
Tony McBride and Viola Korczak
AHCRA
The Australian Health Care Reform Alliance is a
group of 46 consumer, clinical and academic
organisations committed to health reform. This
paper is based on “Paper IV: Community
Consultation and Engagement”, one of five papers
forming a submission to the Council of Australian
Governments, November 2005.