J Clin Res Gov 2 (2013) 53-56
53
Swedish Science Pioneers
Developing World Journal Series
Journal of Clinical Research & Governance
www.jcrg.sciencepub.se
Research Article
Opinions of Anesthesiologists and Surgeons about World Health Organization Surgical Safety
Checklist in a Tertiary hospital in Iran, 2012
Mahasti Alizadeh
a
, Hossein Jabbari Bayrami
a
, Maryam Baradaran
a
, Reza Movassaghi Gargari
b
, Ramin Azhough
c
a: Community Medicine Department, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran
b: Department of Anesthesiology ,Imam Reza Hospital. Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran
c: Department of General Surgery, Imam Reza Hospital, Tabriz University of Medical Sciences, Tabriz, Iran
Correspondence
Maryam Baradaran
Department of Community Medicine
Faculty of medicine
Tabriz University of Medical Sciences
Tabriz, Iran
Postal code: 5166614766
Tell: +98-411-3364673
Email:maryam_baradaran@hotmail.com
Keywords:
Patient Safety
Operating Rooms
Surgical Safety Checklist
Hospital Infection
Hospital Mortality
Received: 2013-06-15
Accepted: 2013-07-29
Abstract
Purpose: The aim of this study was determine the opinions of clinicians in order to modify the surgical safety
checklist(SSC) to make it compatible for use in hospitalsof Iran.
Methods:In a cross-sectional study, the views of surgeons and anesthesiologists of the main teaching hospital in
Tabriz -Imam Reza Hospital- were taken by a form attached to the main checklist. The participants in this study were
asked to write their opinions on each item of the checklist based on the environment of the hospital. The opinions
were classified and analyzed.
Results:Most of the anesthesiologists(87.5%) and some of the surgeons (18%)recommended to change the fourth
item of sign-in part. They suggested using vital sign and base monitoring instead of pulse oximetry. Three of the
physicians added the "Internal Medicine Consultation" and "output monitoring" to the Critical Events Anticipation
item. Hemorrhage, vomiting, nausea, and hemodynamic disorders were added to the key concerns of recovery and
management item by 75% of anesthesiologists.
Conclusion:It is better to modify the Surgical Safety Checklist based on the local needs and facilities of each hospital.
Surgeons and anesthesiologists in an Iranian teaching hospital suggested adding some items to each part of SSC.
DOI: 10.13183/jcrg.v2i2.58 © 2013 Swedish Science Pioneers, All rights reserved.
Introduction
Overload of major surgeries has significant implications for
public health. Since the case mix is so different, the rates of
death and complications after surgery are difficult to be
compared. In industrialized countries, the rate of major
complications has been occurred in 3–22% of inpatient surgical
procedures, and the death rate is about 0.4 - 0.8% [1].
Approximately, half of the adverse events in these studies were
avoidable. Studies in developing countries suggest a death rate
of 5–10% occurring in major surgeries. Infections and other
postoperative complications are also a serious concern
worldwide [1-9].
Despite high improvements in the knowledge of safety in
surgery, at least half of the adverse events occur during surgical
care. Nearly seven million patients suffer from significant
surgical complications each year, one million of whom die
during or immediately after surgery .Accordingly, Surgical safety
has emerged as a major global public health concern [1]. In
May 2004, the world health organization (WHO) approved the
creation of an alliance to improve patient safety globally; WHO
Patient Safety was launched the following in October. For the
first time, heads of agencies, policy-makers and patient groups
from all over the world gathered together to improve the
accomplishment of the goal of “First, do no harm” and to reduce
the adverse events of unsafe health care. The goal of WHO
Patient Safety is to help patient safety policy and practice.
Designing tools for improvement of patient safety including
surgical safety checklist was one of their actions. These efforts
could save millions of lives by improving basic health care [4].
The Checklist should be modified to account for differences
among hospitals according to their processes and the culture of
their operating. Modification of the Checklist should be done
critically. Surgeons, anesthesiologists, and nurses should be
involved in the modification process [9]. Tabriz Imam Reza
hospital is a referral and the largest specialty and subspecialty
hospital in Northwest of Iran. Considering WHO surgical safety
checklist advantages and importance of clinical governance
which patients safety is one of its key components, we decided
to modify WHO surgical safety checklist to fit with Tabriz Imam