G Ital Med Lav Erg 2002; 24:1, 43-48 © PI-ME, Pavia 2002
www.gimle.fsm.it
C. Abbate, C. Giorgianni, F. Munaò
1
, C. Costa, R. Brecciaroli, M. Barbaro
Effects of noise on functional cardiovascular parameters:
a follow-up study
Department of Social and Territorial Medicine, University of Messina
1
Chair of Medical Statistics, University of Messina
Introduction
The relations between noise and effects on cardiova-
scular apparatus have been studied for long by numerous
authors, but often leading to different conclusions.
Some authors (1, 4, 6, 13, 18, 28) tend to deny a signi-
ficant relation between arterial blood pressure and noise,
whereas others (2, 5, 10, 24, 27, 36, 40) have reported an
increase both in systolic and diastolic blood pressure (SBP
and DBP respectively) in exposed populations.
The conclusions of different authors as regards heart
rate (HR) are not less discordant. Spinazzola et al. (30) and
Van Dijk et al. (37), in their reviews, report that various
authors attribute to noise a significant increase in HR; on
the other hand, Fogari et al. (10), in their cohort studies,
consider not significant the variations in the HR attributed
to acute exposure to noise; similarly, Amato et al. (1) and
others attribute to the pollutant no effect on this parameter.
Aim of this study is to search, by means of a follow-up
design, into the relations between noise and cardiovascular
effects.
Method
The sample was selected from a population of 8,263
employees with different qualifications in the oil chemical
area (refining, distribution of fuel and clerk), working for
5 different firms and thus undergoing periodical clinical
examination. A homogeneous sample was selected retro-
spectively, and the widest comparable group resulted to be
the one consisting of workers employed in this field at the
age of 23 years.
Therefore, given the wide size of the initial population,
our analysis focused only on this group in order to start
with a homogeneous sample.
The first selection criteria adopted were male sex and -
in order to simplify the statistical analysis - having been
engaged by the firm at the age of 23.
The population initially involved in the study consisted
of 1340 subjects.
The following exclusion criteria were then adopted to
select the sample, collecting information from clinical hi-
story and sanitary cards:
RIASSUNTO. Lo scopo del presente studio è quello di fornire un
contributo alle conoscenze sulle relazioni, a tutt’oggi controverse,
tra esposizione al rumore e funzione cardiovascolare. Si tratta di
un follow up eseguito su una popolazione di 757 lavoratori di
sesso maschile impiegati in cinque diversi impianti industriali del
ramo petrolchimico. I lavoratori selezionati sulla base
dell’esposizione al rumore, sono stati suddivisi in tre gruppi
omogenei a) impiegati (non esposti), b) autisti (esposizione
compresa tra 80-85 dBA) c) operai (esposizione superiore a 85
dBA). La popolazione è stata indagata attraverso la misurazione
della FC e della PA con cadenza trimestrale per una durata di 12
anni. Ogni sessione di misure era rappresentato da tre
rilevazioni settimanali. Dall’analisi dei dati emerge che tutti i
parametri osservati tendono ad un progressivo incremento
correlato con età ed anzianità lavorativa. Il confronto tra i
singoli parametri evidenzia che
1. la FC non risulta influenzata dall’esposizione al rumore;
2. la PA risulta invece significativamente differente tra esposti
e controlli;
3. la PAD risulta il parametro più sensibile all’esposizione al
rumore, riuscendo a differenziare anche i campioni di esposti.
In conclusione dai dati dello studio risulta che l’esposizione al
rumore influenza la pressione arteriosa, in particolar modo la
diastolica, mentre non sembra avere influenza sulla FC.
Parole chiave: rumore, pressione sanguigna, frequenza cardiaca.
ABSTRACT. www.gimle.fsm.it - The aim of this follow-up design
study is to give a contribution to the knowledge of the
controversial relations between noise and functional
cardiovascular parameters. The study population consisted of
757 male employees working for 5 different firms in the oil
chemical area (refining and distribution of fuel) with different
qualifications - 345 workers, 212 drivers, 200 clerks - and thus
exposed to 3 different levels of noise (85-90 dBA, 80-85 dBA and
<80 dBA respectively). Heart rate, systolic and diastolic blood
pressure were monitored 3 days a week at the beginning of the
working shift, for a period of 12 years.
The analysis of the data obtained indicates that all the 3
parameters under observation tend to increase progressively with
the age and working age of the subjects. In the comparison
between the 3 levels of exposure, heart rate results not affected
by the exposure to noise; systolic blood pressure results sensitive
only for the discrimination of the effects due to exposure,
showing a statistically significant difference only between clerks
on one side and workers and drivers on the other; diastolic blood
pressure is highly influenced by the level of exposure to noise,
showing significantly different slopes for the 3 groups.
In conclusion, blood pressure is a parameter definitely more
reliable for the correlation to the level of exposure, while heart
rate cannot be considered a marker of exposure to noise.
Key words: noise, blood pressure, heart rate.