Antibiotic resistance genes in human pathogens such
as methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus
1
have
become notorious because they confound the tools
that are used to treat disease (FIG. 1). In particular,
resistance determinants in pathogens are commonly
encountered after the introduction of an antibiotic to
clinical use, and treating human pathogens with anti-
biotics directly affects the frequency of resistance to
those antibiotics in these pathogens
1–4
.
The presence of antibiotic resistance elements in
pathogenic bacteria is made all the more problematic
because of the prevalence of horizontal gene transfer,
the process by which bacteria acquire genes from the
environment
5
. Many of the known antibiotic resist-
ance genes are found on transposons, integrons or
plasmids, which can be mobilized and transferred to
other bacteria of the same or different species. There
is evidence of the transfer of resistance elements to
known human commensal bacteria and pathogens
6,7
,
and gene transfer in the human intestinal microbiome
is extensive
8
.
What are the sources and reservoirs of these
transferable genes? A full understanding of the pres-
sures and circumstances that lead to the evolution
and dissemination of antibiotic resistance genes in
pathogens is impossible without a detailed examina-
tion of the origin and role of resistance genes in natural
environments. This Review discusses the environmen-
tal sources of antibiotic resistance, the functions and
roles of resistance genes in microbial ecology and the
ways by which those genes may be disseminated in
response to human antibiotic use.
Selection pressures in the environment
Antibiotics are essential for the treatment of bacterial
infections in humans and animals; it is therefore a top
priority to preserve their efficacy. For decades, clini-
cians and scientists have called for the prudent use of
antibiotics, in an effort to slow the development and
epidemic spread of resistance
9–11
. Prudent use of anti-
biotics in humans demands that physicians establish
that a bacterial infection is responsible for the patient’s
symptoms before an antibiotic prescription is written.
By contrast, in agriculture antibiotics are used in the
absence of acute infection. Some of the same antibiot-
ics that are used to treat human pathogens, such as
amoxicillin and erythromycin, are also used to treat
disease, promote growth and improve feed efficiency
in animals
12
( BOX 1). Just as in hospital settings, the
agricultural use of antibiotics selects for antibiotic
resistance, arguably in a more widely disseminated
fashion owing to the farm-wide administration of
prophylactic antibiotics in feed and water. Antibiotics
from both urban and agricultural sources persist in
soil and aquatic environments, and the selective pres-
sure imposed by these compounds may affect the treat-
ment of human diseases
13,14
. As another example, the
prophylactic use of antibiotics in fish farms has led to
a rise in the number of resistant bacteria
15
. Strikingly,
these resistant bacteria can transfer the resistance
genes to human pathogens
16
. The selection pressure
applied by the antibiotics that are used in clinical and
agricultural settings has promoted the evolution
and spread of genes that confer resistance, regardless
of their origins (FIG. 2).
*
Departments of Bacteriology
and Plant Pathology,
University of Wisconsin–
Madison.
‡
Microbiology Doctoral
Training Program, University
of Wisconsin–Madison,
1550 Linden Dr., Madison,
Wisconsin 53706, USA.
§
Department of Microbiology
and Immunology, University
of British Columbia,
2350 Health Sciences Mall,
Vancouver, British Columbia
V6T1Z3, Canada.
||
Department of Molecular,
Cellular, and Developmental
Biology, Yale University,
New Haven, Connecticut
06520, USA.
Correspondence to J.H.
e-mail:
jo.handelsman@yale.edu
doi:10.1038/nrmicro2312
Published online 1 March 2010
Call of the wild: antibiotic resistance
genes in natural environments
Heather K. Allen
*‡
, Justin Donato
*
, Helena Huimi Wang
§
, Karen A. Cloud-Hansen
*
,
Julian Davies
§
and Jo Handelsman
||
Abstract | Antibiotic-resistant pathogens are profoundly important to human
health, but the environmental reservoirs of resistance determinants are poorly
understood. The origins of antibiotic resistance in the environment is relevant to
human health because of the increasing importance of zoonotic diseases as well
as the need for predicting emerging resistant pathogens. This Review explores
the presence and spread of antibiotic resistance in non-agricultural, non-clinical
environments and demonstrates the need for more intensive investigation on
this subject.
REVIEWS
NATURE REVIEWS | MICROBIOLOGY ADVANCE ONLINE PUBLICATION | 1
Nature Reviews Microbiology | AOP, published online 1 March 2010; doi:10.1038/nrmicro2312
FOCUS ON ANTIMICROBIAL RESISTANCE
© 20 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved 10