Optimizing Raman Ladder Climbing: Theory and Application in Na
2
Bo Y. Chang, Ignacio R. Sola ´ ,* and Jesu ´ s Santamarı ´a
Departamento de Quı ´mica Fı ´sica I, UniVersidad Complutense, 28040 Madrid, Spain
ReceiVed: March 22, 2001; In Final Form: June 22, 2001
The theory of vibrational ladder climbing excitation by coherent stimulated nonresonant Raman using chirped
laser pulses is developed. We analytically obtain the conditions for inverting the population to a final preselected
vibrational state and the restrictions that apply in the linear chirp regime. By controlling both the shape of the
laser pulses and the chirp profile, the ladder climbing process can be accelerated without reducing the yield
of the selective excitation. Numerical results are presented for selection of moderately excited vibrational
levels in Na
2
, where the important contribution of several excited electronic states is also clarified.
I. Introduction
Exciting molecules in specific high vibrational states has been
a long-sought goal, both for a better understanding of the
spectroscopic properties of the molecule and for igniting some
unimolecular (bond breaking) or bimolecular (reactant preparing)
reactions.
1
In molecules with a permanent dipole moment,
infrared (IR) laser pulses have been used to pump the vibrational
energy. By multiphoton IR processes, it has been possible to
excite single modes in regions of high anharmonicity and to
observe the subsequent intramolecular vibrational relaxation
(IVR).
2
However, due to the very weak transition dipole
moments between the ground and high vibrational eigenstates,
population inversion is unlikely to succeed. For coherent
interactions, the minimum time for population inversion (defin-
ing the so-called π pulses) is given by π times the inverse of
the Rabi frequency, Ω
0V
(t) ) µ
0V
E(t)/p, where E(t) is the pulse
envelope and µ
0V
) 〈ψ
V
|µ|ψ
0
〉 is the transition dipole moment
between the initial (ψ
0
) and final (ψ
V
) vibrational eigenfunctions.
For very weak transitions, µ
0V
, 1, and therefore population
inversion requires long pulses, with the onset of decoherent and
nonradiative processes, or very strong laser sources, usually
implying competition between several multiphoton routes, if not
directly ionizing the molecule.
3
A possibility proposed by Manz and colleagues
4
is to fraction
the overall transition into several sequential steps, each of which
is driven by a proper π pulse. The limit of this strategy is to
use one π pulse for every single quantum step excitation V f
V+ 1. The population then follows a pattern equivalent to
climbing a ladder one step after another, which takes advantage
of the (usually) larger transition dipole moments involved
between adjacent vibrational states, especially in approximately
harmonic potentials. Nevertheless, the overall sequence of (V
- 1)π pulses is both experimentally difficult to prepare and
moreover poorly robust, since the yield of each step is very
sensitive to frequency, time, and intensity variations, and the
overall yield is the product of the yields of every step. This
also explains the inability of optimal control algorithms to obtain
this kind of solution, when not properly biased.
5
Chelkowski et
al.
6
and Guerin
7
showed the way to circumvent the problem
using a single pulse with slowly varying frequency, adapted to
the anharmonicity of the potential. The pulse duration must be
at least as long as the whole sequence of (V- 1)π pulses and
the intensity stronger than the intensity of each one. For
sufficiently intense pulses, the population can be adiabatically
transferred from the initial state up to dissociation with 100%
efficiency at least in principle. The method is both robust and
not especially difficult to implement in the laboratory with state-
of-the-art technology.
8
For molecules without a permanent dipole moment, the ladder
climbing method can be implemented using nonresonant
stimulated coherent Raman.
9-12
In this case, either the pump
or the Stokes or both pulses must be chirped. The detuning with
respect to excited electronic states is required in order to avoid
absorption. Although there are a number of schemes which make
use of resonant Raman transitions, such as stimulated Raman
adiabatic passage (STIRAP)
13
or stimulated emission pumping
(SEP),
14
the Raman ladder climbing is an alternative method
especially suited for dissociation or high vibrational energy
excitation, since it benefits from the larger effective two-photon
transition dipole moments between adjacent vibrational levels.
In this paper, we develop a general theory of Raman ladder
climbing deriving the required conditions for the sequential
inversion of population between adjacent levels and obtaining
the minimum time for the final excitation of a single, selected
vibrational level. We demonstrate the important contribution
of highly excited electronic states and the possibility of
improving the yield of the process by a suitable election of the
laser amplitude and chirp profiles. The validity of the theoretical
results is numerically tested showing the efficiency of the Raman
ladder climbing method applied to the selective excitation of
vibrational states of a nonrotating sodium dimer. In section 2,
we present the molecular model and calculate the effective
Raman Rabi frequencies. In section 3, we develop the theory
of optimal Raman ladder climbing, which is numerically tested
in section 4. Section 5 is the conclusion.
II. Model for Nonresonant Raman in Na
2
In Raman ladder climbing, the system is exposed to the action
of two fully overlapping lasers, the pump E
p
(t), and the Stokes
E
s
(t) pulses. The pulses have the same amplitude, and the
frequency of the pump is negatively chirped; that is, its carrier
frequency smoothly decreases. The same results can be obtained
by positively chirping the frequency of the Stokes pulse or
chirping both. * E-mail: ignacio@tchiko.quim.ucm.es.
8864 J. Phys. Chem. A 2001, 105, 8864-8870
10.1021/jp011077s CCC: $20.00 © 2001 American Chemical Society
Published on Web 09/06/2001