The relationship of selected fabric
characteristics and the barrier
effectiveness of surgical gown fabrics
Karen K. Leonas, PhD a
Renita S. Jinkins, PhD b
Athens and Atlanta, Georgia
Background: Relationships between selected fabric characteristics and the barrier
effectiveness of surgical gown fabrics to liquid strike-through and bacterial transmission
were examined.
Methods: Eight commercially available surgical gowns were evaluated in this study. Five of
the gowns were disposable and were produced from nonwoven fabrics. Three of the gowns
were reusable and were produced from woven fabrics. Standard test methods were used to
evaluate the fabrics. Fabric characteristics evaluated included thickness, weight, pore size,
and oil and water repellency. Yarn count was determined for the woven fabrics to establish
the number of yarns per inch in both the warp (lengthwise) and fill (crosswise) fabric
direction. Resistance of the fabrics to the penetration of microorganism suspensions under
a hydrostatic pressure was determined. Microorganisms used in this study were
Escherichia coli and Staphylococcus aureus. Scanning electron micrographs are presented
to illustrate differences among fabrics.
Results: Results of this study showed that fabric characteristics of construction, repellency,
and pore size contributed to gown performance. Liquid strike-through was not always
accompanied by bacterial transmission.
Conclusions: Higher fabric repellency ratings and smaller pore size generally corresponded
with higher barrier properties. (AJIC Am J Infect Control 1997;25:16-23)
The transference of pathogens through body
fluids recently has received much attention. The
Occupational Safety and Health Administration,
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and
the Association of Operating Room Nurses have
published guidelines to help health care workers
reduce their risk of occupational exposure. 1-3 A
key factor in these recommendations is the use of
protective surgical apparel as a barrier to micro-
bial transfer. The barrier properties of the fabrics
are determined by fabric characteristics, the bac-
From the University of Georgia,a Athens, Georgia, and Amoco
Fabrics and Fibers Companyp Atlanta.
Supported by Kimberly-Clark Corporation, Professional Health
Care.
Reprint requests: Karen K. Leonas, PhD, 314 Dawson Hall, The
University of Georgia, Athens, GA 30602.
Copyright Ā© 1997 by the Association for Professionals in Infection
Control and Epidemiology, Inc.
0196-6553/97 $5.00 + 0 17146174303
teria, and characteristics of the bacteria-contain-
ing fluid.
Bacteria are believed to be transported from
one location to another by carriers such as dust or
liquids. 4,s In the operating theater, fluids such as
blood, perspiration, and alcohol act as carriers
transporting the bacteria through the fabric.
Small particles such as skin cells and lint also may
act as carriers. 6,7 Therefore one must consider the
barrier fabric's effectiveness in preventing trans-
mission of the carrier and of the bacteria.
Many studies have been conducted in the labo-
ratory and in the operating room to evaluate the
effectiveness of various surgical gowns as barriers
to microbial transmission¢ ,s-ll Little attention has
been given to specific characteristics of the fabric
in the gown. There is a need to more specifically
identify the fabric parameters that control trans-
mission. Researchers have identified fabric con-
struction and repellency as critical characteris-
tics, 5,8,9 but few details about these characteristics
have been addressed. In addition, other fabric
characteristics known to influence barrier proper-
16