Recent Hardy Criticism
Ralph Pite*
University of Cardiff
Abstract
This article offers a survey of recent Hardy criticism (focussing on books by Jo
Devereux, David Musselwhite, Edward Neill,Andrew Radford and T. R. Wright
and a collection of essays edited by Tim Dolin and Peter Widdowson). It sets these
in the context of how Hardy studies have developed over the last twenty years or
so and suggests a number of directions that future research might take.
For a moment pause:–
Just here it was
‘The Mound’, Winter Words (Hardy 843)
In Hardy studies too, the wall came down around 1989. Peter Widdowson’s
Hardy in History: A Study in Literary Sociology (1989), plus a number of
feminist studies – Rosemarie Morgan’s Women and Sexuality in the Novels
of Thomas Hardy (1988), Patricia Ingham, Thomas Hardy: A Feminist Reading
(1989), Marjorie Garson’s Hardy’s Fables of Integrity: Woman, Body, Text
(1991), and M. R. Higonnet’s edited collection, The Sense of Sex: Feminist
Perspectives on Hardy (1993) – along with several considerations of ‘outsider’
Hardy (Lance St John Butler’s collection, Alternative Hardy [1989] and Joe
Fisher’s lively The Hidden Hardy [1992]) collectively shifted the critical focus.
Before that, despite Pamela Boumelha’s excellent work, Thomas Hardy and
Women: Sexual Ideology and Narrative Form (1982), Hardy studies were still
by and large dominated by major 1970s accounts – by Hillis Miller’s, Ian
Gregor’s, and John Bayley’s – and his work remained more starkly divided
between major and minor than that of any other novelist. Richard Taylor
countered this hierarchy in his The Neglected Hardy: Thomas Hardy’s Lesser
Novels (1982) but could not remove the labelling. Meanwhile, the poetry
(especially the 1912–13 poems) had been revived in Larkin’s The Oxford
Book of Twentieth-Century Verse (1973) and placed above the novels by Davie’s
Thomas Hardy and British Poetry (1973) – an assessment that became a
conventional wisdom in part because it suited the conservative strain in
1980s literary culture, and in English culture more broadly at that time.
John Goode’s Thomas Hardy: The Offensive Truth (1988) and George
Wotton’s Thomas Hardy: Towards a Materialist Critique (1985) helped prompt
the late 1980s and early 1990s challenge to critical orthodoxy about Hardy;
© Blackwell Publishing 2006
Literature Compass 4/1 (2007): 284–297, 10.1111/j.1741-4113.2006.00386.x