© Copyright by ICR Publishers 2008
Age-Related Changes in the Aortic Valve Affect Leaflet
Stress Distributions: Implications for Aortic Valve
Degeneration
Reetu Singh
1
, Joel A. Strom
1,2
, Leo Ondrovic
1,3
, Babu Joseph
1
, Michael D. VanAuker
1
Departments of
1
Chemical Engineering,
2
Internal Medicine and
3
Surgery, University of South Florida, Tampa, Florida, USA
Degenerative aortic stenosis, characterized by leaflet
thickening, stiffening and calcification leading to a nar-
rowing of the orifice (1), is currently the most common
form of the condition (2,3). The prevalence of degener-
ative aortic stenosis increases with age (3), with a two-
fold increase in the risk for stenosis for each decade of
increasing age (4); indeed, almost 5% of patients aged
over 75 years are afflicted by moderate to critical forms
of the condition (5).
During valve opening and closing, the leaflets
undergo cyclic loading which leads in turn to flexural
and shearing stresses, such that the leaflets sustain
‘repeated stress injury’. If the effects of this injury are
not neutralized by tissue repair, valve degeneration
may occur due to fatigue (6). Thus, the mechanical
stresses encountered during valve motion are the pri-
mary cause of calcific stenosis of the native aortic
valve, and the structural degeneration of bioprosthetic
aortic valves (7-11). The properties of the aortic valve
tissue, which undergoes alterations with aging, com-
bined with the properties of the aortic wall and the
valve anatomy, play an important role in determining
the stress distributions and, therefore, valve degenera-
tion.
Age-related changes to the aortic valve include a loss
of leaflet elasticity (12), a reduction in stretch after the
age of 40 years (13), an increase in tissue thickness (14)
due to the accumulation of adipose tissue between the
fibrosa and ventricularis and an accumulation of extra-
cellular matrix materials and cellular degradation
Presented in part at the Fourth Biennial Meeting of the Society for
Heart Valve Disease, 15th-18th June 2007, New York, USA
Address for correspondence:
Dr. Michael D. VanAuker PhD, 4202 E. Fowler Avenue, ENB 118,
Department of Chemical Engineering, University of South Florida,
Tampa, FL 33620, USA
e-mail: vanauker@eng.usf.edu
Background and aim of the study: The degeneration
of aortic valve leaflets occurs primarily due to high
mechanical stresses in zones of leaflet flexion. Aging,
which has been identified as a risk factor for degen-
erative aortic stenosis, is associated with reductions
in stretch and in compliance, and an increase in tis-
sue thickness of the leaflet and root. The study aim
was to investigate the effects of age-related tissue
changes on valve opening dynamics and leaflet stress
patterns, and its implications for valve degeneration.
Methods: A three-dimensional finite element model
of the aortic valve and root was developed in
Ansys®. A transient, non-linear analysis was carried
out of the valve opening phase. Three age groups
were identified based on leaflet and root tissue prop-
erties: group I age <35 years; group II aged 33-55
years; and group III aged >55 years. The valve open-
ing dynamics was studied and von Mises stresses in
various regions of the leaflet were computed.
Results: Maximum leaflet stresses occurred along the
leaflet-root attachment, analogous to the spatial dis-
tribution of calcific deposits in the aortic valve. With
increasing age, the rate of valve opening decreased,
and the magnitude of leaflet tip displacement in both
radial and axial directions reduced progressively. At
the leaflet-root attachment, groups II and III showed
19% and 32.7% increases in average stress over group
I, respectively. At the free edge, the stresses in group
III increased 2.7% over group I; however, the average
stress at the free edge in group II decreased 3.5% over
group I. In the leaflet belly, groups II and III showed
27.6% and 60.9% increases in stresses over group I,
respectively.
Conclusion: Changes in leaflet and root tissue prop-
erties lead to altered leaflet dynamics and increased
stresses. This not only emphasizes the role of aging
on the development and progression of degenerative
aortic valve disease, but also has implications in the
design of bioprosthetic heart valves.
The Journal of Heart Valve Disease 2008;17:290-299