Plant and Soil 139: 139-143, 1992
© 1992 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands. PLSO 8905
Effects of starch additions on N turnover in Sitka spruce forest floor
JOSHUAP. SCHIMEL, STEFAN HELFER 1 and IAN J. ALEXANDER
Institute of Arctic Biology, University of Alaska, Fairbanks, AK 99775, USA and Department of
Plant and Soil Science, University of Aberdeen, Aberdeen, AB9 2UE, Scotland. Present address:
1Royal Botanic Garden, Edinburgh, EH3 5LR, Scotland
Received 28 September 1990. Revised July 1991
Key words: carbon, catabolite repression, mineralization, N cycling, starch
Abstract
Starch and carboxymethyl starch were added to forest floor samples collected from a sitka spruce stand
near Aberdeen, Scotland. Samples were incubated for one month and were periodically analyzed for
respiration, biomass-C, net and gross N-mineralization/immobilization. Gross mineralization/immobili-
zation was measured by using a 15N-isotope pool dilution technique. Starch additions did not
significantly affect respiration rates or biomass-C but caused net immobilization. The mechanism of this
appeared to be inhibition of the decomposition of N-containing soil organic matter by the available
starch-C, which resulted in decreased gross mineralization. Carboxymethyl starch acted as a biocide,
probably as a result of an osmotic effect.
Introduction
It has normally been found that adding available
carbon to soil causes net nitrogen immobilization
by soil microbes (Jones and Richards, 1978).
However, Harmer and Alexander (1986) re-
ported an exception to this pattern in that potato
starch caused net mineralization when it was
added to forest floor material from a range of
conifers or to Sitka spruce (Picea sitchensis) for-
est floor in the field. The data suggested that
available energy may have limited the degra-
dation of N-containing compounds in the forest
floor. Such interactions between organic com-
pounds complicates our understanding of soil
organic matter dynamics and particularly the role
of C vs. N limitation in them (Johnson and
Edwards, 1979; Schimel and Firestone, 1989).
To examine more closely the mechanism in-
volved, further laboratory incubations using
analytical-grade starch were performed on the
same forest floor materials. In this case N im-
mobilization was observed, rather than miner-
alization. We subsequently discovered that the
potato starch used in the original studies by
Harmer and Alexander (1986), which had been
supplied for a large field experiment, was in fact
'Stabilose' (Avebe Veendam Ltd., Foxhol,
Netherlands), a form of carboxymethyl starch.
We therefore examined the different effects of
starch and carboxymethyl starch on C and N
dynamics in Sitka spruce forest floor material.
We measured changes in microbial biomass, res-
piration, and N dynamics by using ~SN pool
dilution methodology (Kirkham and Barth-
olomew, 1954) to estimate gross mineralization
and immobilization independently, and so sepa-
rate the components of net mineralization and N
turnover.
Methods
The study site was in a 40-year-old Sitka spruce
stand in Durris forest near Aberdeen, Scotland.
The soil is an acid brown forest soil (dystroch-