MELVIN EMBER
CAROL R. EMBER
Human Relations Area Files, Inc. at Yale University
New Haven, CT 06511
Cross-Language Predictors of Consonant-Vowel Syllables
In this paper we discuss cross-language findings that open up a new window onto language-culture relationships. The lan-
guages of the world vary considerably in the degree to which the syllables of a word are consonant-vowel (CV) in form. A
previous cross-cultural study (Munroe et al. 1996) found that CV score (the percentage of CV syllables in the average
word) can vary across languages from less than 20% to more than 80%. That study described theory and evidence linking
high percentages of CV syllables to warmer climates and the absence of literacy. The theory and evidence offered here
suggests that another factor—degree of baby-holding—is more predictive of CV scores than either climate or literacy.
Mean number of syllables per word is also a predictor of CV scores. Other possible predictors that could be tested experi-
mentally and otherwise are discussed, [cross-cultural, cross-language, morphology, syllables, baby-holding]
E
ver since the days of Edward Sapir and Benjamin
Lee Whorf, and probably even before, anthropolo-
gists have investigated and debated various rela-
tionships between language and culture. Recent times have
seen several noteworthy publications, among them the fol-
lowing. Charles Hockett (1985) reported a correlation be-
tween mode of subsistence and the occurrence of the sound
"f' in a sample of languages around the world. Cecil
Brown and Stanley Witkowski (1980; Brown 1984) pub-
lished numerous studies over the years showing strong as-
sociations between linguistic phenomena—mostly involv-
ing the lexicon as opposed to phonology or grammar—and
cultural variables. And, of course, who can ignore Brent
Berlin and Paul Kay's (1969) famous observation that size
of basic color vocabulary is positively correlated with so-
cial complexity? (See also Ember 1978.) In this paper, we
discuss results from cross-cultural studies that may stimu-
late a new direction in language-culture research—on the
determinants of the degree to which the words in a lan-
guage are composed of consonant-vowel (CV) syllables.
Despite the fact that the consonant-vowel syllable is
"the most common type of syllable in the world's lan-
guages" (Macaulay 1994:220, as cited in Munroe et al.
1996), languages vary considerably in the degree to which
syllables are con sonant-vowel (CV) in form. As scored by
Munroe et al. (1996), some languages have a relatively low
percentage of CV syllables in the average word (less than
20%); in other languages, more than 80% of the syllables
in the average word have the CV form. The language of the
Samoan Islands, where the fust author did fieldwork, is an
example of the latter. In some languages, such as Samoan,
nearly every syllable starts with a consonant and ends with
a vowel. The Samoan preference for CV syllables is strik-
ing. In English, the word Christmas has two syllables in
speech. The first syllable is CCVC in form, pronounced as
"Kris." The second syllable is CVC in form, pronounced as
"muss." In Samoan, the word for Christmas (Kerisimasi)
has five syllables, all CV in form, pronounced as "Keh-ree-
see-mah-see."
1
Munroe et al. (1996) present theory and
evidence linking high percentages of CV syllables to
wanner climates and the absence of literacy. Here we pre-
sent theory and evidence for a third factor—degree of
baby-holding. This third factor is the strongest predictor of
cross-language variation in CV scores. Multiple regression
analysis reveals that baby-holding is a stronger predictor of
CV scores than climate or literacy. We also find that mean
number of syllables per word is a predictor as well. In the
concluding section of this paper, we discuss other possible
predictors that might be tested in future studies, and how
they could be tested—experimentally (in the field and in
the laboratory) as well as by ethnohistorical, cross-histori-
cal, and cross-cultural studies. Whatever the outcomes of
future studies, the findings discussed here show that the de-
gree to which the syllables of a word are CV in form is
measurable and predictable across the languages of the
world.
Previous Theory and Results
The major finding in Munroe et al. (1996) is that wanner
climates are associated with higher CV scores. This asso-
ciation, which was tested on a sample of 53 societies, was
derived from the Munroe et al. theory about communica-
tive efficiency. Referred to hereafter as the "Munroe theory,"
this theory suggests that the conditions or requirements of
American Anthropologist 101 (4):730-742. Copyright © 2000. American Anthropological Association