The People with Asperger syndrome and
anxiety disorders (PAsSA) trial: a pilot
multicentre, single-blind randomised trial
of group cognitive–behavioural therapy
Peter E. Langdon, Glynis H. Murphy, Lee Shepstone, Edward C.F. Wilson, David Fowler, David Heavens,
Aida Malovic, Alexandra Russell, Alice Rose and Louise Mullineaux
Background
There is a growing interest in using cognitive–behavioural
therapy (CBT) with people who have Asperger syndrome
and comorbid mental health problems.
Aims
To examine whether modified group CBT for clinically
significant anxiety in an Asperger syndrome population
is feasible and likely to be efficacious.
Method
Using a randomised assessor-blind trial, 52 individuals with
Asperger syndrome were randomised into a treatment arm
or a waiting-list control arm. After 24 weeks, those in the
waiting-list control arm received treatment, while those
initially randomised to treatment were followed up for
24 weeks.
Results
The conversion rate for this trial was high (1.6:1), while attrition
was 13%. After 24 weeks, there was no significant difference
between those randomised to the treatment arm compared with
those randomised to the waiting-list control arm on the primary
outcome measure, the Hamilton Rating Scale for Anxiety.
Conclusions
Trials of psychological therapies with this population are
feasible. Larger definitive trials are now needed.
Declaration of interest
None.
Copyright and usage
© The Royal College of Psychiatrists 2016. This is an open access
article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution (CC BY) licence.
Anxiety disorders and related symptomatology are commonly
found among those with autistic spectrum disorders (ASDs),
including Asperger syndrome.
1–7
A meta-analysis examining the
effectiveness of cognitive–behavioural therapy (CBT) for anxiety
disorders in children with ASDs reported that treatment had an
effect size of d=1.19 for clinician-rated outcome measures, d=1.21
for parent-rated outcome measures and d=0.68 for child self-
report outcome measures.
8
The literature about the treatment of
mental health problems for adults with ASDs using CBT remains
relatively sparse; there have been some case studies
9,10
and some
small trials.
11–14
The aim of this trial was to collect data sufficient
to inform the design of a definitive large-scale trial. The specific
objectives included (a) assessing whether a CBT intervention is
likely to be efficacious within a pilot, assessor-blind RCT with
adults who have Asperger syndrome experiencing problems with
anxiety, and (b) to gain participant views about taking part in
therapy.
Method
Participants
Fifty-two individuals, M
age
=35.9, s.d.=14.5, 48% women, were
recruited and enrolled within the trial from Kent, South East London
and Norfolk within the UK. Recruitment took place within the
community from Asperger syndrome/autism teams, Asperger syn-
drome user groups, such as Asperger East Anglia, the Kent Autistic
Trust, Bridging the Gap, the Disability and Dyslexia Support Services
at the University of Kent, intellectual disability teams, adult mental
health teams, and through public advertisements. Participant flow
throughout the trial is found in Fig. 1, and further demographic
information can be found in Table 1.
All participants were initially screened by research workers
to determine eligibility to take part in the trial. The inclusion
criteria were as follows: (a) participants fulfilled diagnostic criteria
for Asperger syndrome, high-functioning autism or pervasive
developmental disorder – not specified; diagnosis was confirmed
by inspection of previous records, or the study team used the
Autism Diagnostic Observation Schedule to confirm the diagnosis;
(b) participants had clinically significant difficulties with anxiety
as confirmed through the use of the Hamilton Rating Scale for
Anxiety (HAM-A; score of >14 qualified inclusion); (c) participants
were between 16 and 65 years of age; (d) full Scale IQ>70 on the
Wechsler Abbreviated Scale of Intelligence.
15
The exclusion criteria
were as follows: (a) participants with post-traumatic stress disorder,
or anxiety related to substance misuse; (b) comorbid severe
psychiatric disorders that impair capacity to consent to take part
(e.g. florid symptoms of psychosis); and (c) current substance
misuse such as alcohol or drugs.
Design and randomisation
This study was an assessor-blind randomised trial. Our full
protocol has been published elsewhere.
16
Masked researchers
enrolled participants and carried out the assessments. Even pairs
of participants were allocated to the treatment arm (group CBT+
treatment as usual (TAU) for 24 weeks) or the waiting-list control
arm (TAU for 24 weeks) using blocked randomisation with random
even blocks, stratified by study site. The therapists at each research
site contacted participants to inform them of their group allocation.
All data were stored independently by the Norwich Clinical Trials
179
BJPsych Open (2016)
2, 179–186. doi: 10.1192/bjpo.bp.115.002527