J Neurol (2002) 249 : 529 – 534
© Steinkopff Verlag 2002 ORIGINAL COMMUNICATION
S. Thobois
P. Mertens
M. Guenot
M. Hermier
H. Mollion
M. Bouvard
G. Chazot
E. Broussolle
M. Sindou
Subthalamic nucleus stimulation
in Parkinson’s disease
Clinical evaluation of 18 patients
Introduction
Long-term treatment of Parkinson’s disease (PD) with
levodopa is complicated by motor fluctuations and
dyskinesias. This explains the renewed interest in surgi-
cal approaches during the last decade [15, 16, 23, 24].
Studies in a non-human primates model of PD reveal
that lesions or high frequency stimulation of the sub-
thalamic nucleus (STN) reduce overactivity of this brain
JON 663
■ Abstract The aim of the present
study was to assess the efficacy and
safety of chronic subthalamic nu-
cleus deep-brain stimulation (STN-
DBS) in patients with Parkinson’s
disease (PD). 18 consecutive se-
verely affected PD patients were
included (mean age, SD: 56.9±6
years; mean disease duration:
13.5±4.4 years). All the patients
Received: 30 May 2001
Received in revised form:
21 September 2001
Accepted: 26 September 2001
Dr. S. Thobois () · H. Mollion ·
M. Bouvard · G. Chazot · E. Broussolle
Service de Neurologie D
Hopital Neurologique Pierre Wertheimer
59 Bd Pinel
69003 Lyon, France
Tel.: +33-4/72 35-72 18
Fax: +33-4/7235-7351
E-Mail: stephane.thobois@chu-lyon.fr
P. Mertens · M. Guenot · M. Sindou
Department of Neurosurgery A
Neurological Hospital Pierre Wertheimer
Lyon, France
M. Hermier
Department of Neuroradiology
Neurological Hospital Pierre Wertheimer
Lyon, France
were evaluated clinically before
and 6 months after the surgical
procedure using the Unified
Parkinson’s Disease Rating Scale
(UPDRS). Additionally, a 12
months follow-up was available in
14 patients. The target coordinates
were determined by ventriculogra-
phy under stereotactic conditions,
followed by electrophysiology and
intraoperative stimulation. After
surgery, continuous monopolar
stimulation was applied bilaterally
in 17 patients at 2.9 ± 0.4 V through
1 (n = 31) or 2 contacts (n = 3).
One patient had bilateral bipolar
stimulation. The mean frequency
of stimulation was 140 ± 16 Hz and
pulse width 68 ± 13 μs. Off medica-
tion, the UPDRS part III score
(max = 108) was reduced by 55 %
during on stimulation (score before
surgery: 44.9 ± 13.4 vs at 6 months:
20.2 ± 10; p < 0.001). In the on med-
ication state, no difference was
noted between the preoperative
and the postoperative off stimula-
tion conditions (scores were re-
spectively: 17.9 ± 9.2 and 23 ± 12.6).
The severity of motor fluctuations
and dyskinesias assessed by UP-
DRS IV was reduced by 76% at 6
months (scores were respectively:
10.3 ± 3 and 2.5 ± 3; p < 0.001). Off
medication, the UPDRS II or ADL
score was reduced by 52.8% during
on stimulation (26.9±6.5 preop ver-
sus 12.7 ± 7 at 6 months). The daily
dose of antiparkinsonian treatment
was diminished by 65.5 % (levo-
dopa equivalent dose – mg/D – was
1045 ± 435 before surgery and 360
± 377 at 6 months; p < 0.01). These
results remained stable at 12
months for the 14 patients studied.
Side effects comprised lower limb
phlebitis (n = 2), pulmonary em-
bolism (n = 1), depression (n = 6),
dysarthria and freezing (n = 1),
sialorrhea and drooling (n = 1),
postural imbalance (n = 1), tran-
sient paresthesias and dyskinesias.
This study confirms the great value
of subthalamic nucleus stimulation
in the treatment of intractable PD.
Some adverse events such as de-
pression may be taken into account
in the inclusion criteria and also in
the post-operative outcome.
■ Key words Parkinson’s disease ·
neurosurgery · subthalamic
nucleus · deep brain stimulation ·
UPDRS · depression