Bottom-up vs Top-down Model: The Perception
of Reading Strategies among Thai University
Students
Prathomwat Suraprajit
Faculty of Management Sciences, Kasetsart University, Thailand
Abstract—Reading strategies have been declared as a vital role in reading comprehension among the students
whose English is their second or foreign language. The use of reading strategies would help the learners to
deeper understand the text so that they could achieve their tasks. The present study then investigates the use of
reading strategies by focusing on the bottom-up and top-down models for both academic and business texts
among Thai students in tertiary level. Two hundred-seventy non-simple random undergraduate students
participated in this study. The forty-five-item questionnaire was delivered to the participants. The findings
were that top-down reading strategies were used the most for both academic and business reading, whereas
bottom-up reading strategies were reported the least on both kinds of text. The results suggest that larger
numbers of participants, correction between the proficiency and the use of strategies, in-depth interview, and
strategies used between low and high proficient readers should be examined.
Index Terms—top-down model, bottom-up model, academic text, business text
I. INTRODUCTION
English plays a vital role for all society around this planet. Not only speaking, writing or listening, but reading is also
a very necessary for those who prefer to communicate effectively. Chawwang (2008) stated that reading is the most
important skill because it is the useful tool for acquiring knowledge. Used in both studying and living life, English is a
lifelong skill for many people (Kucukoglu, 2013). Then, without ability to read well, opportunities for personal
fulfilment and job success inevitably will be lost (Anderson et al., 1985). If students expect to get the deepest
understanding of what they read, they should have the techniques or strategies for reading. The ability to read
proficiently is significantly related to how much a person can achieve in his or her personal and professional life (Block
& Israel, 2005).
Reading can also serve many purposes. Firstly, it makes the reader relax. Lots of people prefer to read their favorite
books in their spare time. Secondly, reading is crucial for business purposes. The business people face a ton of emails in
their daily work. The reading skill then supports a lot on this interaction. Lastly, the readers may read for knowledge.
For example, the students are usually required to read the journals or academic books in all courses they registered. The
stated reading purposes are some reasons that present how important the reading skill is. In Thailand, reading is also
very important for Thai people, especially English reading. That is because English is a medium language for Thai
people for cooperating with the neighbors in AEC (Asean Economics Community) countries and other foreign countries
which use English for communicating in various purposes.
However, reading is still considered a difficult task for most of Thai people. According to PISA (2015), the report
from the program for international student assessment showed that Thailand shared of low achievers in reading below
the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) average which is about 20% of students in
OECD countries. The reports from EF EPI (2017) also indicated that English proficiency of Thais is very low and
below the average.
The difficulties in reading among Thais are also found in many previous studies. Hayikaleng, Nair & Krishnasamy
(2016) also comment that Thai students usually face difficulty when they read the academic books that is consistent
with the study of Kasemsap & Lee (2015) who also stated that Thai students are weak in English reading
comprehension. Then, there are some scholars who searched on the reasons why reading is a difficult task among Thai
people. Chawwang (2008) investigated the English problems among Thai students. The results showed that the
problems cover three areas including sentence structure, vocabulary, and reading comprehension. Another idea comes
from Pangsapa (2012) who did a research on the English reading problems among Thai editorial staff. Her findings
revealed that four main reading problems includes not understanding technical words meaning, not knowing the word
meaning, facing with complex and very long sentences with many dependent clauses or paragraphs, and unfamiliar
words.
Therefore, the reading strategies are important and useful for solving these reading problems or difficulties. Garner
(1987) stated that reading strategies are as generally deliberate, playful activities undertaken by active learners, many
times to remedy perceived cognitive failure. According to Brown (2007a), reading strategies could be defined as the
specific methods of approaching a problem or task, modes of operation for achieving a particular ends, planned designs
ISSN 1798-4769
Journal of Language Teaching and Research, Vol. 10, No. 3, pp. 454-460, May 2019
DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17507/jltr.1003.07
© 2019 ACADEMY PUBLICATION