MEDINFO 2001
V. Patel et al. (Eds)
Amsterdam: IOS Press
© 2001 IMIA. All rights reserved
1445
Design of a Consumer Health Record for Supporting the Patient-centered
Management of Chronic Diseases
Paul A. de Clercq
a
, Arie Hasman
a
, Bruce H.R. Wolffenbuttel
b
a
Department of Medical Informatics, University of Maastricht, Maastricht, The Netherlands
b
Department of Endocrinology, Maastricht Academic Hospital, Maastricht, The Netherlands
Abstract
This paper describes and discusses the design and usage of
a shareable consumer health record system to investigate
whether these systems can assist in the management of
chronic diseases. This web-based system that can be used
both by care providers and patients contains medical and
patient information, provides access to websites that
contain quality information, provides guideline-based
advice, allows discussion between patients and allows us to
interrogate both patients and care providers on a regular
basis in order to get a good impression of the utility of such
a consumer record for both chronic patients and the
physicians and nurses. A health record system that was
developed for the area of Diabetes is presented as an
example.
Keywords:
Consumer Health Record, Chronic Disease management,
Diabetes, Decision support, Internet, Ethnographical
approach, Patient-centered care.
Introduction
Patients are increasingly confronted with Information and
Communication Technology (ICT). Chronic patients for
example can obtain information about their disease by using
a Web-browser. It happens more and more that they take a
printout to their physician to discuss patient-related
information. The physician is not always familiar with this
information. A problem is that from the information
available on the printout it is not always easy to determine
the quality of the source of the information. But usually
physicians appreciate that their patients are actively
searching relevant information because this is an indication
that the patient feels responsible for his or her treatment.
A recent study showed that for chronic patients, a patient-
centered approach 1) increases the patient’s satisfaction
with their physician's care, 2) increases the patient’s interest
in the contents of their medical records and 3) improves the
patient’s overall health status [1]. The possibilities of ICT
nowadays go even further. Electronic Patient Records
(EPRs), for example, are increasingly used to store and
represent patient data [2]. In several countries vendors [3]
offer disk space to consumers (which may be patients) in
which they can store relevant information about their health.
The patients pay for the services offered. These vendors
usually suggest that information can also be copied from the
information systems of physicians, so that the patient
eventually possesses a record that contains all relevant
information about the patients’s health. When visiting a care
provider the patient can now share with the physician those
data that (s)he wants: the patient owns the information.
Although in principle a good idea, there are a number of
problems associated with this approach that should be
further evaluated. In the first place not so many systems
containing an EPR are at the moment operational. In the
Netherlands for example, most GPs use an information
system but the specialists usually record medical data on
paper. Moreover, currently available information systems
(specialist information systems, hospital information
systems, GP information systems), due to lack of
standardization, store information in different formats and
probably use different terminologies. The current consumer
record systems are not flexible enough to store the data
obtained from the various systems at standard locations, so
that a readable consumer record is created. Usually the
different pieces of information are pasted together, resulting
in spaghetti of stored data: the overview is lost. A new
development in consumer health records is the increasing
active role of the patient. Not only care providers, but also
the patients themselves are allowed to enter (medical) data.
Although this may increase the patient’s involvement in the
management of their disease, it may also decrease the
validity of the medical data. Since patients do not have the
medical knowledge and background of a care provider, they
may interpret the care provider’s information incorrectly,
resulting in erroneously entered data.
This paper describes the design and usage of a consumer
health record to further investigate these problems and to
investigate how both patients and care providers look at the
possibilities and limitations of consumer records. In our