A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF THE IMPULSIVE NOISE REDUCTION
ALGORITHMS IN ULTRASONIC B-SCANS
Ramon Miralles, Raquel Molina
Instituto de Telecomunicaciones y Aplicaciones Multimedia (iTEAM)
Universidad Polit´ ecnica de Valencia, Camino de Vera S/N,46022, Valencia, Spain
phone: +3496 3879737, fax: +3496 3877309, email: rmiralle@dcom.upv.es, web: www.gts.upv.es
ABSTRACT
As the technology becomes cheaper and industries are con-
scious of the quality control importance, ultrasonic inspec-
tion becomes more popular. However, automatic inspection
systems instead of manual ones should be designed if a suc-
cessful implantation is desired. Signal processing algorithms
play an important role on the designing of these systems.
Unfriendly environment found in production lines cause that
these systems should make intensive use of noise reduction
algorithms. This work deals with studying the best algorithm
for impulsive noise reduction in an industrial environment.
A review of the typical impulsive noise reduction systems is
done and particularized for the described situation. Finally,
computational aspects are analyzed and some solutions are
proposed.
1. INTRODUCTION
In industrial applications of non-destructive testing using ul-
trasounds is very frequent to find alternating current (AC)
motors. These AC motors are commonly running in the
vicinity of non-destructive testing equipment and are used for
example for operating transport belts. The rotational speed
of this engines is controlled by the Variable Frequency Drive
(VFD). The VFD is a nonlinear device that introduces a large
amount of noise that is picked up by the ultrasonic receiver
electronics difficulting the flaw detection. In some situations
the noise presence could be minimized with a good hard-
ware and shielding design. However there are other situ-
ations where it is not possible to make such a design, for
instance impossibility to use relatively short cables between
the transducer and the ultrasonic pulser/ receiver. In this sit-
uations, signal processing algorithms can help to remove the
impulsive noise and facilitate the design of the defect detec-
tor. Additionally, it has to be taken into account the need of
real time algorithms in industrial systems. Production lines
work fast and the distance from product to product is in most
of the situations a few centimeters, so that fast algorithms
should be employed. In this work different algorithms for re-
ducing the impulsive noise in the ultrasonic B-scans will be
analyzed. The work will be structured as follows. In the next
section we will study and model the noise. Later in section 3
different signal processing algorithms for reducing this noise
will be proposed. In section 4 the presented algorithms will
be tested in a simulated scenario (subsection 4.1) and finally
in subsection 4.2 real examples will be shown. The work
finishes with some conclusions.
This work was supported by the national R+D program under grant
TEC2008-02975 (Spain) and FEDER programme.
2. ON THE MODELLING OF IMPULSIVE NOISE
INA TRAVELLING BELT SCENARIO
Lets assume that we are doing an ultrasonic inspection of a
material that is travelling on a transport belt of a production
line. The ultrasonic transducer somehow fixed to the produc-
tion line. We will assume that the coupling of the transducer
to the inspected material is somewhat solved. We will as-
sume also that material geometry allows doing this kind of
inspection. If the ultrasonic transducer works in pulse-echo
mode, B-scans are obtained. B-scans are defined as a suc-
cessive number of captured A-scans (ultrasonic traces) for
different positions. The following experiment was done to
measure and model the effect of the ultrasonic noise in the
B-scans as a consequence of the alternating current engine.
A polyethylene rectangular box filled with distilled water
was placed on the transport belt of the production line. Dif-
ferent B-scans were acquired for different rotational speeds
of the engines. The rotational speed was controlled vary-
ing the frequency of the VFD. The VFD generates Electro
Magnetic Interferences (EMI) that couple into the receiver
electronics contaminating the B-scan in form of impulsive
noise. The ultrasonic B-scans acquired with this experiment
resemble a noisy background with a unique ultrasonic echo
due to the reflection on the top of the water tank (see figure
1). This experiment was repeated for different frequencies of
the VFD in the range f
VFD
= {0Hz - 50Hz}. This analysis
allows to study the impulsive noise statistics. The figure 2
shows the measured probability density function of the cou-
pled noise at the different speeds. The results obtained are
similar to what some other authors have measured [1].
Time (samples)
Position (centimeters)
500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000
1
2
3
4
5
6
Figure 1: An acquired ultrasonic B-scan with impulsive noise
(only the backwall echo should be visible).
17th European Signal Processing Conference (EUSIPCO 2009) Glasgow, Scotland, August 24-28, 2009
© EURASIP, 2009 1577