The Turkish Online Journal of Design, Art and Communication - TOJDAC
ISSN: 2146-5193, September 2018 Special Edition, p.1207-1214
APPLICATION OF THE DISPUTATION TECHNIQUE TO ENHANCE
STUDENT’S SELF-ESTEEM
Rahimi Che Aman
School of Educational Studies, Universiti Sains Malaysia : rahimi@usm.my
Dzilal Abdul Aziz
Faculty of Educational Study, Universiti Putra Malaysia; dzilal@gmail.com
ABSTRACT
This study aims to identify the effect of the disputation technique to enhance self-esteem in a student
with low academic performance. Apart from that, this study also uncovers the symptoms of low self-
esteem and the level of self-esteem in a student. A subject was chosen through purposive sampling
technique. The subject was selected based on various predetermined criteria. The research comprised
six counselling sessions. The qualitative data was collected throughout the counselling sessions using
the transcription of the counselling sessions, observation list and quantitative data collected using the
Rosenberg Self-Esteem Scale. The data were then analyzed using descriptive analysis and content
analysis. The result showed that the student’s level of self-esteem increased. As a conclusion, the
symptoms of low self-esteem have also been successfully identified, and the result shows that the
application of the disputation technique is effective in enhancing the self-esteem of a student with low
academic performance through cognitive, emotion and behavior analysis.
Keywords: disputation technique, self-esteem, counselling
Introduction
Low academic performance is believed to lower the self-esteem of students due to irrational beliefs
held by the student (Nielsen and Horan, 1996). Low self-esteem will affect the future of the students in
term of self-concept and self-confidence if the level of self-esteem is not improved (Shokraii-Rees,
2003). The approach chosen to be used to help increase the level of the student’s self-esteem is the
disputation technique based on the Rational Emotive Behaviour Therapy (REBT).
Research Background
Adolescence is an intense time of emotional and physical change in a young person’s life (McClure,
Tanski & Kingsbury, 2010). It is during this period that adolescents begin to develop a positive or
negative perception of themselves. Based on a recent study, adolescents are experiencing more social
and psychological problems than ever before (Mc Namara, 2000). These trends show an increased
pressure that adolescents face which will ultimately tear down the walls of confidence and diminishes
one’s self-esteem (Mc Namara, 2000).
An adolescent spent a great amount of time per day in school. Thus, no aspect of school life, be it in
the realm of academic achievement or social acceptance leaves a child’s self-esteem untouched. The
development of high self-esteem and high academic achievement can lead to an improved quality of
life (Shokraii-Rees, 2003). Many adolescents are stressed daily due to low grade and test scores.
Academic performance, academic achievement and social adjustment influence children’s self-esteem
(Henderson, 1991). The term self-esteem refers to how the beliefs and personal attributes that people
have about themselves can affect them (McClure, Tanski & Kingsbury, 2010). Starting from these
beliefs, judgements and feelings are formed about their capabilities and worth. Over time, children
create and assemble feelings that people have about their own capabilities and self-worth that they can
articulate to others as their self-esteem. Jordan, Spencer & Zanna (2005) stated that self-esteem is a
product of an individual’s own sense of their achievements and aspirations. Therefore, people who
perceive themselves as successful in areas of their aspirations should have higher self-esteem than
people with lower self-assessments.
The process of formal education can have a profound effect on a child’s self-esteem as the child
must master specific learning skills which are evaluated through the academic assessment carried out
in schools. Thus, low academic performance will affect the self-esteem of an adolescent due to
Submit Date: 10.07.2018, Acceptance Date: 22.08.2018, DOI NO: 10.7456/1080SSE/162
Research Article - This article was checked by Turnitin
Copyright © The Turkish Online Journal of Design, Art and Communication