Genetica 114: 207–215, 2002.
© 2002 Kluwer Academic Publishers. Printed in the Netherlands.
207
Polytene chromosomes of Simulium craigi (Diptera: Simuliidae)
Fiona F. Hunter
Department of Biological Sciences, Brock University, St. Catharines, Ontario, Canada L2S 3A1 (Phone: 905-688-
5550, ext. 3394; Fax: 905-688-1855; E-mail: hunterf@spartan.ac.brocku.ca)
Received 2 February 2001 Accepted 17 November 2001
Key words: clinal variation, cytotaxonomy, polymorphism, polytene chromosomes, Simulium craigi
Abstract
Simulium craigi Adler and Currie is a polymorphic species based on polytene chromosome banding patterns in
the long arm of chromosome III (IIIL). Three cytotypes are described based on the predominant IIIL sequences.
These correspond to three broad geographic areas: cytotype ‘CC’ from Pennsylvania; cytotype ‘AF’ from Ontario
and Manitoba; and cytotype ‘ACF/BCF’ from New Hampshire. In the absence of sympatric populations, these
cytotype differences are best explained by clinal variation within a single species. The relationship of S. craigi to
other described members of the S. vernum group is discussed.
Introduction
In black flies (Simuliidae) the micromorphological
features of larval salivary gland polytene chromo-
somes have been used extensively to differenti-
ate among species, sibling species, and cytotypes.
Rothfels (1981) elaborated on the assignment of sib-
ling species status through the recognition of sibling-
specific autosomal sequences (commonly the result of
fixed inversion differences or interchanges), sex chro-
mosome differences, and/or autosomal polymorphism
profile differences. In the absence of sympatric pop-
ulations, the term ‘cytotype’, the more conservative
designation, is preferred.
There have been several cytological treatments
of species in the Simulium vernum Macquart (com-
plex) group. The chromosomes of S. vernum s.l. (as
Eusimulium vernum) were first studied in detail by
Brockhouse (1985). Included in Brockhouse’s 1985
publication are descriptions of 14 S. vernum cyto-
types along with descriptions of two closely allied
species, S. bicorne Dorogostaisky, Rubtsov, and
Vlasenko and S. ‘Yukon’. Adler and Currie (1986)
formally described ‘Yukon’ as S. decolletum Adler and
Currie. One of Brockhouse’s vernum cytotypes, ‘Cale-
don’, was subsequently raised to morphospecies status
by Adler and Currie (1986) and is now known as
S. caledonense Adler and Currie. Hunter and Connolly
(1986) described the chromosomes and presented a
working hypothesis for relationships among seven
species in the S. vernum group from North Amer-
ica. This included S. aestivum Davies, Peterson, and
Wood, S. gouldingi Stone, S. croxtoni Nicholson and
Mickel, S. fionae Adler (as ‘Simulium sp.’), S. impar
Davies, Peterson, and Wood, S. pugetense Dyar and
Shannon, and S. quebecense Twinn. Hunter (1987a)
characterized four related Western European species:
S. carpathicum (Knoz), S. cryophilum (Rubtzov),
S. costatum Friederichs, and S. vernum. Adler (1987)
described a new species in the group, S. loerchae
Adler, found in North America. Reference to the chro-
mosomes of S. silvestre (Rubtsov) of the Nearctic
region has also been made (Adler, in Currie, 1997).
Hunter (1989) examined S. furculatum Shewell, but
concluded that it did not belong to the S. vernum
species group.
The current paper deals with the polytene chromo-
some analysis of diverse populations of S. craigi Adler
and Currie, a North American species previously de-
scribed by Adler and Currie (1986). The objectives
are to determine: (1) the taxonomic status of S. craigi
given its wide geographic distribution and (2) the
relationship of these populations to other described
members in the S. vernum group.