496 | Healio.com/Psychiatry PSYCHIATRIC ANNALS 43:11 | NOVEMBER 2013
C M E
T
he health care burden of chronic
disability, with mental illness
and somatic symptom disorders
leading the way, is crippling to global
economies.
1
In the recent JAMA report
by the U.S. Burden of Disease Collabo-
rators, the top diseases with the largest
number of years lived with disability in
2010 were low back pain, major depres-
sive disorder, other musculoskeletal dis-
orders, neck pain, and anxiety disorders.
Migraine, drug use, alcohol use and dys-
thymia were also in the top 20. The au-
thors noted that half of the health system
cost is due to disability and morbidity.
1
Based on extensive research dur-
ing the past 20 years, psychotherapy is
now acknowledged to be an effective
and cost-effective treatment for a broad
range of conditions.
2
Given evidence
that psychotherapy is beneficial, the
relative cost of treatment has become
an important consideration in clinical
decision making.
3
With this in mind,
the shorter and less expensive a psycho-
therapy model can be while retaining ef-
fectiveness, the greater the effect it can
have on widespread health system costs.
Based on long wait lists and wait
times for long-term psychotherapy in
public clinics, Habib Davanloo, MD, of
McGill University developed his method
of intensive short-term dynamic psycho-
therapy (ISTDP) between the 1970s and
2000s.
4
Thus, two major reasons for this
development were to improve service
access and to reduce service cost per
patient in publically funded Canadian
medicine.
ISTDP is a brief treatment designed
to achieve broad-based gains across
symptoms and personality difficulties.
At its core, the objective of ISTDP is
to help patients overcome emotional
blocks that lead to occupational disabil-
ity, somatic symptoms, depression, anx-
iety, and self-defeating behaviors. The
method includes a specialized series of
interventions designed to overcome high
levels of resistance, low levels of emo-
tional tolerance (depression, somatiza-
tion, conversion), and dissociation (frag-
ile character structure). ISTDP has been
The Cost-Effectiveness of Intensive
Short-Term Dynamic Psychotherapy
1. Expose the reader to various
sources of health care costs and
diagnoses responsible for these.
2. Review the evidence for multiple
categories of cost reduction for
intensive short-term dynamic
psychotherapy (ISTDP).
3. Review the return-to-work rates for
patients receiving ISTDP treatment.
Allan Abbass, MD, FRCPC, is Professor
and Director of Education, as well as Di-
rector, Centre for Emotions and Health,
Dalhousie University Department of
Psychiatry. Jeffrey W. Katzman, MD, is
Professor and Vice Chair, Education and
Academic Affairs, University of New Mex-
ico Department of Psychiatry.
Address correspondence to: Allan Ab-
bass MD, FRCPC, Room 8203, 5909 Veter-
ans Memorial Lane, Halifax NS, Canada
B3H 2E2; email: allan.abbass@dal.ca.
Disclosure: Drs. Abbass and Katzman
have no relevant financial relationships
to disclose.
doi: 10.3928/00485713-20131105-04
EDUCATIONAL OBJECTIVES
C M E
Allan Abbass, MD, FRCPC; and Jeffrey W. Katzman, MD
© Shutterstock
Psychiatric Annals - Proof Copy