PHYSICAL REVIEW E 101, 053206 (2020)
Mitigation of multispecies Weibel instability in a finite non-neutral magnetized beam-plasma system
Sam Yaghoubi , Abbas Ghasemizad,
*
and Soheil Khoshbinfar
Department of Physics, Faculty of Science, University of Guilan, P.O. Box 41335-1914 Rasht, Iran
(Received 5 February 2020; accepted 22 April 2020; published 21 May 2020)
Compressing and charge neutralization of the heavy-ion beam in an inertial fusion reactor are considered as
pivotal processes for increasing the energy gain. For this purpose, the ion beam is usually transported through
the plasma channel so that multispecies Weibel instability can grow in this system. Recently, a small solenoidal
magnetic field has been added to this method to have additional control of these processes. On the other hand,
charge and current may not be completely neutralized in this transport; as a result, the fractional charge and
current neutralization can affect the growth rate of this instability. In this work, the dispersion equation has been
obtained in cylindrical, cold, magnetized, non-neutral plasma in the macroscopic fluid frame. Numerical results
show that if the electron cyclotron frequency of the background plasma normalized by plasma frequency is larger
than the ion beam velocity normalized by the speed of light, as well as the current fraction being smaller than
1/2, the eigenmodes of multispecies Weibel instability can be completely stabilized. Moreover, these results are
valid when the percent deviation from the charge-neutral state is positive. In the negative regime of percent
deviation, the instability increases drastically so that the system can be completely unstable only for more than
2%. Therefore, selecting the radius of the ion beam smaller than the electron skin depth of the plasma and the
beam pulse duration much longer than the plasma oscillation time are proposed for quenching of this instability.
DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevE.101.053206
I. INTRODUCTION
Neutralization of the ion beam charge and current states
by the background plasma is an important issue in broad
research areas which involves the transport of fast particles
in plasma, especially in astrophysics [1–4], accelerators [4,5],
and inertial confinement fusion [6–9]. The successful trans-
port and focusing of the relativistic ion beam in the inertial
fusion reactor core on the submillimeter-sized target is a
challenging task. It is usually difficult to reduce the focal spot
of the incident ion such as lithium, potassium, or cesium from
several centimeters to a few millimeters [10,11]. The latest
proposed technique to tackle this problem has been applied
in the Neutralized Drift Compression eXperiment (NDCX)
project at the collaborative program of LBNL, LLNL, and
PPPL. In this project, an ion beam with an initial particle
density of 10
10
− 10
14
cm
−3
was injected into a cylindrical
waveguide that previously was filled by a cold, collisionless
plasma having the temperature 1–10 eV [12,13]. In this
process, the density and the temperature of the beam reach
100 times the initial value, while the radius of the beam has
decreased from a few centimeters to several millimeters [14].
Recently, the application of a solenoidal magnetic field in a
more advanced project, NDCX-II, provides additional control
on the focusing of the ion beam. Here the magnetized plasma
responses to the injection of the intense ion beam excite
the micro-instabilities such as multispecies two-stream and
Weibel instabilities [15–18]. Moreover, the Whistler instabil-
ity and helicon waves may grow in this medium, provided
that ω
ce
/ω
e
2 β
b
, where ω
ce
, ω
e
, and β
b
are the cyclotron
*
Corresponding author: ghasemi@guilan.ac.ir
frequency, plasma electron frequency, and ion beam velocity
to the speed of light, respectively [19].
This research has been focused on the weak magnetic field
(ω
ce
/ω
e
2 β
b
); consequently, there are no Whistler and heli-
con waves in this medium. However, there still exists concern
about the linear growth rate of the multispecies two-stream
and Weibel instabilities in the non-neutral magnetized plasma.
In most cases, the two-stream instability exhibits a much faster
growth rate than the Weibel instability; however, it finally
reduces the beam quality by pinching [20]. An overview of
multispecies Weibel instability in the absence of the external
magnetic field may be found in Ref. [15]. There, by using
the fluid model, the growth rate of this unstable mode in the
finite neutral state was discussed, and for the nonconstructive
situation of the system, the optimum lengths of the plasma
channel were also derived. Moreover, other studies on the
magnetized infinite plasma in the neutral state, especially
Ref. [18] on the NDCX project, have confirmed that the axial
external magnetic field can moderate the growth rate of the
Weibel instability [21,22].
There is some evidence that charge and current states in
the beam-plasma system may deviate from the neutral state.
The electron response time to the injection of the ion beam
is estimated with the electron plasma frequency (T
response
=
2π/ω
pe
)[23]. So, if the pulse duration of the incident ion
beam is smaller than the response time, the ion beam can
experience the charge and current non-neutrality during the
compression stage. The application of a small magnetic field
of ∼100 G may destabilize the beam neutralization. More-
over, it has been pointed out that the axial magnetic field
satisfying the condition of ω
ce
/ω
e
β
b
strongly affects the
degrees of charge and current neutralization [24,25]. In a non-
magnetized plasma, for a thin beam (Z
b
n
b
n
p
), the plasma
2470-0045/2020/101(5)/053206(10) 053206-1 ©2020 American Physical Society