Original Research
Natural History of Scoliosis in Nonambulatory Spastic
Tetraplegic Cerebral Palsy
Yaoming Gu, MD, MS, Jean E. Shelton, MD, Jessica M. Ketchum, PhD,
David X. Cifu, MD, Dorothy Palmer, MD, Ann Sparkman, LPN,
Melinda K. Jermer-Gu, OTR, Marianne Mendigorin
Objective: To analyze the development and progression of scoliosis in children and
adolescents with nonambulatory spastic tetraplegic cerebral palsy.
Design: Retrospective longitudinal review.
Setting: Pediatric nursing home.
Participants: A total of 110 children and adolescents 18 years of age, with scoliosis.
Interventions: N/A.
Main Outcome Measures: Cobb angle, age, weight, height, history of hip dislocation,
tracheostomy.
Results: The Cobb angle increased with age, weight, and height in a nonlinear fashion. A
square root transformation of the Cobb angle was chosen to model the nonlinear relation-
ship between the Cobb angle and predictors. Age, height, and weight were significant
univariate predictors of the square root of the Cobb angle (slopes = 0.377, 0.067, and 0.06,
respectively). In the multivariate mixed model, age remained a significant predictor of the
Cobb angle (slope = 0.456), but height and weight did not. If the Cobb angle was 40° by
age 12 years, scoliosis was more likely to progress than if the Cobb angle was 40°. The
effect of age was stronger for those with history of tracheostomy (age slope = 0.631 vs
0.281) than those without. The relationship of age and Cobb angle did not differ signifi-
cantly between hip dislocated and non– hip-dislocated groups.
Conclusions: Age was found to be the most significant predictor of Cobb angle, and the
effect of age was greater in the tracheostomy group than in the nontracheostomy group.
After adjustment for age, the weight and height were not significant predictors of Cobb
angle. Cobb angles of 40° by the age of 12 years were associated with greater increases in
Cobb angle with age.
PM R 2011;3:27-32
INTRODUCTION
The prevalence of cerebral palsy (CP) is 1.9 to 2.6 per 1000 births [1]. Prematurity is 1 of the
major causes of CP [2]. Among individuals who have a gestational age of 20 to 25 weeks, CP
prevalence increases to 19 per 1000 live births. Scoliosis appears more frequently and with
greater severity in children with CP as compared with healthy children [3]. The estimated
incidence of scoliosis in CP ranges from 25% to 64% in institutionalized patients [4,5].
There are few studies in which investigators researched the natural history of scoliosis in
children with CP [5-9]. Many factors influence the severity of scoliosis. Factors that predict
the progression of scoliosis are early onset of curvature and the severity of the CP [5,8].
Scoliosis continues to worsen even after bone maturity [9]. The severity of CP seems to play
a major role in the progression of the curvature. This association appears to be multifactorial
[5]. Asymmetric spasticity of paraspinal musculature may force the spine to the contralateral
side and result in scoliosis. In addition, hip dislocation may affect the pelvic obliquity and
begin the curvature of the spine that results in scoliosis. However, muscle release below the
iliac crest does not seem to stop the progression of scoliosis [10].
Overall, the mechanism that triggers scoliosis in CP remains unclear. The reason that
scoliosis continues to worsen after bone maturity has also not been defined. Experimental
Y.G. VCU Spine Center, Virginia Common-
wealth University, 8700 Stony Point Park-
way, Suite 260, Richmond, VA 23235.
Address correspondence to Y.G.; e-mail:
ygu@vcu.edu
Disclosure: nothing to disclose
J.E.S. Department of Physical Medicine & Re-
habilitation, Eastern Virginia Medical School,
Norfolk, VA
Disclosure: nothing to disclose
J.M.K. Department of Biostatistics, Virginia
Commonwealth University, Richmond, VA
Disclosure: nothing to disclose
D.X.C. Department of Physical Medicine &
Rehabilitation, Virginia Commonwealth Uni-
versity, Richmond, VA
Disclosure: nothing to disclose
D.P. Department of Physical Medicine & Re-
habilitation, Eastern Virginia Medical School,
Norfolk, VA
Disclosure: nothing to disclose
A.S. St. Mary Infant Home, Norfolk, VA
Disclosure: nothing to disclose
M.K.J.-G. Sheltering Arms Hospital, Rich-
mond, VA
Disclosure: nothing to disclose
M.M. St. Mary Infant Home, Norfolk, VA
Disclosure: nothing to disclose
Presented in part at the American Academy of
Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation annual
meeting, November 2008, San Diego, CA.
Submitted for publication December 22,
2008; accepted September 22, 2010.
PM&R © 2011 by the American Academy of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation
1934-1482/11/$36.00 Vol. 3, 27-32, January 2011
Printed in U.S.A. DOI: 10.1016/j.pmrj.2010.09.015
27