The Teaching of Biological Evolution: is it essential to the scientific
progress?
Heslley Machado Silva
Federal University of Minas Gerais, University Center of Formiga, University of Itaúna, Brazil. E-mail:
Daiana Evilin Gibram
University Center of Formiga, Brazil
Graça Simões de Carvalho
CIEC, Institute of Education, University of Minho (UM), Portugal
Abstract
Nowadays the teaching of biological evolution
faces the creationist movement that claims this theme
has no scientific evidence and that it could be
excluded from the educational system. A challenging
question about whether the exclusion of the teaching
of Darwinian Evolution would harm the scientific
progress was asked to a Brazilian population
sample. In general, the results showed a rejection of
the above question. Among the religious
respondents, Spiritualists were those showing higher
acceptance of the proposed statement whereas the
Evangelicals were those less agreeing with the
proposed question and with a considerable
percentage of disagreement; Catholics were in a
median position, agreeing with the question and a
few rejecting it. The more educated the respondents
were the higher acceptance of the question. The
present study revealed that even the inquired
creationists recognize that the teaching of biological
evolution is essential in modern science.
1. Introduction
Supported by a large body of evidence, the topic
of biological evolution has become a major pillar of
modern science. Indeed, it is hard to find a student
that has not been in contact with the Darwinian
Theory in his/her academic path anywhere in the
world [1]. There is a network of evidences leading to
concepts that underpin the evolutionary theory,
which in turn sustain theoretical models allowing
predictions. Such predictions when confronted by
new empirical results may or may not generate
changes in the models. Much of Darwin's
contribution to science was just to be able to gather a
series of observations coming from different fields
and synthesize them to explain the common ancestry
[2].
Berkman and Plutzer [3] claim the importance of
the teaching of biological evolution in the
curriculum, especially in secondary school, due to its
unifying role in biology. These authors also
emphasize the role of Darwinian Theory to show
students how modern science works and how it is
essential to the understanding and progress of
biological areas such as genetics, agriculture and
health, among others.
In 2009, a series of celebrations for the
anniversary of the birth of Charles Darwin and the
release of the most impactful book "The Origin of
Species" took place. Since the publication of this
book the issue of Darwinism and the teaching of
evolution was in vogue both in scientific and lay
media [4]. On the other hand, there has been a strong
reappearance of creationist movements, being
initially limited to the United States, but currently
echoing around the world, and most notably in Brazil
[6]. This rebirth of the creationist view may come
from a reaction to the confirmation of the importance
of Darwinism, especially in the educational field [3],
but may also be related to more fundamentalist
religious view, highlighting the biblical text as the
only reliable source of knowledge and moral stance
[5].
Copyright © WCE-2014 Published by Infonomics Society ISBN 978-1-908320-37-7 82