89
Brief Treatment of Complicated PTSD and Peritraumatic Responses
in a Client With Repeated Sexual Victimization
Terri L. Messman-Moore, Miami University
Patricia A. Resick, Center for Trauma Recovery, University of Missou~J-St. Louis
The present case study describes the successful treatment of a woman with a history of sexual, physical, and psychological abuse in
childhood and multiple rapes in adulthood, utilizing a relatively brief cognitive-behavioral treatment, Cognitive Processing Therapy
(CPT). Treatment addressed assault-related PTSD, major depression, suicidality, compulsive self-harm behaviors, and primary and
secondary dissociative responses. Treatment also addressed related issues of low self-esteem, social isolation, and the client's sense of
helplessness, which had resulted in her failure to implement active selfJrrotection strategies. Client symptomatology was tracked
throughout treatment using the PTSD Symptom Scale (PSS) and the Beck Depression Inventory (BD[) at regular intervals owr the
course of 34 sessions and for 3 months posttermination. The relatively short course of therapy (22 weeks) and treatment strategies are
described, including cognitive and behavioral components of CPT, supportive strategies, safety planning in the context of ongoing
threats and victimization, and the importance of the therapeutic relationship. Particular emphasis is given to adaptation of the b~4ef
treatment to complex symptomatology and patterns of symptomatic change in relation to cognitive and behavioral intervention. Find-
ings indicate that treatment for individuals with extensive victimization histories does not require different strategies or a signifi-
cantly longer period of treatment than does treatment for those with a single traumatic experience.
E
MPIRICALINVESTIGATIONS now strongly support a be-
lief long held by clinicians working with child sexual
abuse (CSA) survivors, specifically that CSA survivors are
at increased risk for further sexual victimization in ado-
lescence and adulthood (Messman & Long, 1996; Po-
lusny & Follette, 1995). Both CSA and adult rape are as-
sociated with numerous acute and chronic psychological
difficulties, including PTSD symptomatology, depression,
suicidality and self-harm behaviors, anxiety, substance
abuse, dissociation, interpersonal difficulties, low self-
esteem, and feelings of guilt and self-blame (for reviews
see Goodman, Koss, & Russo, 1993; Polusny & Follette;
Resick, 1993).
It has been proposed that traumatic experiences and
life stresses tend to be cumulative, such that individuals
who have experienced many stressors tend to cope less
effectively than people with fewer stressors (Hanson,
1990). Interpersonal violence in particular appears to
have this cumulative effect. Previous victimization, in-
cluding many different forms of child and adult abuse, is
associated with more depression and longer recovery in
women who have been raped (Kilpatrick, Saunders,
Veronen, Best, & Von, 1987). Follette, Polusny, Bechde,
and Naugle (1996) found that women with a history of
three different forms of abuse (CSA, adult sexual assault,
Cognitive and Behavioral Practice 9, 89-99, 2002
1077-7229/02/89-9951.00/0
Copyright © 2002 by Association for Advancement of Behavior
Therapy. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved.
[~ Continuing Education Quiz located on pp. 168-169.
and adult physical abuse) reported higher levels of anxi-
ety, depression, dissociation, sexual problems, and sleep
disturbances than women with a history of only two forms
of abuse, who in turn were more distressed than women
with a history of only one form of abuse, and so on. Mur-
phy and colleagues (1988) also found that women who
were sexually victimized both in childhood and adult-
hood reported higher levels of general distress, somatiza-
tion, obsessive-compulsive behavior, depression, anxiety,
hostility, and interpersonal sensitivity than women with a
single sexual assault (either childhood or adulthood) or
no history of victimization.
Given that revictimized women have greater levels of
psychological distress and trauma-related sequelae, clini-
cians can anticipate that such women will have a more
complicated clinical presentation, with severe levels of
psychopathology, often accompanied by self-injurious be-
haviors, impaired interpersonal relations, and maladap-
tive coping skills. The question is, how does a history of
repeated and often prolonged victimization affect the cli-
ent in therapy? Will her problems require more time in
treatment? Does treatment need to directly address every
victimization experience, or even focus on every present-
ing problem to be successful?
Current research has strongly supported the efficacy
of cognitive and behavioral interventions for treatment
of PTSD symptomatology in trauma victims, particularly
female rape victims (Foa, Rothbaum, Riggs, & Murdock,
1991; Resick & Schnicke, 1992). Neither of these studies
excluded women with a prior history of victimization.
Howevei, some may criticize such investigations, empha-